Bending the Curve with Our Thinking about Design Foundations
Natasha Rabsatt19:072022
You can't easily break paradigms, but you can shape the mental models
Paradigms, the worldviews people bring to work, are hard to break, but schemas and mental models are easier to shape. That distinction matters for any organization trying to design inclusively for AR, VR and the metaverse, where strong design foundations are, in the speaker's words, no longer elective. Experience designer and XR strategist Natasha Rabsatt, founder of NAR Creative, asks how strategic design can align a diverse workforce without pushing anyone out.
Learn how schemas, mental models and strategic design combine into stronger design foundations
Natasha Rabsatt, founder and CEO of NAR Creative LLC, argues that organizations need strong design foundations before they can design inclusively and sustainably for immersive technologies and the metaverse. She explains strategic design as the application of design principles to systemic problems, and shows how understanding schemas and mental models helps align a diverse workforce with organizational mission and values.
“And I believe to really bend the curve with design in the world, you must first be ready to really bend our minds and to bend our thinking.”
“This is strong design foundations at this point are critical. It's no longer elective anymore.”
What you will learn
Define strategic design as applying design principles to systemic problems and tell it apart from tactical design, organizational design and strategic planning.
Identify the core building blocks of a design foundation: understanding of people, leadership alignment, design principles and mindfulness.
Distinguish schemas, mental models and paradigms, and recognize which ones an organization can realistically shape.
Plan how to de-conflict mental models so diverse teams align with organizational mission, vision and values.
Recognize why inclusive, sustainable immersive and metaverse design has to be built in at the foundation layer.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Strategic design is a game-changer for businesses and organizations - it goes beyond tactical and product-focused design and anchors organizational design culture and thinking to support innovation.
Schemas and mental models are foundational to design - these assist with simplified and complex human knowledge development and deconfliction of past experience.
Mindful, inclusive, and sustainable immersive or Metaverse design innovation must be enabled through strong design foundations.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Mid-career, People manager, Executive
Length
19:07
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is strategic design?
It is the application of traditional design principles to systemic problems to positively affect decision-making culture in organizations. It grew out of architecture and urban planning and focuses on problems in context rather than only on solutions.
How is strategic design different from tactical design?
Tactical design covers products going to market and creative projects, which strategic design can enable but is not. Strategic design is also not organizational design or strategic planning; it works alongside those efforts.
What is the difference between schemas and mental models?
Schemas are mental representations that organize knowledge into categories, like file folders on a computer. Mental models are more complex representations of how things work, strung together like a lattice to connect many pieces.
Why focus on schemas and mental models rather than paradigms?
Paradigms, such as worldviews and schools of thought, are hard to break, while knowledge sets and mindsets are easier to shape. The goal is to align diverse people with the organization's mission, not to erase their differences.
Why do design foundations matter for immersive technology and the metaverse?
The rapid growth of AR, VR and other immersive technologies makes strong foundations essential. Mindful, inclusive and sustainable metaverse design has to be enabled at the design foundations layer, beyond guidelines.
About this talk
We hear a lot about design and how it is important to the creation or enhancement of systems, products, and even immersive experiences (also in the metaverse) - but how do we truly design better, more comprehensively, more inclusively, or more accessibly in today's tech-driven world? How do we begin to affect meaningful change in organizations and businesses? Let’s explore how the understanding of strategic design and how knowledge around schemas and mental models support and elevate design program foundations, which ultimately enable us to design better and innovate in today’s tech-driven world.
Design principles are the rebar of your foundation (74 s)
Strategic design looks below the iceberg (57 s)
Schemas as file folders in your brain (87 s)
Hello and welcome. I'm honored to be here today at WomenTech and I'm really excited about sharing with you. I'm Natasha Rabsaatt and I'm a designer, advisor, XR specialist or extended reality strategist and I am the founder and CEO of NAR Creative LLC. We are a United States based strategic design and advisory firm that is in the tech for good ecosystem. We specifically support businesses and organizations with posturing for the future by building strong foundations and organizations to support inclusion, sustainability and mindfulness with immersive technologies such as augmented virtual reality, et cetera, in the metaverse.
I've worked in just a little bit about me. I've worked in various industries and sectors leading initiatives with learning immersive technologies and design and on the design side. I've done everything really ranging from that creative work, tactical design pieces. I call it building experiences, working with clients, doing research, things like that, all the way up to the strategic design piece where I support organizations with building culture and thinking and decision making making to enhance innovation.
So today we are talking about design foundations. And I believe to really bend the curve with design in the world, you must first be ready to really bend our minds and to bend our thinking. So I will share how the understanding of strategic design schemas and mental models. So these three things, strategic design schemas and mental models support and elevate these program foundations from a high level as it relates to businesses and organizations.
And I do believe that we can use this conversation today to really guide our efforts with designing better, more inclusively and more sustainably in today's tech driven world. As we begin this journey together, please feel free to add any questions in the chat and I will do my best to answer them at the end of this call.
Okay, so in this digital society, you've probably noticed that expectations for success have become pretty high, especially for businesses and organizations that create products and services to meet the needs of real people in the real world. We've seen a lot of social movement, great social movement across the world with everything on diversity and inclusion, how we're treating each other, how we're treating environments and the resources in this planet.
And much of this has really been accelerated through the global pandemic, where the need for remote communication has become vital to societies, economies and institutions across the globe. But with this growing need for this remote engagement and communication and digital transformation, the use of immersive technologies to include AR, VR, blockchain, artificial intelligence in and out of the metaverse really has skyrocketed, making the needs for strong design foundations, mindfulness and human practices, it's made it really essential.
This is strong design foundations at this point are critical. It's no longer elective anymore. And organizations with strong foundations are really able to pivot and scale and sustain all of the changes that are happening today and will happen in the future. And so it's not really, it's all around immersive technologies, but the time is right, right now, to really look inside of your organization at a deeper level to sort of see where you are with this.
So let's take a deeper look into design foundations. As you see on the screen, there is a little foundations that these are supposed to be blocks, almost like basin re blocks. And this is what, when I think of design foundations is what I'm thinking about. Strong foundations are really set to be built upon solid ground from solid thinking and alignment with the industry best practices and principles.
At the core, design foundations may consist of many things. And these are a few things that I've put in here. And these things in your organization may be described differently or defined differently, based on your business model needs and values, but there are things that are consistent across probably every organization. And I've seen that. And I've seen that design foundations must really and truly include a deep understanding of people and humanity, also alignment with leadership and focus strongly on design principles.
Design principles are really like laws or guidelines and considerations that are applied. And these principles really anchor the foundation. I see them sort of like rebar. So rebar inside of a foundation that's being poured. It really helps to prevent it from breaking it with the slightest movement. And so the foundations are really design foundations. That's really how I look at it. But mindfulness is another component that we kind of, it's like another layer where we're adding, we need to be able to build this in as well.
And I, I, I, when I refer to mindfulness, I define it as sort of this commitment, this quality or state of being conscious or aware of these principles and then actually, and best practices and then actually doing something about it one step at a time, committing to excellence. So strong foundations. So strong foundations really help to build that, that organization that you're looking for, that long-term sustainability. But how do we actually do build this now? Right. So I think we can consider something called strategic design, and it's really a vehicle or connector to build decision making and culture.
So let's kind of dive into that a little bit. Strategic design is really the application of traditional design principles to systemic problems. Really to positively affect culture around decision making in organizations. It works in tandem with things like organizational design and development efforts. And it's often led by strategic designers. And it's often led by strategic designers. And so where does strategic design come from? It comes really out of practice with architecture and urban planning.
But what it really is, there's a lot to say about strategic design, but it's really about problem focus. It's about focusing on systemic problems and not just solutions. So think of it as like a triangle. And at the top, we have solutions. The solution market on the bottom, it's much like an iceberg where there's a lot of it under the water. But the top is a solution. So strategic design is looking at the entire problem.
It's not a problem. It's focused on contextual systems. It's focused on understanding things in context. It affects decision making culture. And it's really oriented towards the future, future, not just only now, or what's happening, but it's future oriented and multi level, and it affects the entire ecosystem, what's in the ecosystem and what's coming in from the outside, what it is not, and it often gets confused with things like tactical design.
Technical design, technical design, like products go into market creative projects. Now creative projects and things like that can be enabled to in a better way, through strategic design, but it is not strategic design, it is not strategic design is also not organizational design. It's not strategic planning. And it's not there to replace any of these other efforts in the organization. It is to work with these other efforts in the organization.
So now if we go a little bit deeper. I'm sorry, if we go a little bit deeper, strategic design is really important. Now, like, let's look inside of the organization. When you look at what is happening inside of the walls of organizations, you may notice a few things. There's people with diverse backgrounds, nationalities, languages, cultures, ability levels, different needs. And these people have different knowledge sets. And when we talk about this, what's going on?
Strategic design is really important. Now, like, let's look inside of the organization. When you look at what is happening inside of the walls of organizations, you may notice a few things. There's people with diverse backgrounds, nationalities, languages, cultures, ability levels, different needs. And these people have different knowledge sets. And when we talk about knowledge sets, I'm going to eventually call this what we call schemas. That's how we essentially structure and organize information in our brains. And then what we're doing with this knowledge is this knowledge also coupled with mindsets really help to drive behaviors, motivational levels, either supporting or upholding paradigms. So paradigms are more like larger theories, worldviews, or schools of thought. Paradigms are actually harder to break. So in your organization, going on to the next piece here, inside your organization, this graphic shows a lot of different
people. And so they're, they all come with different paradigms, knowledge sets, mindsets, and some may be the same, right. But really, what we're looking at, there's something that's really positive about having people with all of these different thoughts, is that we see any, we see diversity, which is a great thing that helps with innovation, diverse organizations and companies outperform others that are not. We've seen many of that research out in the industry. The challenge with this is that many organizations, especially if, if there's not enough, a strong alignment to strategic vision, mission, and values, there could be challenges with getting people on the same page to work together. And not only work together in the sense of doing day-to-day tasks, but work together, especially the goal of the organization is also to support the reduction of effects from systemic problems in our
society. So paradigms are pretty solid. And like I said, they're harder to, they're harder to break. But knowledge sets, these schemas and mental models, these, these mindsets and knowledge sets are easier to shape. And a lot of times when we hear the term schemas and mental models, we think of like learning. It is about learning. It's about, it's a, it's cognitive. But the goal is really not to eradicate or attempt to, to change paradigms or to reduce the diverse hiring. The goal is really to, to embrace these different people and different schools of thoughts, but really put them into alignment from a strategic point of view. So design foundations have to be multidisciplinary, multi-level, and really tap into that contextual layer, understanding of people in your organization
to really start affecting change. And so now let's start to talk about how we're connecting these dots. At the high level, schemas are basically these mental representations. And there's a lot to say about schemas. It's, this is rooted in cognitive psychology. Many professions borrow from this schema theory, as it's called. But schemas are really mental representations and enable us to organize our information in, excuse me, knowledge into categories. And I look at schemas as almost like file folders on a computer. So schemas are built throughout our lives. And a lot of times they're built without us knowing that they're there. Sometimes formal education, we can build, we can build schemas.
But in these file folders, think of something like a dog. We've learned that dogs have certain characteristics. And so maybe a dog has a tail, it has, it has a nose, it has ears, it has four legs. That is a schema. I will say that is one file folder. Maybe cats is another file folder. So that's the easiest way I think of schemas. But they're really tied again to this knowledge and memory that we have.
Mental models then are really, some people will say that they are mindset. Some will say that they're not mindsets or they're, they affect, they affect mindsets. But, but mental models really are representations of how things work. It's about understanding. And they're more complex than schemas. They're strung together in a way. It's essentially like a, like lattice or overlapping, more like a, more like a lattice. So, so what we're really saying here with mental models is that we, it's really, we cannot, we cannot remember everything. And so mental models really help us connect the dots between many different pieces. And then kind of going into this strategic design part.
Now, strategic design is truly like the vehicle, whereas schemas and mental models are the knowledge and the mindsets within your organization or business. So just moving on a little bit now. So how are we actually bridging the gap? So we need to be able to identify and de-conflict mental models and even schemas, but mostly mental models that are not supported, supportive of the larger organizational vision. But really, we want to set guideposts to show people in the company or your organization a better way. The goal, again, is not to remove people because of their differing knowledge sets or their backgrounds, but really aligning their backgrounds to the larger organizational mission, vision, and goals to, but really to help to dismantle systemic problems that are affecting them from the outside in society a little at a time. No one designer, leader,
a person in any organization will be able to do this type of heavy lifting and have a result that will automatically align the culture and support this, again, dismantling. It is important to really consider leveraging strategic design for these purposes. And this type of design work is really intentional. And as you see on the right side of the screen, there's this graphic with a lot of different dots, and it's almost representing different people in the organization. So with all of these different backgrounds, this can work very nicely that diversity and to support long-term sustainability, because you have all of those points of view, you have all of those perspectives to be able to challenge ideas and to challenge ideas in businesses so we can come up with better solutions. But on the
strategic layer, really strategic design is the game changer. It is a game changer for businesses and organizations. It goes beyond that tactical product-focused design and really anchors that organizational design culture. It really helps to anchor our design foundations, what we stand for. And schemas and mental models in this context are really, again, they're foundational to understanding how people think and store information in their brains. And how they retrieve it and how it affects their actions and behaviors and organizations.
And we can, again, easily break schemas and mental models through application, but it's harder to break those paradigms. So we really want to focus on shaping the future through leveraging this knowledge around schemas and mental models. And really the future state, when we get into the last piece, because we're almost here at time, really to get into that mindfulness piece around immersive technology, we have to be able to enable this from the ground up again in your design foundations. Mindful, inclusive, and sustainable, immersive, or even metaverse design, it has to be enabled at that design foundations layer. So things around humanity, we value inclusion, so how are we truly building inclusion in? It's not, it's beyond guidelines and pieces like that. We have to intentionally
design our foundations and our organization in a way that supports this through their mission and vision, but also align to what's happening on the outside so you can dismantle some of these issues a little bit at a time through your efforts. And that's really all I have for today. I really thank you for your attention. I'm going to take a quick minute to answer some questions.
So please feel free to add them in the chat. And thank you to Women Tech for this amazing event. If there aren't any other questions or any questions, definitely for us to stay in touch. That's my contact information. Thank you again to Women Tech for hosting this amazing event so that we can share meaningfully together. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why strong design foundations come before inclusive metaverse design
Natasha Rabsatt shows how strategic design, schemas and mental models help organizations align diverse people around better, more inclusive design.
In short
Natasha Rabsatt argues that organizations cannot design inclusively, sustainably or mindfully for immersive technologies until they have strong design foundations in place. Her route there is strategic design, which applies design principles to systemic problems, combined with an understanding of how schemas and mental models shape the way people in an organization think and act. Paradigms are hard to break, she says, but knowledge sets and mindsets can be shaped and aligned.
Key takeaways
Strategic design is a game changer for businesses and organizations: it goes beyond tactical and product-focused design and anchors organizational design culture and thinking to support innovation.
Schemas and mental models are foundational to design: they assist with simple and complex human knowledge development and the de-confliction of past experience.
Mindful, inclusive and sustainable immersive or metaverse design innovation must be enabled through strong design foundations.
Why design foundations are no longer optional
Rabsatt, founder and CEO of the strategic design and advisory firm NAR Creative LLC, opens by framing the talk as a challenge to how people think. "And I believe to really bend the curve with design in the world, you must first be ready to really bend our minds and to bend our thinking." (1:26)
She sets the context in a digital society where expectations of businesses have risen sharply. Social movements around diversity, inclusion and how people treat the planet, together with the remote communication needs accelerated by the global pandemic, have driven the use of AR, VR, blockchain and artificial intelligence in and out of the metaverse. That growth, she says, makes strong design foundations, mindfulness and human practices essential. "This is strong design foundations at this point are critical. It's no longer elective anymore." (3:29) Organizations with strong foundations, in her view, are the ones able to pivot, scale and sustain change.
What a design foundation is made of
Rabsatt pictures design foundations as building blocks set on solid ground and aligned with industry best practices and principles. While each organization may define them differently based on its business model and values, she sees consistent elements: a deep understanding of people and humanity, alignment with leadership, and a strong focus on design principles.
She compares those principles to the steel inside concrete. "So rebar inside of a foundation that's being poured. It really helps to prevent it from breaking it with the slightest movement." (5:04) On top of that sits mindfulness, which she defines as a commitment to being aware of principles and best practices and then acting on them one step at a time.
Strategic design: problems before solutions
To build these foundations, Rabsatt points to strategic design as the vehicle that connects decision making and culture. She describes it as the application of traditional design principles to systemic problems, rooted in architecture and urban planning and often led by strategic designers working in tandem with organizational design and development efforts.
Using the image of an iceberg, she explains that solutions are only the visible tip. "It's about focusing on systemic problems and not just solutions." (6:55) Strategic design is contextual, future-oriented and multi-level, and it affects the whole ecosystem. Just as important is what it is not: it is not tactical design such as products going to market or creative projects, not organizational design and not strategic planning. It exists to work with those efforts, not replace them.
Schemas, mental models and paradigms
Looking inside organizations, Rabsatt sees people with diverse backgrounds, nationalities, languages, cultures, ability levels and needs, each carrying different knowledge sets and mindsets that drive behavior and either support or uphold paradigms. Diversity helps innovation, she notes, but without strong alignment to vision, mission and values it can be hard to get people working together.
The key distinction is between what can and cannot easily change. "But knowledge sets, these schemas and mental models, these, these mindsets and knowledge sets are easier to shape." (10:50) Drawing on schema theory from cognitive psychology, she offers a simple image. "And I look at schemas as almost like file folders on a computer." (11:49) A schema for dogs holds tails, noses, ears and four legs; cats get another folder. Mental models are more complex: representations of how things work, connected like a lattice so people can link many pieces without remembering everything.
Bridging the gap and designing for the metaverse
If schemas and mental models are the knowledge and mindsets of an organization, strategic design is the vehicle that aligns them. Rabsatt calls for identifying and de-conflicting the mental models that do not support the larger organizational vision and setting guideposts that show people a better way. The aim is not to remove anyone for having a different background but to align those backgrounds with the mission, while helping dismantle systemic problems a little at a time. No single designer or leader can do this heavy lifting alone, which is why she treats strategic design as essential. "It is a game changer for businesses and organizations." (16:17)
She closes by bringing the argument back to immersive technology. Mindful, inclusive and sustainable metaverse design has to be enabled at the foundation layer, going beyond guidelines to intentionally design the organization's mission and vision in ways that also respond to what is happening outside it.
Watch the talk
Bending the Curve with Our Thinking about Design Foundations, by Natasha Rabsatt (19 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/bending-curve-our-thinking-about-design-foundations-natasha-rabsatt
About the speaker
Natasha Rabsatt is Founder and CEO, Experience Designer, and XR Strategist at NAR Creative LLC, a strategic design and advisory firm that helps businesses and organizations build strong design foundations to enhance inclusion, sustainability and mindfulness with immersive experiences such as AR and VR. She has led the creative vision for global enterprise learning initiatives, spearheaded XR program start-up and governance, and led cross-functional teams to build XR literacy and design inclusion.
Questions this talk answers
What is strategic design?
How is strategic design different from tactical design?
What is the difference between schemas and mental models?
Why focus on schemas and mental models rather than paradigms?
Why do design foundations matter for immersive technology and the metaverse?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Strategic design
Schema theory
Mental models
Cite this talk
Natasha Rabsatt. "Bending the Curve with Our Thinking about Design Foundations." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/bending-curve-our-thinking-about-design-foundations-natasha-rabsatt