Navigating an Acquihire: Culture Transformation in the Retail Space by Katie Shire-Engleman
20:412022
A startup marketer in hoodies set out to change a 90-year-old grocer
On her first trip to Pittsburgh, colleagues put on suits and ties for the meeting, while she came from a world of Lululemon hoodies and Converse sneakers. Katie Shire-Engleman, who joined Giant Eagle through an acquihire from the startup Munchery and went on to lead its marketing, had to change a top-down family business without strong-arming anyone. How do you earn enough trust to shake the tree?
Learn how listening, quick wins and an open office turned a skeptical company toward change
Katie Shire-Engleman describes how she moved from a Silicon Valley startup, Munchery, into leading marketing at Giant Eagle, a formal, family-run, 90-year-old grocer, through an acquihire. In conversation with host Jenna Bowler, she argues that culture change in a traditional company depends on listening, building trust and delivering quick wins before pushing for transformation, and she shares the business results that followed.
“Giant Eagle historically has been a very, very top down culture. And it was important for the very top to see how successful it can be to just open up communication and get people to start talking because good ideas can come from anyone, just like bad ideas can come from anyone.”
“And one of the things that I found is that, you know, you never know who might be that influencer within the group, but you got to figure that out quickly because if you can connect with them and get their buy-in, you can start to turn the tide with a large group and it's not always the most senior person in the room.”
What you will learn
Start a culture change by listening to why past decisions were made, so you are seen as a partner rather than a disruptor.
Pick a visible quick win early to prove a new team's value to skeptical leaders.
Use a shared personality exercise such as Myers-Briggs to help a newly merged team understand how each member works.
Identify the informal influencers in a group and win their buy-in, even when they are not the most senior people.
Make your presence known in virtual meetings by asking questions and showing how you move the needle.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Fireside chat
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Mid-career
Length
20:41
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
How do you change the culture of a large traditional company after an acquihire?
Katie built trust first through active listening and relationships, then used quick wins and visible changes such as open seating to show a better way of working.
What should a new leader do in the first 90 days of a transformation?
She started by listening to understand why decisions had been made, then pitched a new ESP as a quick win to show key leaders she could make a difference fast.
How can you bring together a team assembled from different departments?
She asked everyone to leave their ego at the door and take a Myers-Briggs test, so people who had never worked together could learn how each other processes information.
Can you measure the impact of a culture change?
Katie points to divisions that once doubted digital marketing now spending mostly on digital, and a record sales year in 2021 that beat a pandemic year.
What advice would she give her younger self?
Ask the question, do not be afraid to speak up, and make sure your presence is known so you are memorable after a meeting.
VPs next to coordinators: opening a top-down culture (55 s)
If you offend one, you offend all (55 s)
Ask the question and make your presence known (68 s)
Welcome, everybody. Thank you for joining this session. Today, we are here to talk about navigating an aqua hire, culture and transformation in the retail space. And I'll just quickly introduce myself and then introduce our speaker here. So my name is Jenna Bowler, and I'm Director of Marketing at an enterprise software startup called Oceant. And I'm thrilled to be here today with Katie Shirer-Engleman, VP of Marketing at Giant Eagle, to talk about her journey navigating an aqua hire from her position as Director of CRM at a small tech startup called Munchery, to leading a marketing team of 60 at a multi-billion dollar privately owned company, Giant Eagle. Katie's background spending time at both large traditional retailers like Walmart, while they were moving into the e-commerce space and going through their own transformation, as well as tech organizations like Yelp, and then,
of course, startups like Munchery. Katie is now leading marketing and marketing transformation at Giant Eagle. Katie, thanks so much for being here with us today to share your story. Katie Shirer- Thank you so much for having me, Jenna. I'm really excited to be here to just share a bit more about the culture transformation that we've been undergoing at Giant Eagle, as well as just some of the experience I've had as a woman in leadership, especially in an organization that is very, very much known for being a little bit of an old boys club, which is the grocery space. So excited to be here to be here tonight. Katie Shirer- Yeah, absolutely. I mean, let's talk about that. So, you know, you transition from a Silicon Valley small tech startup to a multi-billion dollar private
company. I mean, can you just talk a little bit about how the culture was when you arrived, what the culture was like, where you were coming from, and a little bit of what that challenge was to transform? Katie Shirer- Absolutely. I think the culture that we had at Munchery, I mean, everybody that you were working with was in an open space with you. You kind of could just grab whoever you needed to work through a challenge. And Giant Eagle couldn't have been more different.
Katie Shirer- First off, you know, Giant Eagle is based in Pittsburgh. I'm in San Francisco. And just a far more formal organization, you know, 30 plus thousand team members. So a lot more structure. My very first trip to Pittsburgh, I will never forget. I had people like put suits and ties on to start the meeting. And I come from the world of Lululemon and like hoodies and Converse sneakers.
Katie Shirer- So a little bit of shock all around, but it's been such an incredible experience. You know, I've had a lot of experiences at very large companies like Walmart and Thermo Fisher Scientific, but also, you know, at smaller organizations. And this was the first time I was at a large privately held company. And so it's just been really incredible to watch how we've been able to bring some of what made startup life awesome, you know, being fast, being agile, you know, being hands on into a very structured corporate environment that was very agency first. I think one of the most transformative or shocking things that we brought to Giant Eagle was the idea that we didn't have offices at our San Francisco office. Nobody had a formal office, no walls. We have meeting rooms,
but like everybody sits with everybody. So you had VPs sitting next to coordinators. Giant Eagle historically has been a very, very top down culture. And it was important for the very top to see how successful it can be to just open up communication and get people to start talking because good ideas can come from anyone, just like bad ideas can come from anyone. So it was awesome to really just get everyone to be thinking differently about ways of working. And I'm really proud to share that, you know, the success of what we were able to show and a lot of that cultural mindset, then translated into a new office. Yeah. Called our tech annex in Pittsburgh. And that is completely open space. So a lot of exciting momentum to really just get people to start thinking differently about how to
work together. Right. Yeah. I love that. Not only building those, that muscle to communicate, but even changing the space physically so that people knew, you know, this is an open environment. This is where you can share ideas. I mean, that's amazing. And, you know, often when you see a startup getting acquired by a large, large company, it's the acquired company that's adapting to the larger organization's culture, their processes, their priorities. So, you know, you were asked to be part of the change coming from, you know, the smaller munchery startup into Giant Eagle. You must have undoubtedly face challenges, even though people wanted change, they wanted to transform. I'm sure there were challenges that you encountered along the way. So can you, can you talk about those more and tell us
more how you tackled them? Absolutely. And this has been such a huge part of the journey that I've been on. And I come from an environment that's very Silicon Valley focused, very data driven. And I'm used to that environment where like, you know, it's all about the numbers, it's all about the data. And if you don't deliver on that, well, there are 25 people behind you who are willing to take your job. And so it's really just about getting the numbers right. And that is very, very much not the case at a lot of these retailers. They needed far more relationship building. Giant Eagle is a family run organization. And so what was important for me to experience and start to open up to was kind of the softer side of business operations
that at times can get lost in Silicon Valley. And it's really been hugely beneficial in building that trust because change is really, really hard. Giant Eagle is a 90 year old grocer. They've been around for far longer than I have, and they were very established in what they do. And so to come in and try to shake the tree was not going to happen without building that trust and building that confidence, which, you know, it takes a bit of time. And so it required a certain amount of patience and collaboration and understanding that I don't think women always get in the workplace. And it became at times very uncomfortable to try to push my way into the room and figure out how could I be positioned as an ally, as someone that can be seen
as a viable partner without just, you know, strong arming my way through or, you know, without threatening people, which is such a frustrating position to be in. But this is where really using a lot of active listening and, you know, building relationships with those key people has been huge in my journey at Giant Eagle. And it's something that I don't know if we always focus as much on as we could within Silicon Valley.
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the company I work for is based in the Midwest. I'm based in Southern California. And so I too feel like there's a way to kind of take the best from both cultures, right, and create something new where you can leverage more data, like you said, like maybe leverage some of the ways of working or a fail first mindset or other things, but then merge that with the relationships, you know, family values or other things that might really hold and work well for the company or the culture that you're working with and figure out how do we kind of take from both, not just come in and change everything. So it sounds like you were able to do that too, which is, which is fun. That's really cool.
And I think that is so crucial during like a time like now where everyone is remote or at least in a hybrid model where, you know, you can work from anywhere, you can be anywhere. So you have no idea who you're going to encounter at any given time at any given day, you no longer have to live in the same city that you work. And so I fully expect some of those trends to continue to show that you're going to see people from all over the country, all walks of life coming together, whether it's retail, e-commerce, tech, whatever it is, everyone is in this remote working environment now. And it's more important than ever to figure out how to build those bonds and relationships through the screen.
Absolutely. Yeah. Culture, I think matters more than anything now, because what does give you that identity, if you're not walking into the physical space every day, if you're not seeing people, you know, in the break room, if you're not observing people, that's one of the things we talk about a lot too, is there's so much culture that can be observed in a way, just by how people, you know, behave or interact, or like you said, in offices, out of offices. And yeah, now it's our chance to do that more virtually. I guess I wanted to hear about some of the steps you took, Katie, because, you know, it was quite a journey. It was quite a challenge. You know, nothing's going to change on day one. I don't know if there's a 30, 60, 90 day plan that you can come up with to show that you're,
you know, changing an organization. So, you know, did you start first with your team? Did you work with the executive group? Like, what were some of the steps that you took to really bring about more transformation? Absolutely. And, you know, there's no one way to do something like this. When I came on board at Giant Eagle, there was actually somebody who already had my exact job. And so it was a little bit of a shock to her to have me come in with the same title, and we had to figure out how to work together. And one of the challenges at Giant Eagle is they are the largest employer in Pittsburgh.
And so if you offend one, you offend all because you're likely working with your, you know, with someone's neighbors, best friends, you know, dog walkers, cousin, you never know who knows who. It's a very community focused organization and incredibly connected. And so it, it was really critical to understand the lay of the land and then start to show short term wins. One of the first things we did was pitch a new ESP, which is not something that I would always recommend ripping out technology in your first 90 days. But I really wanted to show some key leaders that, you know, this is where I can make a difference quickly. Because having a team in San Francisco was 100% an experiment for Giant Eagle.
They'd never had a remote office before. So there was a little bit of skepticism around like, is this even a real thing? Like, are we really going to have a team 3000 miles away with, within marketing? And so, you know, focusing on what are our long term needs, and then what are those quick wins to build those relationships, and become more data driven and agile. And so we really looked at some of the technical capabilities at our MarTech stock. We also really looked at the media mix and started figuring out where we can modernize. But I think the number one most important thing I started with was just listening. You know, again, Giant Eagle had been around for 90 years. So it was really critical to
understand where they had started and why the decisions had been made a certain way, so that I could come in and be seen as a partner and not just a disruptor. When it came to my team, it was a mix of people that I was able to bring with me from Munchery as well as team members that I inherited from other departments. That was really, really scary for the group. I mean, it was literally people taken from all different areas and mushed together to create this new digital marketing team. People were confused. People were scared. And one of the first exercises I did with my team was a Myers-Bergs test.
I just said, everybody, leave your ego at the door. Let's do this. I'm going to share a bit about myself, how I think, how I process information, and I want you to do the same. And everyone had a lot of fun with it. You know, everybody loves to know which celebrity has the same personality that they do. And it just allowed for people who had never worked together before to start to understand, okay, this is how this new person that I need to partner with processes information and go from there.
Laura Lee: I think that's what's so key about what you said, Katie, that really resonates with me. I mean, all of it did. But one thing that really I wanted to highlight is putting your people first. You were listening. You know, you were trying to understand them as individuals, even though you were bringing about a digital-first skill set, data-driven, you know, mindset. It was really trying to understand the organization and how people could contribute, how people who, you know, needed to change and adopt new processes would fare with that, you know, discovering things about themselves. Like, I don't know. I feel like all of those are such great things to think about, how you worked with the people and listen to the people while also bringing forward technology.
Katie Grant: Absolutely. And, you know, it's very much one of those areas where you have to start to learn to read the room and read the environment. Like you can always tell when someone's like a little nervous or on the edge of their seat or not quite ready to open up. And one of the things that I found is that, you know, you never know who might be that influencer within the group, but you got to figure that out quickly because if you can connect with them and get their buy-in, you can start to turn the tide with a large group and it's not always the most senior person in the room.
Katie Grant: That's a really good point too. Like I found in my career that I used to be so focused on productivity. I want to get the job done. You know, I became a mother even more so wanted to be productive because I got stuff to do, you know, at home and have to juggle things. But this idea of really understanding how to socialize new ideas or processes and motivate people, that's such an important part of driving change. And I think that's something that, you know, a lot of women are good at. They're good at, you know, making connections, building the relationships, like you said, like listening, empathizing. A lot of times my meetings with male colleagues start with them telling me how their day
was telling me, you know, what's going on in their lives. And I'm not sure if that's how they connect with each other, you know? So I think I might have unique opportunities to learn more about people, which, which is cool. It makes the job, you know, more fun and helps you get to know people, which is great. So, you know, I wanted to give you a chance to, though, to talk about the data side. So you took these different steps, you know, you really learned and understood more about the organization. And there's plenty of research out there that talks about, you know, digital transformation and its impact on an organization's bottom line. But I guess I'm curious, were you able to measure the impact of
your cultural change and the cultural shift within marketing or within the company as a whole? Absolutely. None of this matters at the end of the day if there aren't results behind it. Relationships are key, but, you know, we're still a business. We still are here to make money. We've made some huge strides forward. We had some divisions that didn't believe in digital marketing when I came on board and their budgets are now at 95.5 digital to traditional. We also had a record sales year in 2021.
So the fact that we were able to exceed a pandemic year with the modernized media mix that I was able to really encourage and build that confidence with the organization, you know, the proof's in the pudding. And so the more that the organization began to trust me and my team, the more responsibility came our way, the more we were able to show those impactful results. And we've got a really exciting vision and future ahead for us. We're very focused on our MarTech and our ad tech capabilities. We're looking out, you know, what would it take to really go all in on a retail media network?
Obviously the cookies going away. We've got a lot of changes to privacy law and we're very fortunate at Giant Eagle where we have so much first party data. And I feel confident in saying that the organization would not be set up to make these next steps had we not been willing to invest in the people and the culture transformation that we needed to make to get more comfortable with doing things differently.
Exactly. I was going to say, it feels like you came in at a time when you were able to start this transformation. And then by the time the pandemic hit, people were probably so much more comfortable in connecting with each other because they knew each other better or they're open to adopting more technology or new things or shifting because they already went through that. So it's like the transformation that begets more transformation. And that mindset of being willing to change and adopt new things, it sounds like it's going to keep your team and the business going well into the future.
Absolutely. So I want to ask you one last question. I'm kind of like eyeing the time in the corner and we've got a couple minutes left. And this has been a great conversation. So thank you for sharing your tips and your insight. I wanted to do that thing where I say, you know, if you could look back and talk to your 25 year old self, you know, I'm sure there's some tips or advice that you would give.
So what would that be? What would you share with your younger self? What a great question. And what I would share with my younger self is to ask the questions. Don't be afraid to raise your hand and speak up. I think we've all had that moment where we might be sitting in the room and not necessarily feel comfortable raising our hand. Ask the question. If you have that question, I'm sure someone else does. And also make sure your presence is known, especially in this virtual environment where like, you know, people are just, there's no like sidebar or like, oh yeah, I'm on my way to this meeting. You should join me. You want to make sure that you are memorable when you walk out of the meeting, because our calendars are all so jam packed. Every minute matters and
every minute counts. And I have definitely had moments where I'm like, okay, we had all these people in this room. 90% of them didn't talk. Is this a value to people? So ask the question, don't be afraid to speak up and demonstrate where you are, you know, helping move the needle so that you are memorable from the conversation. Yeah. Make your presence known. I love it. Well, thank you so much for joining us, Katie. It's been a pleasure working with you in preparation and here on the stage today. For anyone joining, feel free to connect with us on LinkedIn. Both Katie and I are on LinkedIn and we look forward to seeing more great content at this conference. Thank you to all the organizers for
Women Tech and hope everyone has a good rest of their event. Thank you so much. It's been a pleasure. Bye. Bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
How do you transform a 90-year-old company's culture without strong-arming it?
Katie Shire-Engleman explains how listening, quick wins and trust helped a startup team change the marketing culture at Giant Eagle.
In short
Culture change in a traditional company starts with listening, not disruption. Katie Shire-Engleman, introduced in this fireside chat as VP of Marketing at Giant Eagle, describes how she arrived through an acquihire from the startup Munchery and helped a formal, top-down, family-run grocer open up, modernize its marketing and deliver measurable results. Her approach: understand the history, build relationships, win early and let results earn more responsibility.
Key takeaways
Start a culture change by listening to why past decisions were made, so you are seen as a partner rather than a disruptor.
Pick a visible quick win early to prove a new team's value to skeptical leaders.
Use a shared personality exercise such as Myers-Briggs to help a newly merged team understand how each member works.
Identify the informal influencers in a group and win their buy-in, even when they are not the most senior people.
Make your presence known in virtual meetings by asking questions and showing how you move the needle.
From hoodies to suits and ties
Katie came from Munchery, a startup where everyone worked in one open space and you could grab whoever you needed to solve a problem. Giant Eagle, based in Pittsburgh with more than 30,000 team members as she described it, could hardly have been more different. On her first visit, people put on suits and ties to start the meeting. Having worked at large companies such as Walmart and Thermo Fisher Scientific as well as smaller organizations, she says this was her first time inside a large privately held company.
One of the most shocking things her team brought was its San Francisco office, where nobody had a formal office and VPs sat next to coordinators. That model mattered because of where Giant Eagle started:
"Giant Eagle historically has been a very, very top down culture. And it was important for the very top to see how successful it can be to just open up communication and get people to start talking because good ideas can come from anyone, just like bad ideas can come from anyone." (3:50)
The idea spread: according to Katie, Giant Eagle went on to open a fully open-plan tech annex in Pittsburgh.
Trading pure data for patience and trust
Katie describes her Silicon Valley background as one where everything was about the numbers. At a family-run, 90-year-old grocer, she found that the softer side of business mattered far more. She also notes that the grocery space is often seen as something of an old boys club, and that the patience and collaboration the role demanded is not something women always get in the workplace.
"And so to come in and try to shake the tree was not going to happen without building that trust and building that confidence, which, you know, it takes a bit of time." (6:26)
The tools she leaned on were active listening and building relationships with key people, positioning herself as an ally and viable partner rather than forcing her way through. Host Jenna Bowler adds that the goal is to take the best of both cultures, combining data and new ways of working with the relationships and family values that already work, especially now that so many teams build bonds through a screen.
Listening first, then a quick win
Katie arrived to find someone already holding her exact job title, and a company that, as the largest employer in Pittsburgh, was deeply interconnected.
"And so if you offend one, you offend all because you're likely working with your, you know, with someone's neighbors, best friends, you know, dog walkers, cousin, you never know who knows who." (10:40)
She needed to understand the lay of the land and then show short-term wins. Her team pitched a new email service provider early on, something she admits she would not always recommend in the first 90 days, because a marketing team 3,000 miles away was a real experiment for Giant Eagle and leaders were skeptical. Alongside that, the team reviewed its marketing technology and its media mix. Yet she is clear about what came first:
"But I think the number one most important thing I started with was just listening." (11:35)
Bringing a scared, merged team together
Her new digital marketing team combined people she brought from Munchery with people inherited from other departments. People were confused and scared. Her first exercise was a Myers-Briggs test: she asked everyone to leave their ego at the door, shared how she thinks and processes information, and invited them to do the same. It gave people who had never worked together a way to understand their new partners.
She also stresses reading the room and spotting the people who shape opinion:
"And one of the things that I found is that, you know, you never know who might be that influencer within the group, but you got to figure that out quickly because if you can connect with them and get their buy-in, you can start to turn the tide with a large group and it's not always the most senior person in the room." (14:14)
Proving it with results
For Katie, relationships are the means, not the end.
"None of this matters at the end of the day if there aren't results behind it. Relationships are key, but, you know, we're still a business." (16:13)
As she cited, some divisions that did not believe in digital marketing when she joined now spend their budgets overwhelmingly on digital, and the company had a record sales year in 2021, exceeding a pandemic year. As trust grew, so did her team's responsibility. She now looks ahead to marketing and ad technology, a possible retail media network and the use of first-party data as cookies disappear, and she credits the people and culture investment with making those next steps possible.
Her advice to her 25-year-old self closes the conversation: ask the question, speak up, and make sure you are memorable when you leave a meeting.
Watch the talk
Navigating an Acquihire: Culture Transformation in the Retail Space, with Katie Shire-Engleman (21 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/navigating-acquihire-culture-transformation-in-retail-space-katie-shire-engleman-0
About the speaker
Katie Shire-Engleman was introduced in the session as VP of Marketing at Giant Eagle, where she leads a marketing team and its transformation after joining from her role as Director of CRM at the startup Munchery. Her background spans large retailers such as Walmart, tech organizations such as Yelp, and startups.
Questions this talk answers
How do you change the culture of a large traditional company after an acquihire?
What should a new leader do in the first 90 days of a transformation?
How can you bring together a team assembled from different departments?
Can you measure the impact of a culture change?
What advice would she give her younger self?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Myers-Briggs (MBTI)
30-60-90 day plan
Cite this talk
WomenTech Network. "Navigating an Acquihire: Culture Transformation in the Retail Space by Katie Shire-Engleman." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/navigating-acquihire-culture-transformation-in-retail-space-katie-shire-engleman-0