How wearables can bridge the healthcare gap for women while ensuring data privacy
Stacy Salvi18:322023
Sent home for a panic attack, she actually had meningitis
In 2000, ER doctors told a young woman with stomach pains and hay fever symptoms to go home and relax. It was a rare strain of meningitis. That woman was Stacy Salvi, now VP Strategy at Movano Health after eight years at Fitbit, and she asks whether a wearable's longitudinal data could have changed what clinicians saw, and what it takes for doctors to trust that data.
Learn the four hurdles wearable data must clear before doctors can use it to treat women better
Stacy Salvi, VP Strategy at Movano Health, argues that wearable technology can help close the quality of care gap for women, whose symptoms are too often downplayed by clinicians. Drawing on her own near-fatal misdiagnosis and studies on cardiac care, she sets out what wearable data must deliver to be useful to doctors and users: medical-grade accuracy, relevant metrics, shareability and simple, actionable insights designed for women from the ground up.
“Had we not pushed back on the hospital staff that day, I probably wouldn't be here.”
“One of my favorite things to say to our team is that, while we can provide our users with a salad bar of data types, we also need to tell them a recipe that tastes good to them.”
What you will learn
Recognize how women's symptoms are downplayed in care, especially in cardiac emergencies where their symptoms differ from men's.
Check wearable health data against four requirements clinicians need: medical-grade accuracy, useful analytes, shareability and digestible delivery.
Turn raw sensor readings into actionable insights users can apply in daily life, rather than adding more metrics.
Design health products for women from the ground up, testing with diverse users instead of simply sizing down.
Address privacy early by building data protection into product features, not only into policies.
Key takeaways from the speaker
How wearables can bridge the healthcare gap for women
The importance of medical-grade data in a wearable device
Simplifying data with actionable insights
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
18:32
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why do women receive a lower quality of care?
Clinicians downplay women's symptoms more often than they should, which Salvi links to unconscious bias and gaps in training. In heart disease, women's symptoms differ, so they may be told they have anxiety or acid reflux and treatment is delayed.
What must wearable data offer before doctors can use it?
It must be medically accurate, focus on analytes doctors care about such as hypertension and blood glucose, be shareable (first as a PDF, eventually through EHR integration) and be digestible at a glance to avoid metrics fatigue.
Why does wearable adoption lag?
Manufacturers race to add sensor readings, creating a mountain of data users cannot act on. Salvi argues products must connect the dots and tell users how to act on the data.
Could wearable data affect mental health care?
A wearable cannot tell your mood, but mood is shaped by sleep, activity and stress, and logging how you feel alongside passive data can help people check in with themselves over time.
How is the Evie ring designed for comfort?
As a medical device it goes through fit and feel testing across a diverse set of hands and fingers, and its open design flexes slightly to accommodate swelling.
About this talk
At Movano Health, we are designing a health wearable with women in mind, focusing on specifically addressing their unique health needs. Keeping women at the forefront of every product & UX decision is critical to deliver a product that can not only help make women healthier, but also bring them an experience that they will enjoy using. To get there, we continuously engage with a diverse set of women to better understand what we should prioritize. Sometimes these unique needs or insights are at odds with what’s been done before, the easiest path forward, or the most cost-effective option. However, we continue to invest in features and designs that will deliver a product different from anything on the market.
Through our own research with consumers, we’ve heard the following about what they feel is currently an opportunity in the wearables space, and we’re using these findings to determine our product roadmap going forward:
- Health data privacy and security has never been more important to women, so ensuring users’ data is encrypted and de-identified is key to building trust with our consumer.
- Women are looking for more personalized and timely insights from her device that help uncover the “why” behind what she’s feeling. We are building algorithms that deliver better insights and at just the right time, so the user gets the information most relevant to her and helps her understand her overall health.
- Consumers are looking for more reliable and accurate data so they can trust what they are learning about their health, which is why we are delivering medical-grade information across all our metrics.
- We are also designing a beautiful smart ring that’s not a complete circle, allowing for some flex to be more comfortable and accommodate swelling throughout the day.
Misdiagnosed as a panic attack: it was meningitis (78 s)
Four hurdles wearable data must clear for doctors (73 s)
Salad bar of data, but where's the recipe? (58 s)
Stacy Salvi: Hello there, everyone. Nice to see you all today, or at least virtually see you. My name is Stacy Salvi, and I'm speaking to you today from the Movano Health office here in the Bay Area, California. If you haven't heard of us, we are the makers of the EV ring, as this beautiful woman is wearing here in the picture, and I'll show you more pictures later as well.
Stacy Salvi: And, of course, I'm really excited to be here today and grateful for the opportunity to speak with you. It's honor an honor to be presenting alongside such an impressive group. Stacy Salvi: So I want to talk to you all about a topic that is near and dear to my heart, and that is how wearable technology can help close the quality of care gap for women.
Stacy Salvi: I was fortunate to study this topic alongside some tremendous researchers while at Fitbit and during my time at Google. And now that I'm at Movano Health, we spend our days helping people learn more about their bodies through purpose driven innovation and health care. Stacy Salvi: First, though, I want to start us off with a story. This is a story about a young woman who almost lost her life because multiple clinicians.
Stacy Salvi: We made some quick judgments about some symptoms that she was experiencing. Stacy Salvi: We may not think of women as underserved in health care, but this story exemplifies how women may be dismissed by medical professionals and how, in some cases it may have dire consequences. Stacy Salvi: Her combination of indications included severe hay fever like symptoms and stomach pains. Initial diagnosis by a nurse and multiple ER doctors was that she was having a panic attack and just severe allergies.
Stacy Salvi: She was sent home and told to relax. But despite this advice, she and her mother returned to the ER. Something just wasn't right. Stacy Salvi: Fortunately, this young woman's mom who isn't a doctor advocated beyond the assumption that what was going on was stress induced. Stacy Salvi: And as it turns out, this was a rare strain strain of Neisseria meningitis.
Stacy Salvi: And you probably guessed already that this story isn't about somebody from the latest episode of Grey's Anatomy. This is a true story that happened to me in the year 2000. Stacy Salvi: Had we not pushed back on the hospital staff that day, I probably wouldn't be here. Stacy Salvi: I narrowly avoided some serious complications of my oncoming sepsis, including heart or organ failure or paraplegia.
Stacy Salvi: I was critically unstable for 36 hours and had a coronary catheter inserted into my heart to watch for potential heart attack as my body was showered with bacteria. Stacy Salvi: I'm sharing my story with you all because while it may be anecdotal, it is an all too common example. Stacy Salvi: I'm going to walk you through several stories and studies showing disparities in care for women.
Stacy Salvi: And you know it stems from unconscious bias and insufficiency within training itself, but it happens and so it's important that we can talk about it. Stacy Salvi: So pose the question what may have happened that day if I had walked into the ER bolstered with data from a wearable device could my blurry set of symptoms come into focus speeding along the administration of tests, or at least created the space for further inquiry.
Stacy Salvi: Could the power of proof led to a quicker diagnosis and avoidance of nine days in the hospital and three months of recovery, I believe so. Stacy Salvi: The reality is downplay the symptoms felt by women more often than they should, resulting in a lower quality of care. Stacy Salvi: This happens across the board and it is more prominent for women of color.
Stacy Salvi: The statistics I want to share today are from summary studies and I don't want to gloss over the inequities felt by communities of color. Stacy Salvi: But for the purposes of this presentation, the statistics will be blended. Stacy Salvi: Women experience a reduced quality of care in a multitude of ways from pain management to heart health preventative medicine, all the way to the emergency room.
Stacy Salvi: Heart disease is the number one cause of death for women in the United States, more than all forms of cancer. Stacy Salvi: Top four forms of cancer combined. Stacy Salvi: This fact is not widely known. Stacy Salvi: One study revealed that only 41% of lay people are aware of the high morbidity of women due to heart disease.
Stacy Salvi: But what's more concerning is that only 22% of primary care physicians and 42% of cardiologists feel well prepared to assess a woman's cardiovascular disease risk. Stacy Salvi: We also know that within cardiac distress, women are at risk more than men, simply because their symptoms are different. Stacy Salvi: Women may be told that they are suffering from anxiety or acid reflux.
Stacy Salvi: This delay of treatment has serious consequences. Stacy Salvi: In a study out of the University of Leeds, which looked at almost 700,000 cases over a 10 year span, the provision of guideline indicated care resulted in unnecessary deaths. Stacy Salvi: One example of a gap in care includes a metric known as door to balloon time. Stacy Salvi: Those precious minutes from when a patient enters the ER until they are sent to a catheterization lab.
Stacy Salvi: Men are inherently rushed to this more quickly than women. Stacy Salvi: As the researchers discovered, had proper treatment or tests been ordered in the same time as they had for men, more than 8000 lives of those study could have been saved. Stacy Salvi: Modifying the approach with women in mind could save lives and change outcomes.
Stacy Salvi: Fortunately, we live in a time where we're starting to uncover these biases in science and medicine. Stacy Salvi: And hopefully soon we can make the necessary course corrections, but still there's a lot of work to be done. Stacy Salvi: And this is where, as researchers and technologists in the wearable space, we have a real opportunity.
Stacy Salvi: But by designing with purpose and empathy we can ensure that wearable products and their commensurate services can help shore the gaps in care. Stacy Salvi: So let's talk through how we can help. Stacy Salvi: First and foremost wearable technology can enable a stronger doctor patient relationship by facilitating a conversation. Stacy Salvi: We've talked a lot about it from the user's perspective or patient's perspective, but in this case I want to look at the advantages of wearable data from the doctor's point of view.
Stacy Salvi: Today, a primary care physician may see her patient probably came into the doctor just having searched Google with possible symptoms. Stacy Salvi: I know i'm guilty of that once a year for an annual checkup. Stacy Salvi: They might take labs, but her view of what's going on with her patient may be limited to a singular moment.
Stacy Salvi: If wearable data could be incorporated into a practice for snapshot view becomes three dimensional knowing what is happening before and after the patient is in the office. Stacy Salvi: And in fact, we know that doctors agree insider intelligence reports that an overwhelming majority of clinicians 83% plan on incorporating personal device data into their practice over the next 10 years.
Stacy Salvi: To get there, though, we have wearable sensor data has some hurdles to overcome. Stacy Salvi: First, it needs to be accurate. Stacy Salvi: This one is probably almost too obvious to mention, but I have to say it anyway. Stacy Salvi: We're dead in the water without medical grade accuracy. Stacy Salvi: Sure, some trend level data is useful, but accuracy must prevail here.
Stacy Salvi: Second, wearable sensors must focus on useful analytes. Stacy Salvi: Medscape published a study in this area and doctors indicated that they would be most interested in hype and data related to hypertension blood glucose and others. Stacy Salvi: Third data must be shareable. Stacy Salvi: Initially, this can take on the simplicity of a PDF, but eventually we do need to integrate into EHRs.
Stacy Salvi: Undoubtedly, this is a heavy technical lift and expensive, but so long as patients understand the benefits and provide proper consent, we can provide clinicians with a window into patient well being outside of their office. Stacy Salvi: Finally, the data needs to be delivered in such a way to accommodate the time constraints of modern healthcare. Stacy Salvi: This means it must be digestible and clear at first glance to avoid metrics fatigue.
Stacy Salvi: For EV, of course, we as a new product on the market, we have our eye on adoption. Stacy Salvi: And wearables have been around for a long time. Stacy Salvi: We understand that the user has an expectation of what a wearable can do, and that's relatively set. Stacy Salvi: But adoption lags in wearables because they're not always connecting the dots for user users and here's what I mean by that.
Stacy Salvi: Today wearable devices do an excellent job at bringing awareness through data, but sometimes and I know that this is even true for me. Stacy Salvi: I've been in this business for quite a long time. Stacy Salvi: I'm not sure where to look. Stacy Salvi: It seems that wearable manufacturers are racing to beat one another in the sheer quantity of sensor readings.
Stacy Salvi: The result is that this data has quickly become a mountain that we can't get our arms around. Stacy Salvi: One of my favorite things to say to our team is that, while we can provide our users with a salad bar of data types, we also need to tell them a recipe that tastes good to them.
Stacy Salvi: It's not enough to simply see the data we need people to understand how they can act on that data in their daily lives. Stacy Salvi: And to do that we must build our services with empathy and diversity from the ground up. Stacy Salvi: By testing with a diverse audience, bringing these groups into an experience that is tailored to them, we can earn their trust and be a dependable resource where they may not have been in the past.
Stacy Salvi: I challenge my team on a daily basis to consider this in their daily work. Stacy Salvi: This, of course, means going beyond sizing down and actually designing products for those who menstruate and particularly given that these groups have been excluded from scientific and medical research in the past. Stacy Salvi: And we need to address concerns around privacy upfront early and in an understandable way by not only maintaining lock type policies around data sharing, but also enabling product features that keeps data private and secure from the outset.
Stacy Salvi: So that brings us to Evie. Stacy Salvi: At Mavano Health, our aim is to bring purpose driven healthcare solutions to consumers. Stacy Salvi: We believe that making our wearables medical grade will deliver on the promise that users can lead healthier lives. Stacy Salvi: Evie isn't retrofitting an existing platform to be medical grade, it is medical grade from the outset.
Stacy Salvi: Personally, I feel fortunate to have joined a company that shared my belief that health is a fundamental human right. Stacy Salvi: And more importantly, that we're at an achievable intersection to make med tech to consumer accessible for people as possible. Stacy Salvi: The roadmap has a core focus on delivering wearables that empower users with an easy and fun to use service that keeps them engaged for the long run.
Stacy Salvi: The longer the user is with us, the more health benefits she will see. Stacy Salvi: This human centric design considers the experience from many angles, including psychosocial considerations on the front end and a relentless pursuit of accuracy on the back end. Stacy Salvi: This combination is powerful for evie and I believe for the wearables market in general, as we consider the potential health impact we all have on the health and well being of our users.
Stacy Salvi: So I want to take us back to the story we talked about at the beginning. Stacy Salvi: Of course, I do not want to compare what happened to me to the inequities felt by many communities in this country and around the world. Stacy Salvi: And reflecting back on my case, it did present with mixed indications so it's understandable that clinicians couldn't pinpoint immediately what was going on.
Stacy Salvi: The hospital couldn't rely on patient history because at that time patient data wasn't readily available. Stacy Salvi: And I was out of state state and out of network, they could only see really what was right in front of them a singular moment in time. Stacy Salvi: Consider though if I had come to them bolstered with longitudinal data from the prior days or even months, the hospital staff could have gotten a more objective read on what was happening with my body.
Stacy Salvi: Before I stepped into the ER, perhaps they could have seen a gradual increase in my respiration rate over previous days from PPG and spo2 sensors. Stacy Salvi: Or an alarming and unusual spike in my resting heart rate or increased dehydration of a previous days leveraging by impedance algorithms. Stacy Salvi: And maybe if we were to consider all future sensing possibilities increased white or red blood cell count, all from a small ring wrist-based wearable or patch.
Stacy Salvi: Today wearables do a great job at celebrating daily progress. Stacy Salvi: The apple watches iconic rings or haptic feedback on a Fitbit when I hit my 10,000 steps. Stacy Salvi: Each have made their mark on this industry and I see them being carried forward for years to come. Stacy Salvi: This positive feedback has made steps a currency and ingrained in our culture in incredible ways.
Stacy Salvi: And this is really just the beginning. Stacy Salvi: I predict that as sensors get more advanced and smaller and thus more wearable, we're going to see a ton of progress in this area over the next five to 10 years. Stacy Salvi: Wearables can enhance healthcare, but by being both a clinical companion and accelerate us to a future where people can get the care that they need.
Stacy Salvi: Thank you all so much for having me today I truly appreciate it i'm more than happy to answer any questions if we still have time. Stacy Salvi: I think I still have six minutes to go. Stacy Salvi: Oh okay so I got a question it's from liz and she asks do you feel this this data from wearables could affect the mental health industry.
Stacy Salvi: So I actually do certainly I think it's a little bit unrealistic to say that a wearable could tell you the mood that you're in. Stacy Salvi: But mood is impacted by so many different things like sleep and activity and other stress factors that are going on with our bodies. Stacy Salvi: So if wearables and their you know commensurate companion apps can be used to log certain information around how we're feeling whether that's positive or negative.
Stacy Salvi: I definitely see that as an ability to to gather data from a mindfulness perspective. Stacy Salvi: I think sometimes you know it's it's so important that we just check in with ourselves to know how we're feeling. Stacy Salvi: There are so many different times at least in my life I can speak personally about this where you know sometimes I am not feeling great over.
Stacy Salvi: Several weeks and it's really good to check in and kind of know what's been going on. Stacy Salvi: So I definitely see wearables playing a part through both passively collected data, but also you know what's worn on the body. Stacy Salvi: that's a great question, thank you so much. Stacy Salvi: Are there any other questions.
Stacy Salvi: Okay, the comfort of the ring so the description of the talk, this is from Deborah the description for the talk mentioned comfort of the ring have you tested with users under varying conditions carrying groceries washing hands. Stacy Salvi: yeah so that's a great question. Stacy Salvi: So we're we're only speaking maybe somewhat obtusely about it because we're still pre launch.
Stacy Salvi: But absolutely you know usability testing is certainly part of what we're doing here. Stacy Salvi: Because we are building the hardware itself to be a medical device we're required to do all levels of testing from you know fit and feel. Stacy Salvi: How it's fitting across, you know, a diverse set of hands and fingers. Stacy Salvi: So absolutely we are checking the checking on the comfort of the ring and one of the things that we are working on is making sure that the ring is it is an open currently an open design, and so it can flex ever so slightly, which helps accommodate for swelling in the body, which is really nice actually.
Stacy Salvi: And. Stacy Salvi: Well, thanks Deborah Deborah says thanks so. Stacy Salvi: Well, this is definitely my favorite topic, if you would like more information about the ev ring ev ring.com is where you can find it please sign up on our. Stacy Salvi: Our mailing list so you can hear more about it, but more generally you know this is just something that we're working really hard on every day here and something I very very passionate about and really excited to bring to market.
Stacy Salvi: Wonderful well I am going to sign off now and give you all a couple minutes back. Stacy Salvi: Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Could wearable data stop doctors from dismissing women's symptoms?
Stacy Salvi of Movano Health explains why medical-grade, women-first wearables could help close the quality of care gap for women.
In short
Stacy Salvi, VP Strategy at Movano Health, argues that wearables can help close the quality of care gap for women by giving clinicians objective, longitudinal data instead of a single moment in an exam room. For that to work, she says, wearable data has to be medical grade, focused on what doctors need, shareable and simple enough to act on, and the products have to be designed for women from the start.
Key takeaways
How wearables can bridge the healthcare gap for women
The importance of medical-grade data in a wearable device
Simplifying data with actionable insights
A story that almost ended differently
Salvi opens with a case: a young woman with severe hay fever like symptoms and stomach pains, diagnosed by a nurse and several ER doctors as having a panic attack and severe allergies, then sent home and told to relax. Her mother, who is not a doctor, insisted something was wrong. It turned out to be a rare strain of meningitis, and the patient was Salvi herself, in 2000.
"Had we not pushed back on the hospital staff that day, I probably wouldn't be here." (2:13)
She spent 36 hours critically unstable, nine days in hospital and three months recovering. Salvi is clear that her case is one example, but she uses it to frame the question that drives the talk: what if she had walked into the ER carrying data from a wearable device?
The gap in care women face
Salvi argues that clinicians downplay women's symptoms more often than they should, and that this is more pronounced for women of color, although the statistics she shares are blended. As the speaker cited, heart disease is the leading cause of death for women in the United States, yet one study found only 41% of lay people know this, and only 22% of primary care physicians and 42% of cardiologists feel well prepared to assess a woman's cardiovascular risk.
Because women's cardiac symptoms differ from men's, they may be told they have anxiety or acid reflux. She points to a University of Leeds study of almost 700,000 cases over ten years, which, as she cited it, found that if women had received tests and treatment as quickly as men, more than 8,000 lives could have been saved. Door to balloon time, the minutes between entering the ER and reaching the catheterization lab, is one measure where men are rushed through faster.
"Modifying the approach with women in mind could save lives and change outcomes." (5:27)
What doctors need from wearable data
Salvi shifts the view from the patient to the physician. Today a primary care doctor sees a patient at a single moment; wearable data could make that snapshot three dimensional by showing what happens before and after the visit. She cites Insider Intelligence reporting that 83% of clinicians plan to incorporate personal device data into their practice over the next ten years.
To get there, she sets out four hurdles. The data must be accurate. It must cover useful analytes, and she cites a Medscape study in which doctors showed most interest in data on hypertension and blood glucose. It must be shareable, starting with something as simple as a PDF and eventually integrating with electronic health records, with proper patient consent. And it must be digestible at first glance to fit the time constraints of modern healthcare.
"We're dead in the water without medical grade accuracy." (7:22)
From a mountain of data to a recipe
As a new entrant, Movano Health is focused on adoption, and Salvi believes adoption lags because wearables are not connecting the dots for users. Manufacturers race to add more sensor readings, and even she, after years in the business, is not always sure where to look.
"One of my favorite things to say to our team is that, while we can provide our users with a salad bar of data types, we also need to tell them a recipe that tastes good to them." (9:20)
That means building services with empathy and diversity from the ground up, testing with diverse audiences, and going beyond sizing down to design for people who menstruate, groups historically excluded from scientific and medical research. It also means addressing privacy early and clearly, through product features that keep data private and secure, not only through data sharing policies.
Designing Evie and looking ahead
Movano Health's Evie Ring is built to be medical grade from the outset rather than retrofitted. Salvi describes a roadmap centered on an easy and fun service that keeps users engaged, since the longer a user stays, the more health benefit she sees, combining psychosocial considerations on the front end with a relentless pursuit of accuracy on the back end.
Returning to her own story, she imagines what longitudinal data could have shown: a gradual rise in respiration rate, a spike in resting heart rate or growing dehydration in the days before she reached the ER. She predicts major progress over the next five to ten years as sensors get smaller and more advanced.
"Evie isn't retrofitting an existing platform to be medical grade, it is medical grade from the outset." (10:38)
In the Q&A, she says wearables cannot read mood directly, but sleep, activity and logged feelings can help people check in with themselves. She also explains that the ring is tested for fit across diverse hands and uses an open design that flexes to accommodate swelling.
Watch the talk
"How wearables can bridge the healthcare gap for women while ensuring data privacy" by Stacy Salvi, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-wearables-can-bridge-healthcare-gap-women-while-ensuring-data-privacy
About the speaker
Stacy Salvi is VP Strategy at Movano Health, where she leads commercial product and go-to-market strategy, drawing on more than 15 years of experience leading strategy across partnerships, product development and company growth. Before that she was Head of Strategic Partnerships for Fitbit at Google, where over eight years she helped launch nearly 20 products to more than 116 million users, both as an attorney and from within the product team.
Questions this talk answers
Why do women receive a lower quality of care?
What must wearable data offer before doctors can use it?
Why does wearable adoption lag?
Could wearable data affect mental health care?
How is the Evie ring designed for comfort?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Door-to-balloon time
Human-centric design
Resources mentioned
Evie Ring website and mailing list
Cite this talk
Stacy Salvi. "How wearables can bridge the healthcare gap for women while ensuring data privacy." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-wearables-can-bridge-healthcare-gap-women-while-ensuring-data-privacy