Called her boss's golden child, she was still passed over for a man
After four years of weekends, long hours and on-time projects, the woman her boss called a golden child watched a less experienced male colleague get the promotion. Later, as a new manager, she heard she was unapproachable, for the same directness often celebrated in men. Stefanie Khan, Senior Director of Analytics at Red Hat, asks what women should do when hard work alone does not get them rewarded.
Learn how she won the promotion, reworked harsh feedback and turned difference into an edge
Stefanie Khan, Senior Director of Analytics at Red Hat, shares setbacks from her 15-year data career rather than her successes. She argues that women must ask for the recognition they deserve, treat uncomfortable feedback as material for self-reflection, and use what makes them different to challenge the status quo in male-dominated rooms.
“Sometimes you have to stand up for yourself and ask for it. And not only ask for it, but demand it.”
“I'm overly assertive and direct and unapproachable. And by the way, these are often qualities that are highly celebrated in men.”
What you will learn
Recognize when steady hard work is not translating into promotion and prepare to ask for it directly.
Respond to feedback that clashes with your self-image by observing your own demeanor, communication style and body language.
Adjust an assertive style so that direct messages land well, for example by saying no with a smile.
Use your differences in perspective and background as an advantage when you are outnumbered in leadership meetings.
Reframe setbacks and bad experiences as lessons rather than failures.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Challenge the status quo
Use your diverse perspective to add incremental value
Women can break the barriers in a male-dominated industry
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career, People manager
Length
17:07
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What should you do if a less qualified colleague is promoted ahead of you?
Stefanie went to her vice president the next morning, made her case and asked why she had not been promoted. She was promoted within a week with a substantial pay raise.
How should you handle feedback that you are unapproachable?
Rather than taking it negatively, she spent weeks observing her demeanor, communication style and body language, then adjusted her approach to be direct in a way that would be received well.
Can a woman be assertive without being seen as demanding?
Stefanie learned to say no with a smile, be a little warmer and build friendships with leaders and teams while still driving change.
How can you stand out when you don't look like everyone else in the room?
She urges women to be the pink in a sea of gray: offer a different perspective, set the example and use their unique edge to challenge the status quo.
About this talk
Overcoming the challenges of being a diverse woman in technology. Using my key differentiators to make a difference, add value, and challenge the status quo.
Good morning, good afternoon, and good evening. I know this is a global audience here. So absolute pleasure to be here. So grateful and honored to be a part of this amazing conference. A lot of great content from so many leaders within the tech industry. So happy to spend the next couple of minutes here just to walk you through a little bit of what I would like to share with you.
during this morning. I've spent the last couple of weeks kind of pondering what my message was going to be to you. What is it that I wanted to convey that would be impactful and leave a level of impact in all of the female leaders in this virtual room? To be honest, as I think through that, it's really not the wins and the successes that have crafted me to be the leader that I am today. I'm currently the senior director of the of data analytics for Red Hat. So Fortune 500 company that is really spearheading all things open source. I've spent about 15 years of my life in all things data. So from end to end solutions, including data warehousing and data science, predictability, AI, RPA, the list goes on. But instead of talking about who I am and my best
background or my background or my technical experience, I kind of wanted to share with you today, some of the challenges and some of the rough times that have taught me to be a better leader. And I'm hoping that the conversation over the next couple of minutes here will be impactful. Really trying to keep this more conversational. So I have not prepared any sort of deck or slides to read off of. I really just want to share some of my personal experiences throughout my career that has helped me drive who I am and transform into who I am as a leader and also how I've been adaptive to the varying scenarios throughout my career.
And I really hope that even if I impact one person today, then I'm able to make that change and welcome everyone. I see a few folks joining also from all over the world, Poland, Sydney, Australia. That is amazing. Thank you so much for taking the time to join me here. So I'm going to get started today and take you back, not trying to date myself here, but almost 15 plus years. Back to my earlier career, I was fresh out of school, eager to work hard, very dedicated, hoping that I would be justly rewarded.
And I was working for a healthcare organization, started out as a financial analyst, pivoted into a more technology focused role, and spent every waking hour that I could to do the best job possible. So working weekends, extra long hours, delivering all my projects on time trying to be as collaborative and thoughtful as I possibly could be. In fact, my leader at the time referred to me as her golden child.
So I took that as a notion of a job well done. However, four years went by, there was no promotion in sight. And I thought that it was coming, I would continue to do a good job, and that that promotion would come. So little did I know, a male colleague, a male counterpart was promoted. He did not have the credentials that I had. He did not have the background or experience that I had.
I remember some very solid feelings around disappointment, levels of betrayal, sadness, anger, all of the above. And I also remember going home that night feeling a little defeated, feeling a little lost. I didn't know what to do. I didn't know what that meant for me, for the work that I've done, for my loyalty to this company. What does that mean for me with my colleague being promoted, and I had not.
I woke up the next morning, and I said, you know what, I'm going to take this as an opportunity to face my fears and stand up for myself. So I approached my vice president that morning. I very vividly remember walking into her office and asking if she had a couple minutes to chat. And she said, Sure, come on in. I walked in, closed the door, sat down. I remember my palms being ever so sweaty, and I was so probably the most nervous I had ever been in my entire life.
And I sat and I pled my case. I conveyed to her that I am a great employee, that I have done everything that you have ever asked me to do and beyond. And I've recently learned that my counterpart had been promoted. And why haven't I been promoted? Paused and waited for her response. And to my dismay, her response was, you absolutely deserve a promotion.
I kind of chuckled to myself as I am now, because I was shocked at that response. And, and within a week, I was promoted and giving us given a substantial pay raise and a promotion. And I left her off office feeling happy, and feeling that I had accomplished what I sought out to accomplish that morning. However, reflecting on that scenario, this is the messaging that I want you to really listen to, is sometimes you're not given what you are deserved of.
Sometimes you have to stand up for yourself and ask for it. And not only ask for it, but demand it. And while we may be, we as women may be given the opportunities along the way, we may not be justly rewarded along the way. There may be feelings of being underappreciated there. And you really need to be empowered in who you are and the, in the, the work that you're producing and the value that you're adding.
And that level of incrementality that nobody else can bring, um, to know your worth and demand what you're worth. So first messaging there. And, uh, thank you. I'm, I'm seeing some more, some more folks rolling in here. Um, moving right along. I wanted to tell you a little bit about another experience that I had, and this was a little further on into my career.
Um, I was a first time manager, first time managing people. And to take you back a little bit, I was raised to always put my best foot forward, always look my best, always dress my best, always dress for the job that I wanted. Although that has certainly changed in the last couple of years, working from home and, and, and having the luxury of, um, being a little bit more flexible there.
Um, but alongside that, I've also, I've also been told that I'm overdressed. I'm overly assertive and direct and unapproachable. And by the way, these are often qualities that are highly celebrated in men. So it's always been a little puzzling to me to get that sort of feedback. So going back to, to the initial story here, um, first job as a manager, first job managing people.
I had my first quarterly review of which I was excited. I thought I was doing a fantastic job. I had taken on a lot of incremental work, a lot of leadership responsibilities, learning so much, and kind of really enjoying that journey of transitioning from an individual contributor over to a leader. And, um, at the beginning of, of that feedback session was very, very positive, but the end note ended with my boss telling me that I was unapproachable.
And now this is something that I had heard almost my entire life, but from a professional capacity where I knew I was giving it 110%, I was shocked. That I was being told that I was being told that I was unapproachable, puzzled by it. In fact, I remember also leaving his office and thinking about how can I be unapproachable.
I'm the one that organizes the happy hours. I'm the one that's, you know, stopping and talking with everyone and being as social as I possibly can. So what could he possibly mean by I was unapproachable? So instead of taking it in a negative light, I really started to spend the next couple of weeks to observe myself, to do some self-reflection.
What was my demeanor? What was my communication style? What was my body language? And after I started paying attention to that, I really, I started noticing some things in myself that would lean into a perception where I was unapproachable. And I took that feedback and instead of taking it as a negative light, I decided to improve and incorporate that into my approach going forward.
I realized that in order to drive change, in order to drive transformation, in order to drive innovation, I had to be direct and assertive, but I had to be direct and assertive in a way that would be received well. So what that translates to me in summary is being able to say no with a smile on my face, being able to deliver a message that would resonate with the teams and with my colleagues and with my leaders, where it wasn't coming across as being demanding or overly directive, but more so being understanding.
So going back to my boss at the time and that level of feedback that he gave me and really my choice to take it as constructive feedback, a level of thought there was, was he trying to hold me back? And really, I didn't know the answer. I really didn't. So instead of taking it in a negative light, I decided to tweak my approach ever so slightly.
And like I said, be a little bit warmer. Say no with a smile. Build friendships with your leaders and your teams. And I urge you that the next time you receive a piece of feedback that is not aligned with your perception, with what you're trying to accomplish, with the work that you're doing, take a step back to do sort of an out-of-body experience and observe yourself in a non-biased way to really compare and contrast your approach against others, to really evaluate yourself and really hone in on whether this piece of feedback is intuitive, is valuable, is something that you can take to make something better about yourself, instead of taking it into a negative light.
And reading through the comments, I will go back after this session. There's one other topic I want to get through in the last couple of minutes here, but thank you so much for the comments. And feel free to reach out to me personally with any other questions or comments. But the last point I wanted to hone in on is the topic of today, succeeding in a male-dominated industry, being a woman in a male-dominated industry.
It dates back to when, you know, I decided to venture into learning about technology, getting a degree, and really pursuing this passion of mine, and being questioned by friends and family of, you don't want to be a nurse, you don't want to get into a more female-friendly field. You want to sit at a computer and write code all day, although, you know, I don't do that anymore, but I have teams that do that today.
You know, it is an ongoing challenge of being a woman in a male-dominated industry, in a male-dominated industry. In fact, I recently read a really interesting survey that said one out of four senior leaders are women. That may feel like a great number. We're certainly making strides, but one out of four is only 25% of senior leaders.
That's not a very big portion. So, like I said, we're making huge strides here, but we're still the minority. Although we represent almost half, or I think at this rate, a little bit over half of the world's total population. So, it is really an uphill battle. And taking myself into a professional, taking my story back into a professional landscape here, as I think through board meetings and C-suite meetings and leadership meetings, I'm often outnumbered in stakeholder board meetings, not only in headcount, but also in opinion and perspective.
And it can be intimidating. And that's something, as women, we have to be able to overcome. That just because we're a little bit different, just because we don't look like everybody else in the room, does not mean that we don't have an equal say. And that our opinions and perspectives should not be equally validated. And so, when I think about myself, I bring something very different to the table.
It's a combination of a lot of minority-related statistics. So, I'm a millennial. I'm Asian. I'm a woman. I'm young. I'm really into fashion and all of those things that come alongside things that are so not traditionally technology-related. It checks a lot of diversity buckets, doesn't it? I've learned throughout my career to use that to my advantage, to use the differences in me and to really set my opinion outside of the box and challenge that status quo.
A couple years ago, I coined the term, be the pink in a sea of gray. Be the pink in a sea of gray. What does that mean to me? To me, that means driving that change that you want to see. Set the example. Be the role model. Don't be afraid to challenge a status quo. Offer a different perspective.
Use your differences to your advantage. Use your unique edge to stand out. Yes, you may not look like everybody else in the room, and your opinions may not be aligned with everybody else in the room, but your experience, your drive, and everything that makes you you is going to help you drive and transform and innovate and help a lot of what we're doing today make huge impacts as we go into the world.
A couple of minutes left here, and I'm going to wrap up the talk and really think about the key messaging that I'm leaving with you today. Don't take your bad experiences as failures. I urge you, don't be intimidated by the things that you do wrong. Take them as lessons learned. Take them as an opportunity to grow and self-reflect and really think purposefully and intentionally and how you need to tweak yourself to be better.
Take them as opportunities for you to level up your way of thinking. Take feedback as constructive. Don't take feedback in a negative light. Stand up for yourself. Know your worth. Be yourself, more importantly, don't hide who you are. It's that personality that's going to set you apart, especially when you don't look like everybody else in the room or that you don't, if you don't think like everybody else in the room as, as sort of minorities in the C-suite here.
We have to really stand up for ourselves, challenge the status quo. I challenge you, each of you, when you go home today, and all of you are probably at home in this virtual world, but, you know, when your work day is over, look at yourself in the mirror and see all of you for who you are. The good, the bad, the different, the unique.
I urge you to embrace it. Accept it. Own who you are and use it to your advantage. It is your unique perspective that is going to help you approach your career goals, approach your life goals, get to the next level. I urge you to take what makes you different and use it to your advantage. I urge you to dare to dream and challenge yourself every single day to step outside of your own personal box and really diversify your offerings, diversify your values, and take those actions and really craft who you are.
With that, I will wrap up my session. I hope that the last couple of minutes here has been impactful and really enjoy the sessions thus far. We have a whole day ahead of us as well as a couple more days ahead in this Women in Tech Global Conference. So really learning to, really loving all of the sessions and looking forward to learning more about each of you.
With that, take care. Remember, be the pink in the sea of gray. I urge you to do that. Take care, everyone. Bye-bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why women in tech must ask for what they have earned
Stefanie Khan of Red Hat explains how a missed promotion, an awkward review and a boardroom full of gray suits shaped her as a leader.
In short
Hard work alone does not guarantee recognition, argues Stefanie Khan, Senior Director of Analytics at Red Hat. Drawing on 15 years in data, she shows how asking directly for a promotion, treating uncomfortable feedback as a mirror and owning what makes her different helped her succeed in a male-dominated industry. Her message: know your worth, ask for it, and be "the pink in a sea of gray."
Key takeaways
Challenge the status quo.
Use your diverse perspective to add incremental value.
Women can break the barriers in a male-dominated industry.
The golden child who was passed over
Stefanie chose not to talk about her wins. Instead she opened with the setbacks that taught her the most, starting fresh out of school at a healthcare organization. She began as a financial analyst, moved into a more technology-focused role and gave the job everything: weekends, long hours, projects delivered on time. Her leader even called her a golden child.
Four years later there was still no promotion. Then a male colleague without her credentials, background or experience was promoted instead. She describes going home feeling disappointed, betrayed and defeated. The next morning she decided to face her fears. With sweaty palms, more nervous than she had ever been, she walked into her vice president's office, closed the door and asked why she had not been promoted.
"And to my dismay, her response was, you absolutely deserve a promotion." (4:42)
Within a week she had the promotion and a substantial pay raise. The lesson she draws is the core of the talk: recognition is not always handed out to those who deserve it.
"Sometimes you have to stand up for yourself and ask for it. And not only ask for it, but demand it." (5:43)
She adds that women may be given opportunities without being justly rewarded for them, and that knowing the value you add, the incrementality nobody else can bring, is what lets you ask for your worth.
When feedback says you are unapproachable
The second story comes from her first job managing people. Stefanie had been raised to dress for the job she wanted, and over the years she had heard a familiar set of criticisms.
"I'm overly assertive and direct and unapproachable. And by the way, these are often qualities that are highly celebrated in men." (6:57)
Her first quarterly review as a manager started positively but ended with her boss calling her unapproachable. She was shocked: she organized the happy hours and made a point of talking to everyone. Rather than dismissing the comment, she spent the following weeks observing herself, her demeanor, communication style and body language, and found things that could feed that perception.
"I realized that in order to drive change, in order to drive transformation, in order to drive innovation, I had to be direct and assertive, but I had to be direct and assertive in a way that would be received well." (9:03)
In practice that meant saying no with a smile, being a little warmer and building friendships with leaders and teams. She admits she never knew whether her boss was trying to hold her back. Her advice is to step back when feedback clashes with your self-image, observe yourself as if from outside, compare your approach with others and decide whether the feedback is something you can use.
Outnumbered in the room
Stefanie traces the challenge of being a woman in tech back to her studies, when friends and family asked whether she would rather be a nurse than sit at a computer writing code all day. She cites a survey, as the speaker cited without naming it, saying one in four senior leaders are women: progress, but still a minority when women make up about half the world's population.
In board, C-suite and leadership meetings she is often outnumbered, in headcount and in opinion. That can be intimidating, she says, but it does not reduce anyone's right to be heard.
"That just because we're a little bit different, just because we don't look like everybody else in the room, does not mean that we don't have an equal say." (12:42)
She describes herself as checking many diversity boxes: a millennial, Asian, a woman, young and into fashion. Over her career she has learned to use those differences to place her opinions outside the box and challenge the status quo.
Be the pink in a sea of gray
That idea became her personal motto.
"A couple years ago, I coined the term, be the pink in a sea of gray." (13:45)
For Stefanie it means driving the change you want to see, setting the example, being a role model and offering a different perspective. You may not look or think like everyone else in the room, she says, but your experience and drive are what help you transform and innovate.
She closes with a set of lessons and a challenge.
"Don't take your bad experiences as failures. I urge you, don't be intimidated by the things that you do wrong." (14:38)
Take feedback as constructive, stand up for yourself, know your worth and do not hide who you are. At the end of the workday, she asks viewers to look in the mirror, see the good, the bad, the different and the unique, and use all of it to their advantage.
Watch the talk
Succeeding in Male-Dominated Industry, Stefanie Khan, 17 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/succeeding-in-male-dominated-industry-stefanie-khan
About the speaker
Stefanie Khan is Senior Director of Analytics at Red Hat, with more than 15 years of experience across data warehousing, analytics, data science and business intelligence. She holds a bachelor's degree in Business Information Systems and an MBA, and has led in several Fortune 500 companies with a focus on driving change and transformation through a diverse perspective.
Questions this talk answers
What should you do if a less qualified colleague is promoted ahead of you?
How should you handle feedback that you are unapproachable?
Can a woman be assertive without being seen as demanding?
How can you stand out when you don't look like everyone else in the room?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Cite this talk
Stefanie Khan. "Succeeding in Male-Dominated Industry." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/succeeding-in-male-dominated-industry-stefanie-khan