HealthTech Innovation and Its Impact on Health Equity
Laura MacMillan19:392022
A gender field sounds simple until it meets 1,400 practice databases
In a study the speaker cites of about 5,000 patients, 56% of LGBTQ+ respondents had been refused care or mistreated, and afterwards they were seven times less likely to seek care. Laura MacMillan, UX Research Manager at Zocdoc, brings trans and non-binary patients' stories straight into product decisions. So why can't a booking platform just add a gender field to its sign-up flow?
See how research, engineering and an ERG are rethinking sign-up for trans and non-binary patients
Laura MacMillan, UX Research Manager at Zocdoc, shares research with LGBTQ+ patients about being dismissed, misgendered and forced to educate their providers. She then shows how turning those findings into a more inclusive sex and gender sign-up flow collided with patient matching, HIPAA risk and practice management systems built on decades-old assumptions, and why the effort is still worth it.
“So really what this talk is going to be about is how building health health tech within our complicated healthcare system is difficult and thorny and absolutely worth it.”
“So, you might hear people use the terms LGBTQ plus friendly, but I want to make a distinction between friendly and competent or knowledgeable.”
What you will learn
Recognize how negative care experiences lead LGBTQ+ patients to hide their identity or avoid doctors altogether
Distinguish LGBTQ+ friendly care from care that is knowledgeable, experienced and affirming throughout the whole journey
Involve an employee resource group in research and design to widen perspectives and improve copy
Anticipate how legacy integrations, patient matching and HIPAA risk constrain inclusive data fields
Write form copy that says what you are actually asking for, such as sex for clinical use
Key takeaways from the speaker
What are the systemic issues leading to the lack of equity in healthcare, and at what scale?
What is the scale of the current challenges we face in healthcare?
What is the impact of continuing to ignore the inequities in the healthcare system?
How is Zocdoc leveraging its platform to increase health equity and build trust within the health system?
How will Zocdoc leverage its platform in the future to create a safer, more accessible, and inclusive patient experience?
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:39
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why do LGBTQ+ patients often have lower expectations of healthcare?
Many have been refused care, misgendered, dismissed or blamed, so they hide their identity or avoid follow-ups, which harms their health outcomes.
What is the difference between LGBTQ+ friendly and LGBTQ+ knowledgeable care?
Knowledgeable care is specific and informed, such as offering PrEP and blood work in one facility or knowing current trans healthcare practice, and it affirms identity at every step from intake forms to front desk.
Why can't Zocdoc simply remove sex from its sign-up flow?
Practice management systems use sex for patient matching, which prevents duplicate records and keeps existing patient records from being overwritten, a HIPAA concern.
Why is adding a gender field technically hard?
Every practice management system stores data differently; many lack a gender field, those that have one use different categories, and notes fields carry other data and have character limits.
What did Zocdoc's ZocPride ERG recommend?
Ask for what is really needed, sex as listed on medical insurance or health records, with a tooltip explaining it is sex for clinical use, rather than sex assigned at birth.
About this talk
Laura MacMillan, UX Researcher Manager, will break down some of the systemic issues in healthcare that prevent all patients from receiving equitable treatment and quality of service. These healthcare divides have massive ripple effects that lead to exponentially different healthcare outcomes which leads to a lack of trust in healthcare. We’ll discuss the sizing of the problem and how we’re leveraging, and will leverage our platform to build trust with all patients to improve healthcare outcomes.
So thanks so much for joining this meeting. I know there are a bunch of different talks happening simultaneously. So I really appreciate the folks who decided to join this one. I'm Laura MacMillan. I am the UX research manager at Zocdoc. So the official title of this talk as we submitted it to the conference is health tech innovation and its impact on health equity.
So that's not all that specific. So really what this talk is going to be about is how building health health tech within our complicated healthcare system is difficult and thorny and absolutely worth it. And I want to share some of the research my team has done with LGBTQ plus patients and the solutions we're working on to help illustrate some of these difficult and interesting problems. So before I dive in, I just want to give a shout out to many of the colleagues that I worked with on this project over time from different departments. It was a massive group effort. So just want to say this was not my work alone by any means.
So to start off, what is Zocdoc? I think that will probably make this whole presentation a lot clearer. Zocdoc is the leading healthcare marketplace. So each month, 6 million patients across the country visit our site to search and book appointments with in-network providers. So we offer appointments with over 200 kinds of specialties and we also offer both in-person and video visit appointments.
In using our site, you can browse reviews, see availability, and also book appointments. So to kind of understand how we work, you can think of Expedia offers booking for flights. Restaurants are bookable through sites like OpenTable. Booking.com allows you to book hotels. This is really how you can think about what ZocDoc does for doctor's appointments. It's patient initiated, directed, and it's free for patients as well.
So now that that's behind us, I want to quickly introduce a piece of technology that I think makes ZocDoc special, our synchronizer software, which we internally call FonWay Sync. So we have providers from thousands of practices across the country on our platform, all of whom use different software called practice management systems or PMSs to track their own schedules and maintain patient records.
So when practices join ZocDoc, they need a way for practices and patients to kind of communicate about schedules, which is really where the ZocDoc synchronizer technology enters the picture. So our Sync software reads a practice's database of availability, allowing ZocDoc to display that availability to patients. So you can think of this as when you call a doctor's office to make an appointment, you hear all the times that they have available.
That's essentially what this technology does, taking that information about all the appointment times and displaying it to you on our website. Of course, there are different levels of sophistication when it comes to these Syncs. I don't want to overcomplicate it too much, but some write these appointments back into the practices software. Some are more manual, but the basic concept stands.
And there are thousands of these practice management systems. We integrate with roughly 1,400 of them. They're all different. We have an amazing team at ZocDoc whose job it is to make sure those integrations run smoothly. So I'll do my best to kind of describe how that works as we move through the presentation. But one at a level set, you understand some of the basics of ZocDoc and one piece of our technology that's going to be really crucial to the story later.
So let's go ahead and get into the research. So at ZocDoc, one of our core values is that we always start with our patients first. So if I can very gently critique my own company to some extent over the years, ZocDoc has really optimized our services. But sometimes we're focused on the average patient, the average provider. But we know that not all patients are treated equally and have equal experiences and outcomes in health care.
So we needed to better understand the experiences of some of these groups of patients. And by addressing these needs, we can help to avoid perpetuating some of the same problems that the health care system has at large. So in order to do that, we start by listening to them. That's my disposition. That's my field is user research.
So we'll share some stories and takeaways from those interviews. But first, I wanted to share a little bit more context on why this is important. So in a study of about 5000 patients, 56% of LGBTQ plus respondents have experience being refused care, providers refusing to touch them or using abusive language, being blamed for their own health status or providers being physically rough.
Perhaps not surprisingly, after experiencing this, they're seven times less likely to seek care in the future. So this has huge ripple effects in terms of health experiences and health outcomes for these populations. So with the help of our ZocDoc team, we spoke with participants in the LGBTQ plus community, learning about their health needs, the qualities they seek in a doctor and how their identity has affected these experiences.
Of course, these are stock photos that you're looking at. So I'm going to be sharing real stories and real perspectives from patients. But because I'm sharing with you all, with this external audience, I'm really careful to use stock photos and obfuscate the quotes to protect the research participants. Something that was really exciting about this project is that in order to conduct these interviews, I work with other members of our employee resource group for LGBTQ plus folks, which is called ZocPride.
So I identify as queer and I'm trained as a researcher and interviewer, but it was important for me to bring in broader perspectives. So by kind of training up some members of our team on some of the basic basics of interviewing, we were able to increase the perspectives we had. And one important definition before I get into the findings, when I refer to sex, that refers to a person's biological status, which is typically categorized as male, female or intersex.
So for example, gender really refers to gender, gender really refers to identity characteristics of personal identities that are socially constructed. So without further ado, digging into some of our research findings. One theme that we heard across the board is that LGBTQ plus patients often will have lower expectations for their health care experiences. And sometimes this leads to not disclosing their identity or avoiding the doctor altogether.
One patient often doesn't tell doctors he's trans because he finds providers who were previously not misgendering him will start doing so when they learn this about him. We heard from one non-binary trans patient who has avoided going to follow-ups for a life-threatening issue, which is a pulmonary embolism or a blood clot, because they felt really dismissed and disparaged by that doctor.
There's also a sense that LGBTQ plus patients have to educate their providers. They have to be experts on their own health issues. Often providers are not experts. So one trans man told us a story. He was having heart issues. He knew or was pretty sure that it was symptoms of high testosterone levels. He went to the doctor, asked them to test him for it.
The doctor accused him of abusing the ER, the emergency room, for hormone therapy. Eventually, he was able to convince them to call another doctor with experience with trans patients who tested his levels and, yes, found that his testosterone levels were completely off the charts. They were dangerously high. Another trans woman told us a story about foot pain.
She had gone in for surgery. She also happens to be HIV positive. When she disclosed her status, the doctor actually denied her surgery that day. So you can understand with these experiences, patients are really going to seek out inclusivity and more affirming experiences. Sometimes, you know, some practices that are not specifically LGBTQ plus affirming can offer inclusive care.
Absolutely. One patient, a trans woman, she told me this story. She really lit up when she told this, that she saw a dermatologist who wasn't at a queer clinic, but just a dermatologist she found online. Who knew to ask her about how her hormone therapy might be affecting her skin and that really brightened her day. However, a foolproof approach or slightly more foolproof approach is going to an LGBTQ plus focus clinic.
One patient told us about going to a clinic in D.C., Washington, D.C., where he knows he can get PrEP easily. PrEP, if you're not familiar, is a treatment for reducing your chance of getting HIV. Another goes to a clinic in Austin where they know they will be asked for their pronouns. A lot of the staff is queer.
They feel a lot of comfort when they go there. And I want to drill a little bit into some of the kind of nomenclature that we're using here. So, you might hear people use the terms LGBTQ plus friendly, but I want to make a distinction between friendly and competent or knowledgeable. So, LGBTQ knowledgeable care is going to be specific and informed.
So, one patient expects LGBTQ knowledgeable care to offer easy access to PrEP and blood work in the same facility. Those two pieces go hand-in-hand as part of treatment. In other facilities, you might have to go to two places, but understanding the ins and outs of, in his case, healthcare for gay men, this is a way to feel affirmed, knowing you can get both of those done in the same facility.
And then also talking about being informed. So, another patient, a trans man, expects providers to read up on literature, go to conferences. His example was, you will strike me as being trans knowledgeable if you know that a new practice in healthcare, in trans healthcare, is to inject hormones under the skin, rather than into the muscle. So, that's a way for him to know that.
It's also experienced and welcoming. So, one patient really hopes that the providers that she goes to will have seen many trans patients, that she won't be the first one. It won't feel like she's kind of being looked at under a microscope. And then, especially for our non-binary and trans patients, the importance of the entire experience addressing their identity.
So, one trans non-binary patient talked about the process of mentally preparing themselves, psyching themselves up before going into the doctor. And that sometimes when they go into the doctor, they, because of being misgendered or being deadnamed, which refers to a provider using their name that they were given by their parent at birth that they no longer use.
So, when that happens to them, they will disassociate, they'll forget what's happening during their appointments, which you can imagine, it's not ideal for outcomes when you don't have a good recollection of what the doctor told you. So, to affirm this person, they're looking for getting pronouns correct throughout the entire process, from intake forms to the front desk staff, to the medical assistant, to the systems that track the information.
So, we learned so much from this research. What do we do next? Where do we, where do we start? So, there are a number of initiatives that we, as an organization, have been working on, but I want to talk about one piece in particular, a focus area, which we look to revisit the sex and gender options we have for patients in our sign-up flow to make them more expansive and inclusive.
Why did we start here? This is an area of our product that already exists. So, we knew the way we were handling this was not ideal, not just through this research, but through feedback we've gotten online, through our amazing customer service team. And this research that I just took you through only reinforced the importance of getting this right.
Setting expectations, making patients comfortable from the start is absolutely paramount. So, we actually did another round of research, much more focused and honed in this time, with non-binary and trans patients, getting their impressions of our existing sign-up flow, what it's like to create a ZocDoc account to book appointments. We tested the sex assigned at birth copy that we asked patients to fill out, and a new proposed tooltip to explain why we were asking for it.
We learned a lot, but just to quickly summarize, patients appreciated this tooltip. I have it highlighted here in red that kind of explains why we're asking for it, but ultimately, it just wasn't enough. One patient who's non-binary described it as, look, gender needs to be a part of this. If you provide sex or sex assigned at birth, you still have to provide the other.
You have to ask gender or pronouns. And, you know, sex assigned at birth, what does that mean? Are we talking about my genitalia? Are you talking about my experience moving through the world? Which kinds of providers and which kind of specialties would even need to see this, right? So opening up a lot of questions. So, okay, so easy, right?
We know that we need to ask patients for their gender. Let's just slap on a gender field in our sign-up flow and call it a day, right? Easy. Of course, it's not so simple. So we led a brainstorm as a cross-functional group, talked about a few different ways for how we could treat sex and gender in that sign-up flow, listing out the pros and the cons and the unknowns of these paths.
One simple, you might call it elegant solution would be to just remove sex entirely from our sign-up and booking flows. We learned in discussing with our engineering team who leads our sync integrations that PMSs, those practice management systems, use sex as an input to something called patient matching. So in our more sophisticated sync products that book ZocDoc appointments directly into a practice's systems, key pieces of a patient's information, including sex, are matched against the existing patients in that practice's database.
That matching does two things, ensures that a new patient record isn't created in a practice's system if there already is a record of that patient, that patient's been there before, or that an old patient record in the practice's system isn't overwritten by this new ZocDoc booking. So you can imagine they're both bad, one sort of from a logistics perspective, and especially the second from a HIPAA perspective, we don't want to be rewriting into patient's records.
So this is really, really an area where we have to tread lightly and make sure we're executing with a lot of care. Okay, so starting to understand how hard and how complicated these things are. So what if we keep sex as a necessary field to fulfill this requirement, but just add a gender drop down. So bringing back our practice management systems, continuing to complicate things that I mentioned earlier, these kind of come into play here.
So every PMS is different and stores information differently. Some have a gender field, in addition to a sex field, many don't, and even those that do have a gender field, have different gender categories. So an interesting historical note, many PMSs are built off some of the original technology of electronic health record systems that began to be developed back in the 70s.
So you get some of the notions from that time around identity that are kind of baked into the databases themselves. So many of these are adapting and changing, but it's not a universal change across the board. So we needed to get further into the weeds of a technical solution. How could we use the information available to us within the PMS to make sure a patient's gender is captured and then properly sent to the practice?
So not every PMS has a gender field, as I mentioned, but they typically do have a generic notes field. So one solution could be to pass the gender into that notes field. Simple, easy, right? But because of limitations within these pieces of software, the notes field is used for some other important information like patient insurance. Also, for other complicating things, a lot of PMSs have character limits.
So the team was concerned that the notes field might actually cut off additional gender information if we were to pass that through. So what's really exciting and really was was such a wonderful thing about this project is that the team actually dedicated the time, put aside the time to research all these products that we integrate with to get an estimate of how often gender could be passed through this through this notes field.
And from preliminary research from the team, it seems like the majority of the time they could be passed along. So that's a really great sign. Meanwhile, while some of this work was going on, we also consulted with our employee resource group, Zoc Pride, who gave some really great recommendations on how to improve the experience while we do research on the larger changes to gender.
So if you think about what we're really asking for in the signup field, it's really just asking for what sex is listed on the patient's medical insurance or patient health record for that matching requirement. It's not really sex assigned at birth because sex assigned at birth doesn't always match the patient's actual record. In the case of trans or non-binary patients, they may have actually changed their legal sex.
So Zoc Pride's recommendation is say what you're actually asking for, update this to sex with a explanatory tooltip saying, look, this is sex for clinical use. It's going to be the one listed on your medical insurance or your health records, just to give that clear definition to be inclusive of our trans and non-binary patients. So to wrap up, we have a few directions we're exploring.
One is a product I haven't mentioned to you all yet. It's a product called Intake, it allows practices to upload their own medical and demographic forms, and many of these forms are becoming more inclusive, so it'll be clear to patients when they fill these out which practices are going to be a little bit more inclusive. The other directions are the ones that I've mentioned, so working on that signup copy and further refining how we can successfully capture gender.
So I know we're just about a time here, it really does wrap up what I wanted to share with you all today, but a few pieces of housekeeping: ZocDoc will be in the expo booth throughout the virtual conference, my amazing colleague Anshal will be leading a meet and greet on Thursday at 12pm Eastern Time, and will also be at the in-person career fair in New York City on Friday.
So if any of this work is interesting to you, we're also hiring, we have open roles in product and design and in our tech org, and I will go ahead and drop a link to that as well. I know we ran out of time, so I didn't get a chance to ask any questions but feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn if you want to chat any further. Thanks.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why inclusive health tech is harder, and more necessary, than adding a gender field
Zocdoc's Laura MacMillan shows how LGBTQ+ patient research met legacy healthcare databases in a sign-up redesign.
In short
Laura MacMillan, UX Research Manager at Zocdoc, argues that building health tech for every patient means listening to the groups the healthcare system has failed, then doing the slow work of changing products that sit on top of old infrastructure. Her team's interviews with LGBTQ+ patients revealed dismissal, misgendering and the burden of educating providers. Turning that into a more inclusive sign-up flow exposed patient matching, HIPAA risk and decades-old database assumptions, and she shows why the effort is still worth it.
Key takeaways
What are the systemic issues leading to the lack of equity in healthcare, and at what scale?
What is the scale of the current challenges we face in healthcare?
What is the impact of continuing to ignore the inequities in the healthcare system?
How is Zocdoc leveraging its platform to increase health equity and build trust within the health system?
How will Zocdoc leverage its platform in the future to create a safer, more accessible and inclusive patient experience?
The platform and the plumbing
MacMillan opens by setting expectations honestly: "So really what this talk is going to be about is how building health health tech within our complicated healthcare system is difficult and thorny and absolutely worth it." (0:30)
She explains Zocdoc as a healthcare marketplace, comparable to how Expedia, OpenTable or Booking.com work for travel and dining. According to the speaker, around 6 million patients a month use it to search and book in-network appointments across more than 200 specialties. The key piece of technology is the synchronizer, or Sync, which reads a practice's availability from its practice management system (PMS) and shows it to patients. There are thousands of these systems, and Zocdoc integrates with roughly 1,400 of them, each different. That detail becomes central later in the story.
Looking past the average patient
MacMillan gently critiques her own company: Zocdoc has optimized well for the average patient and provider, but not all patients are treated equally. "And by addressing these needs, we can help to avoid perpetuating some of the same problems that the health care system has at large." (4:15)
She cites a study of about 5,000 patients in which 56% of LGBTQ+ respondents had experienced being refused care, rough handling, abusive language or blame for their health status, and after such experiences were seven times less likely to seek care. To understand this better, she, as a queer and trained researcher, worked with members of ZocPride, Zocdoc's LGBTQ+ employee resource group, training colleagues in interviewing basics to broaden the perspectives in the room.
The findings were stark. Patients described lower expectations of care, hiding their trans identity to avoid being misgendered, and skipping follow-ups for a pulmonary embolism after feeling dismissed. One trans man had to persuade an emergency room to test his testosterone, which turned out to be dangerously high. A trans woman with HIV was denied foot surgery on the day she disclosed her status.
Friendly is not the same as knowledgeable
Patients actively seek affirming care, sometimes finding it in unexpected places, like a dermatologist who knew to ask how hormone therapy might affect skin. MacMillan draws a sharp line in language: "So, you might hear people use the terms LGBTQ plus friendly, but I want to make a distinction between friendly and competent or knowledgeable." (9:05)
Knowledgeable care, as patients described it, is specific and informed: PrEP and blood work in one facility, providers who keep up with current trans healthcare practice, and staff who have seen many trans patients. For non-binary and trans patients especially, affirmation must run through the entire experience, from intake forms and front desk to the systems that store information. Being misgendered or deadnamed can lead some patients to dissociate and forget what the doctor said, which harms outcomes.
Why a gender field is not simple
The team chose to start with something already in the product: the sex and gender options in sign-up. Testing with non-binary and trans patients showed that a tooltip explaining the sex assigned at birth question was appreciated but not enough. Patients wanted gender or pronouns asked too.
MacMillan captures the tempting shortcut: "Let's just slap on a gender field in our sign-up flow and call it a day, right?" (13:25)
Removing sex entirely was not possible, because PMSs use sex for patient matching, which prevents duplicate records and stops existing records from being overwritten, a HIPAA concern. Adding a gender field ran into the inconsistency of the systems themselves: many lack a gender field, and those that have one use different categories. She notes that many PMSs grew out of electronic health record technology from the 1970s: "So you get some of the notions from that time around identity that are kind of baked into the databases themselves." (15:43)
Passing gender through a generic notes field looked easy, but those fields often hold insurance details and have character limits. The team took time to research the products they integrate with, and preliminary findings suggested gender could be passed along the majority of the time.
Saying what you are actually asking for
Meanwhile, ZocPride offered a practical improvement. What the sign-up really needs is the sex on the patient's insurance or health record, for matching. "It's not really sex assigned at birth because sex assigned at birth doesn't always match the patient's actual record." (17:29) Their recommendation was to relabel the field as sex for clinical use, with an explanatory tooltip.
MacMillan closes with the directions Zocdoc is exploring: refining sign-up copy, finding ways to capture gender successfully, and its Intake product, which lets practices upload their own forms so patients can see which practices are more inclusive.
Watch the talk
HealthTech Innovation and Its Impact on Health Equity, by Laura MacMillan (about 20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/healthtech-innovation-and-its-impact-health-equity-laura-macmillan
About the speaker
Laura MacMillan is UX Research Manager at Zocdoc, where she leads the user research team at the New York health-tech company. She has previously worked in agency and in-house settings on education, personal finance, climate and more.
Questions this talk answers
Why do LGBTQ+ patients often have lower expectations of healthcare?
What is the difference between LGBTQ+ friendly and LGBTQ+ knowledgeable care?
Why can't Zocdoc simply remove sex from its sign-up flow?
Why is adding a gender field technically hard?
What did Zocdoc's ZocPride ERG recommend?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Cite this talk
Laura MacMillan. "HealthTech Innovation and Its Impact on Health Equity." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/healthtech-innovation-and-its-impact-health-equity-laura-macmillan