Half a second of lag is fine for video, fatal for an industrial robot
A half-second delay barely matters when a web page loads, but it can decide whether a traffic accident is prevented or an industrial robot runs safely. That gap is why 5G needs more than new radios, and Cisco software engineer Richa Daga, who has spent a decade building packet optical products, explains what has to change underneath. So what must operators rebuild, from the radio to the core, before 5G can deliver?
Learn how disaggregation, edge cloud and segment routing make 5G's promises achievable
Richa Daga, a software engineer at Cisco, explains why 5G's promises of high bandwidth, ultra-low latency and massive IoT cannot be met by today's networks. She walks through the three 5G service types, the vendor lock-in and cost problems of monolithic base stations, and the architecture that solves them: disaggregation, Open RAN, a decomposed radio stack, edge cloud and segment routing.
“For instance, if network latency occurs and results in an additional half second to download a video or render a web page, it will probably not ruin the customer experience. But in preventing a traffic accident or running an industrial robot, that half second becomes so important.”
“So decomposition it means that the network architecture is built from modular elements that assemble into a whole through open and interoperable interfaces.”
What you will learn
Distinguish the three 5G service types (eMBB, URLLC and mMTC) and the network requirements each one imposes.
Explain why monolithic base station implementations lead to vendor lock-in and higher operating and capital costs.
Map how the 5G radio signal processing stack splits across centralized, distributed and remote radio units over fronthaul and midhaul links.
Describe how an edge cloud location offloads traffic and reduces bandwidth for latency-sensitive applications such as VR.
Assess the benefits of segment routing for network slicing, resilience, load distribution and lower OPEX.
Key takeaways from the speaker
The key takeaway of this session is to understand the need for network evolution.
How to support legacy network and enable a smooth transition to a virtual world without having numerous outages?
What should be the criteria to select different technologies and what are the future possibilities of 5G?
How is AR/VR/IoT/AI success linked to having a robust network backbone?
How to ensure data is protected in the virtual world and address cybersecurity issues.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Tech talk
Technical depth
Practitioner
For
Early career, Mid-career, Senior individual contributor
Length
18:45
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What are the main 5G service types?
Enhanced mobile broadband for faster human-centric connectivity, ultra-reliable low latency communication for mission-critical uses with under one millisecond response, and massive machine type communication for scaling the Internet of Things.
Why can't existing networks simply carry 5G?
Bandwidth demand is growing fast as more of the world comes online, and monolithic base stations lock operators into a single vendor with limited services and high OPEX and CAPEX.
What do disaggregation and decomposition mean for a software-defined network?
Disaggregation makes software a separate purchase from commodity hardware, and decomposition builds the network from modular elements joined by open, interoperable interfaces, enabling multi-vendor Open RAN.
What role does edge cloud play in 5G?
It consolidates centralized unit workloads and the user plane function at an intermediate location, offloading traffic and computing at the edge to reduce bandwidth, for example calculating a VR field of view locally.
Why does segment routing matter for 5G networks?
It encodes paths and policies in the packet header, enabling network slicing, fast rerouting, effective load distribution with guaranteed bandwidth and a simpler network with lower OPEX.
About this talk
Today, we are moving towards a digital remote world where bandwidth demand is going to be humongous, and we need to remain prepared for it by upgrading our networks. New developments are happening in the field of information and communication technologies, but careful consideration needs to be done to decide which technology should be adapted at different layers - access, aggregation, and core area of the network.
The goal of this session is to establish the future possibilities that 5G can bring for us, but it also highlights that essential steps should be taken in the right direction so that 5G can achieve what it promises. Even though massive Optical Network deployment can be time-consuming and costly, but it is a wise and important decision to address the insatiable bandwidth demands in this virtual world.
It’s a thing of the past that fiber-optic networks and wireless networks were thought of as competing technologies, but today, they are required to work together to offer a more cohesive internet experience across fixed and mobile applications. As the fifth generation of mobile internet connectivity promises greater bandwidth, ultra-low latency, and massive machine-type communication, let’s understand how the future lies in fiber-optic technologies to achieve an ever-connected world driven by IoT, AI, ML, AR and VR.
How software-defined networks end vendor lock-in (76 s)
Speaker 1: Hello, everyone. A very warm welcome to all of you to the global women tech network conference 2022. I'm Richa Daga. I'm a technical speaker, author, mentor, and an engineer by heart. I'm passionate about technologies and chipsets that connect the world. I'm working as a software engineer at Cisco and have a decade of experience. in development of packet optical products that are building the internet of the future. I'm really excited to get this wonderful opportunity to interact with all of you here, people who are as passionate about technology and believe in advancing the cause of women in tech as I do. So please join me for this session to take a journey into network modernization for 5G and beyond.
Speaker 1: In this session, we will cover 5G service types, the evolution challenges in the way of 5G insights into radio signal processing stack and edge infrastructure. And most importantly, the need to upgrade networks by designing a new fabric architecture for making 5G possible. So 5G is the fifth generation of cellular technology. And it's Speaker 1: This is getting widely deployed around the world today. So let's understand what all is possible with 5G coming in. So these are the use cases that you can see on the screen. Mobile broadband. It addresses the human centric use cases of 5G for access to multimedia content services and data for better and faster connectivity to handle higher quality video content. So EMBB that is enhanced mobile broadband is
Speaker 1: Natural evolution to existing 4G networks that is faster and will provide a better user experience than current mobile broadband services. The key criteria which is enabled by this use case is seamless coverage. So the use cases for EMBB are like video streaming. So I think the way you and I are interacting today is video streaming. So that becomes faster and more effective in 5G comes in. So lightening fast browsing Speaker 2: Such use cases such use cases are important, which are enabled by enhanced mobile broadband. But do you think that these use cases are mission critical?
Speaker 1: For instance, if network latency occurs and results in an additional half second to download a video or render a web page, it will probably not ruin the customer experience. But in preventing a traffic accident or running an industrial robot, that half second becomes so important. Speaker 1: So in scenarios like those delay and failure are not an option. So that's why come the next use case of 5G that is ultra reliable low latency communication. Your LLC can support real time mission critical communication like autonomous driving industrial robotic automation and emergency disaster response. So the tactile response time with this use case is expected to be less than one millisecond.
Speaker 1: So this use case has stringent requirement for capabilities such as throughput latency and availability. Some examples that fall in this category are wireless control or of industrial manufacturing or production processes remote medical surgery. So I think this is one of the use case which have which we have been thinking a lot during the pandemic like if we can have remote medical surgeries taking place. And that can only be enabled if there is ultra low latency in communication. So smart grades, transportation safety are all enabled with this use case. The third use case is MMTC, that is machine type communication. This is the key technology needed to scale up the internet of things from its current limited use to its general use by enterprises and even the public entities. So this can help to achieve massive internet of
things. MIOT can serve that is massive internet of things MIOT can serve billions of low-cost long-range and energy efficient connected devices across remote applications as well as cloud locations. So now coming to the main point, we discussed about these 5G service types. This is everything that is the magic of 5G which is brought to us. But why are we talking about network modernity?
So what is the need of it? Aren't our existing networks enough to achieve all of the requirements of today's digital world? So I believe not. Here are some of the statistics. By 2023, if you would imagine, 66% of the global population will be connected to the internet. So if so many of the users will be connected to the internet, you can imagine the amount of bandwidth that is required to support all of them.
And global fixed broadband speed will reach 110.4 Mbps and connection speed will reach 575 Mbps in 5G. So the networks are facing, they are on the verge of facing unabated growth. And hence, there comes the need of network modernization. So what did you think? Like augmented reality, virtual reality, IoT, artificial intelligence, edge computing, all the latest technology, all the buzzwords that you have been hearing a lot. Nothing can't survive without bandwidth. So which is possible if we have robust networks? So the successful operators, which you see, they run profitable businesses that rely on revenue from attractive service products that address both the consumer and the enterprise.
market. So today's consumer products, they integrate voice and data playing, whereas enterprise products tend to focus on the needs of businesses. So increasingly, operators are giving us capabilities that allow other businesses to work. So network requirements are everywhere today. So 5G networking is designed to address service creation capabilities with features in both the radio and the radio.
network access network known as 5G core network known as 5G core network known as 5G C or the 5G core. So everything if we have been talking about network modernization, why the question always is like, if we want to understand anything, we should always go into the depth that why is it required? It is required because obviously, there would have been some challenges in evolving to 5G. The promise of 5G.
5G is of a system integrating with the new radio interface that is defined for a broad variety of use cases. So the network, it has to offer lower operational expenses that is OPEX and better control over CAPEX costs throughout the mobile supply chain. So a monolithic functional implementation, such as the base transceiver station is an example of why the current mobile supply chain is outdated.
So with this implementation operators, so with this implementation operators today had to pick one vendor per market. But you know if there is no competition, there is no demand of vendors which is there. We get resoluted to only one single vendor which is available. So this happened and we had a limited set of applications that the operators can provide to their customers. So sometimes these vendor dependencies and lock-in can propagate into other domains when proprietary features are implemented.
So that's why to solve all of these problems came the software defined attributes of the emerging 5G solution set. So if a mobile network operator embraces the principles of disaggregation and decomposition that can have software defined attributes. So both of these principles are at the heart of what it means for a network to be software defined. It means that software is a separate purchasing decision decision from the hardware and that commercial off-the-shelf hardware are used wherever possible. So decomposition it means that the network architecture is built from modular elements that assemble into a whole through open and interoperable interfaces.
So that's why this helps to get over the existing problematic closed RAN. So with the help of open RAN alliance and by employing the principles of software disaggregation and leveraging decomposition which in the 5G system architecture is an attribute of both the radio access network as well as the core. It is possible to build an optimal architecture that addresses the OPEX So this is the OPEX and the CAPEX challenges. So this new RAN cloud architecture. So at the time of 4G we had 4 radio access networks which were distributed RAN but coming to the 5G we have centralized RAN. So this new cloud RAN architecture it addresses the challenges of building multi-vendor networks and harmonize to a common feature set. So one fundamental characteristic is the decomposition of the radio
The radio signal processing stack using standardized splits. So if you would see and understand here the radio signal processing stack decomposition it maps functions in the stack as follows. That is service delivery adaptation protocol or SDAP. It is in the new radios in the NR only. Packet data convergence protocol that is the PDCP and radio resource control that is the control function.
That is the control functions are mapped to the centralized units are mapped to the centralized unit. These stack functions are packet level manipulations that add timing and can be easily implemented in a virtualized environment. The mid-haul links. So if you would be hearing about cross-haul architectures. So they also come into place when 5G came in. They came in. Where the network divided into 3G came in. Where the network divided into front-haul mid-haul and the back-haul. So the mid-haul links that connect the centralized unit to the distributed units are defined.
CU location is excellent for deploying. CU location is excellent for deploying user plane functions. That is a UPF in the decomposed packet core architecture. The decomposed packet core is known as the CUPS that is the control and user plane separation in 3GVP release 14 and 5GC in 3GVP R15. The radio link control RLC and medium access control MAC and the file layers map to a distributed unit. The DU performs significant preparation for the RF layer, including rate adaptation, channel coding, modulation, and scheduling.
So the baseband radio functions. So the baseband radio functions, up and down conversion and amplification along with analog beam forming map into a remote unit deployed at the cell site are known as the remote radio heads. So if you would see what happened used to happen in 5G, we had a BBU that was the baseband unit, but with the coming of the 5G CRAM that BBU became decentralized and disintegrated into distributed unit and centralized unit.
So the interface that was existing previously used previously used between the radio unit and the BBU was the SIPRI, that is centralized packet radio interface. But this SIPRI cannot be enhanced and used for the 5G architectures because it cannot cater to the huge bandwidth demand that 5G brings in front of us. So that's why it came into the picture eSIPRI, which is used in the front hall networks.
So if you would see here in the next slide, this is the edge infrastructure. This is this enables us to achieve the ultra ultra reliable low latency use cases of 5G. So the decomposition and the disaggregation of 5G, which were the software defined networking attribute. They only enabled a major architectural shift to an edge infrastructure that combines decomposed subscriber management with access functionality.
So as the RAN and the core become decomposed, it's become logical to create an intermediate location. This location would consolidate the centralized unit workloads and a user plane function from the mobile core. So you can see here, this is the edge cloud in the figure. And I think this edge cloud deserves a complete separate session of its own if I would want to describe what it is.
But the point is that because of the 5G having software defined attributes, the edge cloud became possible and it facilitated offloading and enabled local virtualized services at a metro level. So these are the interfaces that I explained in the previous slide. If you would see here, that is the 4G C RAN that had the base band unit, but with the 5G coming in this base band unit become this aggregated and decentralized into the distributed unit and the centralized unit and the link between them is called as the front hall.
The initial link that describes the link between the radio unit and the distributed unit is the front hall. And what we need today in network modernization is easy to support it. So if we move further, as we talked about the edge, so the attribute of the edge actually is bandwidth reduction. So it performs computation at the edge itself to reduce bandwidth.
And for example, for virtual reality applications, if you would see the edge can compute a field of view that would otherwise have to be computed from massive amount of data associated to all the possible horizontal and vertical fields of view. So in edge computing, the operator deploys a 5G core user plane function that is the UPF and strategically located parts of the network where a hosting environment for the cloud computing is also deployed.
So the same cloud environment can support the 5G infrastructure workload such as the upper layer of the new radio signal processing stack as well as the UPF. So this is the same cloud architecture that we talked about, which becomes of prime importance is it supports the horizontal scaling of a virtualized run infrastructure and provides a cost effect scaling of high speed 10, 25 or 100 gigi interface that are needed to handle 5G speeds.
So this solution is differentiated with the use of segment routing. So this is another important criteria that needs to be understood that is coming up in the 5G world. That is the segment which supports overlay networking, network slicing and traffic segmentation within the fabric and in the transport network. So policies and intent can be encoded in the segment routing header and propagated throughout the network.
So this is a simplified representation of segment routing through our MPLS network. And the benefits are such that the biggest packet networks in the world by node counts mobile networks are well suited to the benefits of the segment routing because segment information is embedded in the segment routing header at the ingress router R1 in which you will see.
So it defines an explicit path to the destination router via intermediate routers that is the R2 and R3. So SR that is the segment routing brought us a lot of benefits such as network slicing, addressing the network scale. It simplified the network for us and reduced the OPEX. Other benefits are it made the networks very resilient, providing fast rerouting and protection that is superior to the current levels of router protection.
Network utilization became wonders because it helped us to effectively distribute load while guaranteeing bandwidth to mid and critical applications. Network topology, it enabled the multi access edge computing use case. So this is finally the summary of what all we talked about in this quick session. And that is that the cloud network has to be fully virtualized from the RAN to the core.
If we want to reap in the benefits of 5G and with this disruptive architecture in place, we can enable applications such as fixed wireless low latency services and rich media. And all of this also enables mobile access that is edge computing infrastructure that enables the best possible user experience. So I tried to sum all of this that is network modernization required for 5G in these slides.
I know the technical session, we cannot cover all of these details associated in depth. But if you would want to know more about it, you can connect to me further at LinkedIn and I would be able, excessively eager to tell you what are the technological advancements that are happening in Cisco and the other companies and what all is needed and what all is happening.
In the world of 5G to enable high speed bandwidth. And if you have any questions right now, you can connect to me with in the chat section and I would be here to answer them. Thanks a lot for being with me here throughout the session. Thank you women in technology for giving us this opportunity to interact with like minded people who are so passionate about technology and advancing women in tech.
Thanks a lot. We'll see you next time.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why 5G cannot keep its promises without rebuilding the network underneath
Cisco software engineer Richa Daga explains how disaggregation, Open RAN, edge cloud and segment routing turn 5G from a promise into a working network.
In short
5G promises more bandwidth, ultra-low latency and massive machine communication, but Richa Daga argues that today's networks cannot deliver any of it as they stand. In this technical talk, the Cisco software engineer shows why operators must move from monolithic, single-vendor equipment to a software-defined, fully virtualized network, from the radio access network all the way to the core. Her roadmap runs through disaggregation, Open RAN, a decomposed radio stack, edge cloud and segment routing.
Key takeaways
Understand the need for network evolution.
Learn how to support legacy networks and enable a smooth transition to a virtual world without numerous outages.
Know the criteria for selecting different technologies and the future possibilities of 5G.
See how AR, VR, IoT and AI success is linked to having a robust network backbone.
Consider how to protect data in the virtual world and address cybersecurity issues.
Three kinds of 5G, three different demands
Daga opens with the three 5G service types, because each one places different pressure on the network. Enhanced mobile broadband (eMBB) is the natural evolution of 4G: faster video streaming, faster browsing and seamless coverage for human-centric use. Then she poses a question that frames the rest of the talk: are those use cases mission critical?
Her answer draws a sharp line. "For instance, if network latency occurs and results in an additional half second to download a video or render a web page, it will probably not ruin the customer experience. But in preventing a traffic accident or running an industrial robot, that half second becomes so important." (2:33)
That is the territory of ultra-reliable low latency communication (URLLC), which supports autonomous driving, industrial automation, emergency disaster response and remote medical surgery, with a tactile response time expected to be under one millisecond. "So in scenarios like those delay and failure are not an option." (2:33) The third type, massive machine type communication, is what Daga describes as the key to scaling the Internet of Things to billions of low-cost, long-range, energy-efficient devices.
Why today's networks fall short
With the promise laid out, Daga turns to the problem. "Aren't our existing networks enough to achieve all of the requirements of today's digital world? So I believe not." (4:52) As she cited, 66% of the global population is projected to be connected to the internet by 2023, with global fixed broadband speeds reaching 110.4 Mbps and 5G connection speeds reaching 575 Mbps. Augmented reality, virtual reality, IoT, AI and edge computing all depend on that bandwidth, and so on robust networks.
The deeper obstacle is structural. Monolithic implementations such as the traditional base transceiver station meant operators had to pick one vendor per market. Without competition, operators were tied to a single supplier, offered a limited set of applications, and saw vendor lock-in spread into other domains when proprietary features were implemented. At the same time, 5G networks must offer lower operating expenses (OPEX) and better control over capital costs (CAPEX).
Breaking the lock: disaggregation, decomposition and Open RAN
Daga's answer is the software-defined network, built on two principles. Disaggregation means software becomes a separate purchasing decision from the hardware, with commercial off-the-shelf hardware used wherever possible. Decomposition is the other half: "So decomposition it means that the network architecture is built from modular elements that assemble into a whole through open and interoperable interfaces." (8:07)
With the O-RAN Alliance and these principles applied to both the radio access network and the core, she explains, operators can build multi-vendor networks that address OPEX and CAPEX challenges. Where 4G used a distributed RAN, 5G moves to a centralized cloud RAN. The old baseband unit is split into a centralized unit, which handles packet-level functions such as SDAP, PDCP and radio resource control and is easily virtualized, and a distributed unit, which handles RLC, MAC and physical layer work such as channel coding, modulation and scheduling. Remote radio heads at the cell site take care of up and down conversion, amplification and analog beamforming. The network divides into fronthaul, midhaul and backhaul, and because the older CPRI interface cannot cater to 5G's bandwidth demands, eCPRI is used in the fronthaul.
Edge cloud: computing closer to the user
Decomposition unlocks the next shift. "So as the RAN and the core become decomposed, it's become logical to create an intermediate location." (13:00) This edge cloud consolidates centralized unit workloads and the user plane function from the mobile core, enabling offloading and local virtualized services at a metro level. It is what makes the ultra-reliable low latency use cases achievable.
Daga highlights bandwidth reduction as its defining attribute: "So it performs computation at the edge itself to reduce bandwidth." (14:07) For virtual reality, the edge can compute a user's field of view instead of moving massive amounts of data for every possible horizontal and vertical view. The same cloud environment can host both the upper layers of the radio stack and the user plane function, supporting horizontal scaling and cost-effective 10, 25 or 100 gigabit interfaces.
Segment routing and the bottom line
The final building block is segment routing, which supports overlay networking, network slicing and traffic segmentation. Policies and intent are encoded in the segment routing header at the ingress router and define an explicit path through the network. Daga lists the benefits: network slicing, scale, simplification and lower OPEX, fast rerouting and protection, and effective load distribution that still guarantees bandwidth for critical applications.
Her conclusion ties it together. "So this is finally the summary of what all we talked about in this quick session. And that is that the cloud network has to be fully virtualized from the RAN to the core." (16:59) With that architecture in place, she says, operators can enable fixed wireless, low latency services, rich media and edge computing for the best possible user experience.
Watch the talk
Network Modernisation for 5G and Beyond, Richa Daga, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/network-modernisation-5g-and-beyond-richa-daga
About the speaker
Richa Daga is a Software Engineer at Cisco with a Master of Technology in Networked Systems and vast experience in the telecom and optical networking domain, including earlier work at Ciena on products supporting data traffic up to terabits of speed. She chaired her alma mater's IEEE Women in Engineering group, is a core member of the She Speaks Bureau initiative, and is a technical author and IoT thought leader based in New Delhi, India.
Questions this talk answers
What are the main 5G service types?
Why can't existing networks simply carry 5G?
What do disaggregation and decomposition mean for a software-defined network?
What role does edge cloud play in 5G?
Why does segment routing matter for 5G networks?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Open RAN
Software-defined networking (disaggregation and decomposition)
Cloud RAN (C-RAN)
Control and user plane separation (CUPS)
Segment routing
eCPRI
Cite this talk
Richa Daga. "Network Modernisation for 5G and Beyond." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/network-modernisation-5g-and-beyond-richa-daga