Technology for the Care Economy: Are you prepared for the Silver Tsunami? by Chia-Lin Simmons
21:562022
Medical alerts have barely changed since "I've fallen and can't get up"
A fall alert worn by an 85-year-old woman misfires as she sits down in an Oakland ramen restaurant, shouting to ask if she is okay, and she stops wearing it. Chia-Lin Simmons, a 26-year tech veteran leading a turnaround at medical alert maker LogicMark, argues that aging tech has stalled for decades just as the silver tsunami arrives. What would care technology look like if it were built for older people and their caregivers?
Learn the design principles she says aging tech needs, from wearability to fall prediction
Chia-Lin Simmons argues that technology for older adults and their caregivers has barely evolved since the 1980s medical alert era, even as an ageing population and a caregiver shortage converge into a "silver tsunami". She outlines what the next generation of care technology must do: be attractive enough to wear, detect falls accurately using more data, connect isolated health data to predict falls, and serve caregivers through layered protection.
“They're not dead. They want to wear things that are attractive.”
“So they're actually quite more technically savvy than we give them credit for.”
What you will learn
Explain the silver tsunami as the convergence of an ageing population, a caregiver shortage and the wish to age at home.
Recognise why traditional medical alert devices and mass-market smartwatches both fail older users.
Apply the idea that wearability drives adherence when designing health devices for older adults.
Plan fall detection that combines more data points, such as altitude, distance and sound, beyond speed and tilt.
Evaluate care products against a caregiver-centric, connected and multi-layer protection model.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
Founder, Mid-career, Executive
Length
21:56
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is the silver tsunami?
It is the rapid ageing of the baby boomer population, with people over 65 projected to nearly double and, as the speaker cited, more than 23% of the US population aged 65 and over by 2030. It converges with a shortage of in-home caregivers and a strong wish to age at home.
Why have medical alert devices failed older people?
Traditional personal emergency response companies focus on services, marketing and monitoring, source their hardware from other industries and have not advanced fall detection. Their devices look medical and their fall alerts misfire, so people stop wearing them.
Why aren't consumer smartwatches the answer for older adults?
Products like Fitbits and smartwatches are designed for a wide age range and the mass market. They do not account for older users' manual dexterity, safety needs or battery life.
How can fall detection become more accurate?
By adding data beyond the accelerometer and gyroscope, such as barometric altitude, distance travelled and sound. This helps distinguish sitting down too quickly from a real fall.
What should the future of care technology look like?
Simmons describes a caring platform as a service built on wear, connect and care: attractive devices people want to wear, shared rather than isolated data, fall prediction, a caregiver-centric design and multi-layer protection involving AI, family, call centres and emergency services.
The fall alert that screamed in a ramen restaurant (69 s)
Design devices older people actually want to wear (65 s)
Smarter fall detection needs more than speed and tilt (66 s)
Thank you so much for attending. And I want to just go ahead and launch very quickly into who I am and to talk a little bit about sort of technology for the care industry and the upcoming tsunami. And so my name is Shailene Simmons. I've been working in the tech industry for about 26 plus years. I'm currently the CEO of a company called Logicmark.
We are one of the largest providers of medical alert personal emergency response systems in a market today for and serving a number of clients in that particular space. And so probably what seems really unlikely is if you look at my background that how I would have ended up in a company industry and a company that services daycare economy that in for all intents of life.
And for all intents and purposes, I'll sort of launch into this as well and talk a little bit about sort of aging, aging tech as well, and how I ended up there. So I spent most of my career in a number of sort of early stage companies from pre-C to Series D, as well as having served a couple of years as a public company executive at a number of different companies. And so prior to this, I had a early stage pre-C to series D, as well as having served a couple of years as a public company executive at a number of different companies. And so prior to this, I had a early stage pre-C to AIML company.
And I had a early stage pre-C to AIML company. And I was actually working of all things in a retail space, building AIML for recommendation for clothing of all things. And so how did I sort of end up in this particular space? Yeah. And how did I end up with a company where I was, I've been for the last year doing a turnaround for the company. And to be serving a company whose corporate mission is radically different than the company I was at, which was to basically help women make better decisions and help the industry save money.
But to something that is basically speaking to protecting the personal experiences of living life to the fullest. And so a lot of it has to do with probably what many of us had gone through during COVID, which is, you know, COVID changed a lot of things for a lot of people. And so what I was seeing was, like many people, my personal journey was not unlike so many of us who are in this particular industry. In fact, one in four millennials and more than half of Gen Xers, of which I am one of those, is we're part of something called the sandwich generation.
So that means that we're in the midst of the global pandemic and working and doing all those things, we're actually helping to take care of our young ones, as well as faced with actually caring for our elderly parents or other loved ones at a time when we weren't really able to be near them. And in many ways, this day had already been, that sort of, that day has already come for me anyway, because I had lost my own parents and was in a process of actually helping to care for my mother-in-law remotely and constantly sort of worried about whether or not she was doing okay and whether or not she's fallen.
And so I'm sharing some stats here because this is always something that astounded me so much when I first joined this company and while I was doing research to join this company, which is that, in fact, one in four out of people 65 and over actually fall and less than half tell their doctors. And once you fall once, your chances of falling actually doubles, right?
And so that's a heck of a lot of people. And so, you know, that fall actually has great implications in terms of the business that I'm in today and when we talk about the care economy, because when most of the time when we look at this particular industry, we don't actually help people within the first hour of them having an incident.
Their outcomes are actually 80% worse, you know, when you don't find them within the first hour. That means if they broke a hip and you don't find them until three hours later, their outcomes for recovery is much worse. And this other piece kind of astounded me as well. In fact, that basically death rates increased 30% and there's like seven fall deaths like every hour by 2030, which is just a very scary thing, especially as we're going through COVID.
And so when this company came to look for a turnaround CEO, it really made me pause and think about what was happening in the care economy. And most importantly, what were the things that were happening in terms of changing demographics and why it was so important? And so, you know, as we look at what's happening here, and one of the research that I delve into, and I'm sure a lot of you guys are doing the same thing whenever you look at taking a new role, which is, you know, you look at what I call the three-legged stool of success, right?
You look at, you know, does this company have great people? Does it have great products and IP? And then there's always this sort of third piece of the ephemeral pieces. Is it, you know, the right timing for the company? Is the demographics and product market fit timing right? It's the piece that's always a little bit more challenging that you have to dig into a little bit more as well.
And so what really astounded me was that, in fact, you know, the silver tsunami was actually not only coming, but was really already upon us. When we talk about the silver tsunami, it's really about the stats I'm sharing with you today. You know, baby boomers are aging, and so 65, you know, people over 65 are projected to nearly double.
And so actually by 2030, more than 23% of our population in the U.S. alone will be 65 and over. And so, you know, along the correlations to this is that not only are, you know, our population aging, but in fact, more and more of us were actually taking care of them, the one in four millennials again, and the more than half of Gen Xers.
And this population, you know, has been poorly served or underserved by the technology industry for a very long time, despite the fact that if you look at the data here, that they actually are comfortable with technology. 65%, you know, 61% of them actually own smartphones. You know, 75% of them actually use the internet. So they're actually quite more technically savvy than we give them credit for.
And when we talk about the care economy overall, and not just look at the silver tsunami portion of it, in fact, actually one in four adult Americans live with a disability. And so there are people who require a little bit additional assistance potentially as well. And so that figure actually was a major part of a changing demographic that we're facing, but one that somewhat snuck upon a lot of people when we look at it from a tech industry perspective.
In my career in 26 plus years, I spent a lot of my time in what we have all termed as emerging technology, doing connected cars in 2010, before, you know, all the Teslas and connected vehicles were really part of the mass market. Doing early days of cell phones in 2005, when really only 35% of Americans own cell phones.
And so when I looked at this particular market, when we talk about the care economy, as well as most importantly, the portion of the care economy that's focused towards the elderly, it's one that when we look at technology, they have not actually had a tremendous amount of success. And that doesn't seem to be a good situation. And when we look at the data, again, you know, 60% of all Americans over 50 want to age at home.
And so this is actually even pre-COVID. And so, again, pre-COVID as well, the sort of aging at home population labor shortage has been already in the works prior to 2020 when COVID hit upon us. And so by 2040, we're going to have a shortfall of caretakers for folks who are in-home caretakers. And what we found was that as an industry, in fact, that industry pre-COVID had a 50% turnaround, which means every time you hire, 50% of those people are going to turn over every time.
And so that means for every caretaker, they may actually start, you know, getting into a situation where they're trending towards, instead of taking one, you know, one person taking care of 10 people who are aging at home, they may be looking at one in 20. And so these decisions about sort of technology that they utilize and this very strong interest in aging at home all sort of converge into this silver, you know, tsunami, a growing aging population, a shortage of labor, and a situation in which potentially more of us might be isolated at home as well and be far apart from our loved ones kind of converge into a situation where it's a little bit of a perfect storm for a situation where technology could really step in and actually emerging and better technology could step in into an industry, again, that sadly has not done very well.
So for those of you who have grown up in the U.S. in the 80s, this may have been the ad that you might have seen with that very catcher phrase that we all know, help, I fall and I can't get up. And in fact, this is actually the sort of the meme that came out of the medical alert company called LifeCell in 1989.
And so since then, you know, I wish I can tell you, in fact, that things have changed in this particular industry. That on the top there, made by Bosch, is the product that basically LifeCell utilized in 1989. What you will see to the right of that is something called the LifeAlert, which is actually the modern day, quote unquote, equivalent of that particular product.
And so and what you see in the bottom, I'm sorry to say, is one of the early products that our company had. We've been around since 2007. And so our products, while maybe a little bit tiny, bit less antiseptic looking, probably hasn't evolved as much as well before I joined the company last year. And so that means that as a whole, actually, this is not unusual, what we're seeing here in this screen.
In fact, the technology hasn't truly evolved in the 20 plus years that since the early days of this sort of health monitoring and medical alerts monitoring space. And so they came out of the home monitoring service with a call center that monitored your home. And so they had these very rudimentary and medical looking devices that you would wear and you would push that button if you fall.
And the modern sort of aspect of it that they add was something called, you know, fall alerts, right? Except that these fall alerts actually don't work very well. And case in point was my mother-in-law wore one of these devices. And so, you know, she was sitting down a little bit too quickly and tilted a little bit because some of these devices, much like your iWatch, iWatch is using the same technology.
She sat down, accelerometer, gyroscope, sat down a little bit too quickly and tilted. She was 85, you know, so what can I say? She was at a ramen restaurant with me in Oakland. And immediately this device that she was wearing around her neck, which looks kind of like a small remote control, very unattractive, went off and said, Mrs. Becker, are you okay?
And it's screaming at the top of its lungs at a very, very popular restaurant. She was embarrassed and she didn't really want to wear it anymore. And so when we look at that and we think, why can't we do better? But the reality is, is that we could do better. Because the traditional PERS industry, I call it the I've fallen and can't get up business, has sort of still the old school technology products operated by very similar people.
And typically their business is not a little bit less about the technology aspect, but the services and the marketing aspect of things and the monitoring aspect of the business. And so the technology hardware and software typically tends to be sourced by other industries. And so, and then they haven't really evolved the technology. They haven't advanced really too much of the file detection technology.
And that's sort of where the current marketplace sits to the traditional sort of business. And then we've got what I call the quantifiable self-space, right? Which is, you know, the Fitbits of the world and the iWatches of the world and the Pixel Watches of the world. And so they're designed for wearables for people who are as young as 10 or 12 to supposedly a product that would help for people who are older, who are 65 or older.
And so, you know, that development of a hardware product and software that would basically cover that larger range of consumer businesses, when we know that on either end of the extremes, the manual dexterity of that particular user may not be as good as somebody who is between the ages of, you know, maybe 15 to 55. So it's become sort of an issue where this quantifiable self-space product is really great for the mass market, but is it not necessarily good for the aging population from a safety use perspective, from a battery life perspective, and any one of those things.
And so, and that's the current marketplace, which is either we were going to get these old school products that doesn't really have the most bleeding edge technology that would actually help with detecting falls or actually predicting falls even to something that is maybe really great at having some level of fall detection, But it really isn't designed with an older person in mind or even a younger person in mind, a super young under 10, right?
And so that's really the care economy as we stand today when we look at especially the silver tsunami that's coming. So when we look at that, what does the future say? And I really would love to have this opportunity to talk with you guys a little bit more about this. But we see the future as what we call caring platform as a service or a CPAS system where you wear, connect, and you care.
And the reality is that today when we look at the industry, it's incredibly factored and sort of self-isolated as a data sort of experience. We are collecting blood pressure data and every blood pressure monitor product now has an app and they collect the data. And then you have that data in isolation or you have your Fitbit and has some level of blood pressure or steps.
And again, has an app and sits in isolation. And so, and that's great. And so when we look at that, when we look at sort of connected data, one of the things that we think needs to happen in the future is that, yes, everything needs to be connected. It's my third bulletin, but it cannot constantly sit in an isolated data pod.
They actually have to interact with each other or be able to be shareable in order for it to be actionable. And, but first and foremost, I mean, the thing that I always keep in mind is that you have to design something for wearing. Like pharmaceutical companies and the way they think about sort of adherence, you know, they talk about it's great that you have access to Provacol.
You want to be able to actually make sure that people are taking that drug that they're supposed to be taking so that they can actually have the best health outcome. In our particular case, you know, you have to design things that people want to wear. And we are talking about the boomer generation that has large incomes. They have taste.
They're not dead. They want to wear things that are attractive. Why should they be looking at wearing this? This is horrible. So shouldn't we be designing things that look beautiful, like an iWatch or anything that you would want to wear in your body? Because wearing it equals adherence for health, right? But if they don't want to wear it, you're not going to be able to get fall detection.
Secondarily, better fall detection is absolutely crucial. When we talk about that, everything from a device perspective today utilizes accelerometers and gyroscopes, speed and tilt. We think that there is a better sort of way to look at data. For anybody who is interested in AI ML, you know that more than two points of data is required to basically make better predictions.
You need three points plus, right? And so for us as a company, we're absolutely interested in this because we actually own a patent for barometer. Being able to tell basically from an altitude perspective, if you're going from here to here at a speed and tilt, this could be just that you're sitting down too quickly because the distance isn't quite a fall.
And so you want to be able to actually pull together data such as distance along with speed and tilt or distance, speed, tilt and sound. Because if you crash and you fall, that sound is different than if you sat on a chair or something like that, right? Better fall detection is necessary because if it goes off and you're not falling, you're interested in wearing it.
Again, going back to bullet one from an adherence perspective is absolutely less. And so we think that, again, if you think about sort of where the future of the technology needs to be for those who are aging and the silver tsunami that's coming ahead, we also want to see prevention. So all of this data sitting in pods and isolated pods not working together means that we cannot help to look at predicting falls that's coming.
We believe that if you look at some of this data and you look at the way that people are moving and their gait and their sort of predictability in terms of how their movements are in terms of a daily sort of usage, we can actually look at doing things like digital twins where people of similar patterns had a fall incidence.
So we might be able to actually help deal with predicting a potential fall incidence and being able to communicate that to not just, you know, myself or anyone who's a loved one who's caring for, you know, parents and so forth, but also to professional health care takers as well. Data will actually help us make better predictions. And that's what we need as a future for aging tech, but also needs to be care centric, caretaker centric.
Today, when our parents need help, that sort of suddenness comes upon us. And so we're seeing a lot of caretakers pulling things together at the last minute because these things don't work well together. Again, isolated data and so forth. And so technology in a future for taking care of this silver tsunami and those we love need to be actually much more caretaker centric because those are the people who need to help have that data.
And finally, we believe in what I call the multi-layer protection and it takes a village perspective. You know, it used to be that people lived with larger family sets and so there are neighbors who help each other and we no longer can have that. COVID also taught us that as well. And so we need that multi-layer protection of having AI, having family, having a call center, having 911 to know that our loved ones, even if we're far apart, we're far apart from them, have the capability to get help with, you know, for whatever needs that they have.
And that, you know, as a platform or as a service that we can actually connect, not just that sort of initial consent, like circle of, you know, people who can care for our loved ones, but potentially we can extend it to village for people that we're sharing a platform with to actually help us out as well, the classic sort of village experience.
And so we live in a social world today. You know, it's a high probability that we can actually do that as well. And so that's some things that we really think about when we think about sort of the coming tsunami and where the care economy needs to go. And so that's the end of my presentation. And I would love to take a few minutes to answer any questions that people might have.
How about hearing technology advancements other than hearing aids? Absolutely. Yeah. So I think that's a really interesting thing. And we think a lot about that. I mean, today, actually, it's fascinating when we dig into this aging technology space where we're actually seeing folks who are getting out of hearing aid technology because all of us are wearing like earpods today.
Right. And that sort of enhancement of sound, the isolation of a crystal clear sound from talking and being able to sort of block out what stereotypically hearing aids do, which is that sort of the white noise of restaurants and so forth. Those we think are in absolute sort of development. In fact, I know three other companies and have invested in one as an angel investor myself in terms of basically increasing hearing technology.
And ironically, it's not just for the aging as well, because as we sort of as a population have sort of adapted to our environments, because of constancy and so forth, we're actually seeing some bits of hearing loss a little bit earlier than one would expect. And so that sort of hearing technology, we're seeing a tremendous amount of a caring economy as well.
Please feel free to email me if you guys have any questions. I know that I only had 20 minutes and I wanted to sort of open that up if you guys had any Q&As. But if not, feel free, please, to contact me any time. And I look forward to chatting about this topic with everyone. So thank you so much for your time.
I appreciate it.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why aging tech must be designed for wearing, prediction and caregivers
Chia-Lin Simmons explains why medical alert technology has stalled for decades and what care technology needs to become as the population ages.
In short
Chia-Lin Simmons argues that technology for older adults has barely moved on since the 1980s "I've fallen and I can't get up" era, even though an ageing population and a caregiver shortage are already colliding. Her answer is a caring platform built on three verbs, wear, connect and care: devices people actually want to wear, fall detection that uses richer data, and connected information that helps caregivers predict and prevent falls.
Key takeaways
Explain the silver tsunami as the convergence of an ageing population, a caregiver shortage and the wish to age at home.
Recognise why traditional medical alert devices and mass-market smartwatches both fail older users.
Apply the idea that wearability drives adherence when designing health devices for older adults.
Plan fall detection that combines more data points, such as altitude, distance and sound, beyond speed and tilt.
Evaluate care products against a caregiver-centric, connected and multi-layer protection model.
A personal route into the care economy
Simmons describes a career of more than 26 years in technology, much of it in early-stage companies and emerging technology, from connected cars to early cell phones. Before joining a medical alert company to lead a turnaround, she was building AI and machine learning recommendations for clothing in retail. What changed her direction was personal. Like many people during COVID, she found herself part of the sandwich generation, and she was caring for her mother-in-law remotely while worrying whether she had fallen.
The fall statistics she found while researching the role stayed with her. As the speaker cited, one in four people aged 65 and over fall, fewer than half tell their doctors, and a first fall doubles the chance of another. Timing matters most of all: "Their outcomes are actually 80% worse, you know, when you don't find them within the first hour." (3:53)
The silver tsunami is not coming, it is here
Before taking any role, Simmons applies what she calls a three-legged stool of success: great people, great products and IP, and the harder question of whether the timing and demographics are right. On timing, the evidence was overwhelming. She cites projections that people over 65 will nearly double, that more than 23% of the US population will be 65 and over by 2030, and that 60% of Americans over 50 want to age at home.
At the same time, she notes a growing shortfall of in-home caregivers and an industry that, as the speaker cited, had 50% turnover even before COVID. Caregivers could move from looking after ten people to twenty. Yet older adults are not the technophobes they are often assumed to be: "So they're actually quite more technically savvy than we give them credit for." (5:57)
An industry stuck in 1989
Simmons shows how little medical alert devices have changed since the famous 1989 LifeCall advert. The modern equivalents, including her own company's early products, still look rudimentary and medical. She is candid about where the problem lies: "Because the traditional PERS industry, I call it the I've fallen and can't get up business, has sort of still the old school technology products operated by very similar people." (11:25) These firms focus on services, marketing and monitoring, and source their hardware and software from other industries.
Her mother-in-law's experience makes the cost concrete. While sitting down a little too quickly at a popular ramen restaurant in Oakland, her pendant's fall alert misfired and loudly asked whether she was okay. Embarrassed, she no longer wanted to wear it.
On the other side sit what Simmons calls quantified self products, such as Fitbits and smartwatches. They are built for a huge age range and the mass market, not for the manual dexterity, safety and battery life needs of older users. The result is a market split between outdated alert devices and consumer gadgets that were never designed with older people in mind.
Wear, connect, care
Simmons proposes a caring platform as a service, and she starts with design. Borrowing from how pharmaceutical companies think about adherence, she argues that a device only protects someone if they wear it. Boomers have income and taste: "They're not dead. They want to wear things that are attractive." (15:44)
Second comes better fall detection. Today's devices rely on accelerometers and gyroscopes for speed and tilt. Simmons argues that more data points make better predictions, pointing to her company's barometer patent, which can tell from altitude whether a movement is really a fall. Adding distance and sound helps distinguish a crash from simply sitting down, which in turn reduces false alarms that discourage people from wearing devices.
Third is connected data and prevention. Health data today sits in isolated pods, one app per blood pressure monitor or fitness tracker. If that data could be shared, she suggests, gait and movement patterns could feed approaches such as digital twins to predict falls before they happen: "Data will actually help us make better predictions." (17:55)
Finally, the technology must be caregiver-centric and offer multi-layer protection. Families often scramble when a parent suddenly needs help, so tools must serve the people coordinating care. Simmons describes layers of AI, family, call centres and emergency services, extending to a wider "village" of people who can help when loved ones live far away.
Beyond hearing aids
In the brief Q&A, Simmons points to hearing technology as another area of active development. Earbud-style products that enhance and isolate sound are moving into territory once reserved for hearing aids, and she notes she has invested in one such company as an angel investor. She adds that hearing loss is appearing earlier than expected, so this market reaches beyond older adults.
Watch the talk
Technology for the Care Economy: Are you prepared for the Silver Tsunami? by Chia-Lin Simmons (22 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/technology-care-economy-are-you-prepared-silver-tsunami-chia-lin-simmons-0
About the speaker
Chia-Lin Simmons says she has worked in the tech industry for more than 26 years, across early-stage companies and as a public company executive. In this talk she describes leading a turnaround as CEO of LogicMark, a provider of medical alert personal emergency response systems.
Questions this talk answers
What is the silver tsunami?
Why have medical alert devices failed older people?
Why aren't consumer smartwatches the answer for older adults?
How can fall detection become more accurate?
What should the future of care technology look like?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Three-legged stool of success
Caring platform as a service (wear, connect, care)
Multi-layer protection
Digital twins
Cite this talk
WomenTech Network. "Technology for the Care Economy: Are you prepared for the Silver Tsunami? by Chia-Lin Simmons." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/technology-care-economy-are-you-prepared-silver-tsunami-chia-lin-simmons-0