How to be a Holistic Leader (And Why We Need More Holistic Leaders in Tech)
Melanie Margolin19:522023
Why the best leaders in tech refuse to stay in their lane
When she joined Thumbtack's legal function in December 2020, it was two white straight men; by being intentional about hiring, the team grew to ten, seven of them racially, ethnically and gender diverse. Chief Legal Officer Melanie Margolin argues that tech has a shortage of leaders who serve rather than dictate, and that anyone can fill the gap. So what does leading beyond your job description actually look like day to day?
Get three habits to connect across silos, mentor with intention and champion others
Melanie Margolin, Chief Legal Officer at Thumbtack, argues that every person is a leader regardless of title and that tech needs more holistic leaders who serve instead of dictate. She offers three practices: connect across boundaries, guide with intention through mentorship, and represent with pride by championing others, illustrated with her own hiring, mentoring and ERG sponsorship work.
“Good leadership is interested in service, not power. Good leaders guide and support.”
“Silos are great for storing things and from shielding them from the elements. But maybe you've noticed no one lives in a silo.”
What you will learn
Reframe your job as the hub of a wheel that connects ideas, people and platforms, not a box with fixed corners.
Apply an intentional hiring process: build the candidate pool through your network and wait until at least half of it is from underrepresented groups before reaching out.
Mentor at any level by treating mentoring as an equal learning relationship rather than a senior-to-junior one.
Use a one, three and five year career plan to help team members spot and close their career gaps.
Champion colleagues whose work happens behind the scenes by giving them visibility and speaking up for them at promotion time.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Understanding the principles of holistic leadership and how to implement them in your career, no matter your level of seniority
How to earn trust beyond your job description and inspire individuals across a company to get out of their comfort zone
How to connect across boundaries and build diverse networks and teams
The importance of mentorship and how to guide with intention, fostering equal learning relationships between mentor and mentee
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:52
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is a holistic leader?
Someone who uses their job not as a box to live in but as the center of a wheel connecting ideas, people and platforms. They serve wherever they are needed, whether or not it is in their lane.
Why does the tech industry have a leadership shortage?
Melanie says tech has plenty of people who tell others what to do, but too few leaders who inspire, make people better at their work or care about their careers.
How can a hiring manager build a diverse team without being an HR professional?
Treat hiring like a mission, build the pool through your own and your team's networks, review every resume, and do not contact anyone until at least half the pool is women, LGBTQ+, differently abled people, veterans or people of color.
Can someone early in their career be a mentor?
Yes. Melanie argues mentoring is not about who is senior or more successful but about guidance, so mentor and mentee can learn from each other equally at all levels.
What does it mean to represent with pride?
It means earning trust by showing up, sponsoring communities such as ERGs, and championing others' contributions when they are up for promotion, raises or visibility, pointing at teammates the way Abby Wambach did after every goal.
About this talk
The quality of leadership can make or break a company - it impacts everything from the products we build to the teams building them. But leadership doesn’t just fall on the C-Suite, it’s the responsibility of each one of us, regardless of job title or seniority. Enter the holistic leader - someone who inspires teams and seeks to serve in every capacity they can. Join Melanie Margolin, Thumbtack Chief Legal Officer and seasoned business leader and legal professional, to discuss the principles of holistic leadership and how it can help you build more successful, diverse and inclusive teams while earning trust beyond your job description.
I'm Melanie Margolin, my pronouns are she/her/hers, and I'm the Chief Legal Officer at Thumbtack. We're a technology-driven platform that helps people care for their homes from top to bottom. Being the Chief Legal Officer at Thumbtack is only one role I play there, though. I'm also a mentor, an ERG executive sponsor, and an outspoken ally across the entire organization.
You could say that I'm someone who rarely stays in my lane, which is something I credit for much of the success I've had in my career. So I want to dive right in. I'm going to ask you a question, and feel free to just think about it for a moment. Normally we could put it in chat or I could see raised hands, but I don't have that opportunity here.
So just think, how many of you here would consider yourself a company-wide leader? When I ask people this question one-on-one, I often get tentative looks and very few acknowledgements that they are company leaders. But what I hope is that by the end of this talk, everyone will feel like they're company leaders, and you'll all be raising your hands to dive right in.
Because whether it feels like it now or not, every single one of us is a leader. I don't care what your job title is, or a list of projects that you're working on day to day. We're all leaders. And today, I want us to start thinking of ourselves as the right kind of leaders. Because what we all know from sometimes painful experience is we have a leader shortage in the tech industry.
Well, let me be clear about that. We have no shortage of people who think they can just tell us what to do and how to do it. But that is not what great leaders do. And we don't have an abundance of leaders in tech who inspire us or make us better at our work. We don't seem to have folks who care about what we want from our careers or how they can help us be our best.
So instead of relying on the status quo leader, we need to focus on what good leadership is and how we can help cultivate it in others. To me, it's pretty simple. Good leadership is interested in service, not power. Good leaders guide and support. They do not dictate. And good leaders ask, what can I do to help you be great, not what have you done for me lately?
I have 25 years of business and legal experience, and I've been an executive for about 10 of those years. But I only just joined the tech industry in 2020. I quickly realized that we're not doing nearly enough to demand and provide good leadership to our people in this field. This slide shows some women who I love as leaders and role models.
While we do see some examples of inspiring women and people of color in leadership roles, if we look hard enough, there just aren't enough of us, especially in tech. And frankly, this strikes me as kind of crazy, because the quality of leadership can make or break a company. I would argue this is true even more than our products and services at times.
We can use technology to build amazing things, but we simply cannot automate good leadership. It's a human calling, a passion, something that sets some of us on fire in the mornings. And it's hard, let's be honest, because when it's done well, it's an intentional act, and one where you, not the bot, have to show up every day.
As I have tried to show up every day, there are two pieces of advice I've heard over and over in my career. One I try to follow, and the other I intentionally disregard. The first is, don't be afraid to try something new. And the second is, stay in your lane. Do these sound familiar? The first is clearly better for you than the second, but I want you to take both to heart.
I want all of us to walk away this afternoon fired up to lead, and to figure out how you can be the kind of leader that anyone can come to, and someone who everyone seeks out. So I believe these two pieces of advice, both the one I follow and the one I definitely don't, show us how to be the highest possible form of leader.
The holistic leader. Now what do I mean when I say holistic leader? I mean someone who uses their job, not as a box to live in, but as the center of a wheel, or a great connector of ideas and people and platforms. When you think about the wheel, it's one of the simplest, yet most profound inventions that we have.
It has a hub at its center, and from that hub there are spokes or blades that expand out in all directions. Because there are no corners, every part has to move in sync together. And because of that, when the wheel revolves, it takes you and all of your spokes anywhere you want to go. I often tell people that being a holistic leader means living beyond the four corners of your job, and considering the whole highway your lane.
But the larger truth is, as you lead, there should be no corners at all. You should seek to serve in every capacity where you can, where you're needed, in places where gaps exist, on projects or initiatives that ignite your energy, regardless of whether it's your actual job description or whether it's in your lane. The chances are that things that make you the happiest as a leader are those things that have the absolute highest impact for your company, and the people with whom you work, and the people you serve.
Take Megan Rapinoe for example. While she is an incredible soccer player, her social activism and equal pay work are her long-term passions. And what a difference she has made by stepping outside her soccer lane. While we can't all be as cool as Megan Rapinoe, let me start by giving you three straightforward ways you can start being a holistic leader today.
The first one is to connect across boundaries. I think one of the biggest threats to our society right now is fear. We're afraid of each other. We don't trust each other, and we don't even talk to each other, even though we have the power to connect to anyone and everyone 24/7. We don't always do that. And when we do it, we don't always do it well. We choose what we know, and we stay in our silos.
I get it. It's nice and safe in our silos. I'm actually from the Midwest. I lived in Indiana for over 20 years. We have silos everywhere. Silos are great for storing things and from shielding them from the elements. But maybe you've noticed no one lives in a silo. So why should someone work in one? And what kind of leader can you possibly be if your entire world is inside a silo?
We need to be better than that. We need to build a network that reflects our belief that we have something to offer everyone. We need to connect across boundaries and learn from everyone. These connections can be life changing. I take my personal connections and network very seriously. And some of it dates all the way back to when I was in college or law school.
So it's never too early to start building your network. Connections with other people are what drive good business. As an example, I've created a diverse network of professionals in my life who I always think about and for whom I like to make connections. This includes people who I may not initially have had that much in common with.
As you can imagine, these connections come in handy a lot, especially when we're trying to work our way through career decisions and complex problems at work, and also when it's time to hire someone. Throughout my career, I've developed a process for making connections and building high performing diverse teams. It's one of the things and recognitions I'm most proud of across my whole career.
At Thumbtack, we've turned this process into something we call simply Hire Life Melanie. And quickly, here's what I do. First, I treat hiring like a mission. The end goal is to find a top notch person for the job. Next, I build a candidate pool as much as I can through my network and my team's network. The hiring process is not a lottery. It should not be a game of chance.
So I personally view every single resume that comes in because thinking ahead, I want to look back and say I did everything I could to ensure the candidate pool was highly qualified and diverse. Then we don't reach out to one person until at least half of our candidates in the pool are LGBTQ plus or women or differently abled people or veterans or people of color.
My whole team follows this process. And once we have a diverse pool, then we dive in and start the interview process. This intentional approach of connecting across boundaries, it works. I joined a team of two white straight men in the legal function of Thumbtack in December of 2020. As we built our team up to a small but mighty 10, it's made up of seven racially, ethnically and gender diverse teammates simply by being intentional.
Now, here's one last thing to remember about this philosophy. I'm not an HR professional. I'm not certified in recruiting or human capital. And so some would tell me this is not my lane to be in, but obviously I disagree. This is why connecting across boundaries is so important. I have built and I continue to cultivate the kind of network that reflects who I am and what my values are.
This is a holistic leadership approach to connection. I'm a better lawyer for connecting with all of these folks through my career. And frankly, I'm a better person for it, too. I'm sure you will be as well if you give it a try. And through these connections, you'll find not only new hires, but people to mentor, people to mentor you and business connections who can help advance your career at some point.
So the second way to be a holistic leader is to guide with intention. I'm a big believer in the power of formal mentorship in the workplace. A holistic leader understands the continuous growth of new and traditionally underrepresented talent is a team sport. And it happens at all levels through mentorship. If any of you are thinking right now that you couldn't possibly contribute to another person's success, I'm going to respectfully disagree with you.
You absolutely can at all levels and in all roles. If done right, the mentor and mentee relationship can be something where you learn from each other equally. Because that relationship is not about who's senior and who's junior, which person is more successful and less. It's about providing guidance. It's about helping each other with new skills or seeing blind spots or planning for a future that we're all still uncertain about.
Everyone faces those challenges and everyone has a different point of view to share. That is why I consider mentoring a chance to guide and be guided with intention. Over the years, I've built unofficial mentor mentee relationships with people across businesses, financial controllers, engineers, sales and marketing folks, everything in between. That's the beauty, I think, of a holistic approach to this.
I'm always grateful for the time I spend with mentors and mentees. And this is particularly true for every conversation I have with someone outside my lane. Because those folks add another spoke to my wheel and another skill to my toolbox. So let me give you a few examples of intentionally guiding someone in action. When I was at a previous company, I started a simple one, three, five year career plan method with my team.
This helped them identify and fill their career gaps so that as time passed, they were getting more opportunity and driving hard on new goals that they had set for themselves. Being intentional in their career plans and setting aside time to work through the gaps was new for these folks. And when they started doing this, they were more connected to the company and to the company's leaders than they had been before.
They had a real sense of belonging and inclusion in the whole company. When I got to Thumbtack, I wondered if I could take this a step further. So last year we launched Mentoring with Melanie. It was a five part group mentorship series and showcase to dive into topics that you would normally find in formal mentorship. On some of these sessions, we had over 150 people.
It was clear there was an appetite for this type of mentorship and guidance from people at all levels and through all departments. And I get that. I spent years in the legal profession and in the manufacturing industry, often as the only female voice in the room. And sometimes I was decades younger than those around me. There were next to no people of color in leadership positions and very few, if any, LGBTQ plus folks who were lawyers or partners or managers.
I want to give visibility to people like me, strong gay female talent or people who are adjacent to me and also underrepresented in their own right. This program did just that. I was 15 years into my career before I found a true mentor. It wasn't Jane Lynch, but it was someone who was very happy to yell out through a bullhorn things I should do to improve myself and fill my career gaps.
Thanks to her, I became the general counsel of a publicly traded company five years after working for her. Of course, we should recognize that good mentorship will not solve every issue our industry has, but it is a concrete way for each one of us to actively lift each other up, learn new skills and find solutions to problems that we all share.
And this leads me to my third point about being a holistic leader. How do you actually represent others well? Well, I say we should all represent with pride. The currency of leadership is trust, and there are simply no shortcuts there. You have to show up, you have to do the work, and you have to earn the trust.
People need to know you and see in you someone they can trust and follow. Sometimes that comes in the form of seeing someone who looks like you, or has the job you want down the road, or someone who simply has that charisma or personality that opens the first door. At Thumbtack, I was immediately drawn to the great culture.
It was easy to want to learn the people. I joined our ProudTacks employee resource group as an executive sponsor, and as a member of that community, I was representing this ERG in our senior leadership meetings every day, getting to know the folks and being able to help push them forward in their careers. Now, two years later, I probably spend 50% of my time as a holistic leader working on company-wide initiatives, not just legal, and representing as many folks as possible.
I recently became this executive sponsor for our Black employee resource group as well. So I'm cultivating relationships all the time across the entire company. One important part of being a holistic leader is being a champion for others, speaking up and out about people's contributions when they're up for promotion or raises or need more visibility. When I first went in-house and was working in a corporate legal department, I worked with a mid-level associate at a huge law firm named Lauren.
Lauren was super smart and responsive and fun to work with, but her work was really behind the scenes. Eventually, I wanted to bring her up front so that more people could see what she was doing. I made that happen through working with her firm. And when she was considered for a big promotion years later, I could write a recommendation about the years of experience I had with her, being a wonderful client service representative.
When I see Lauren now advocating for her own team, I'm filled with enormous pride. Now, would Lauren have gotten to this point in her career if I hadn't represented her or promoted her or helped make her a priority? I'd like to think so, because she's talented, empathetic and hardworking. But sometimes that's not enough. Sometimes tomorrow's leaders need a champion today.
One of my favorite strong leaders is Abby Wambach. She's a former professional soccer player and one of the most scoring soccer players of all times. She wrote a book called Wolfpack and in that book, she says, you will not always be the goal scorer. When you are not, you better be rushing toward her. Sometimes you will be the goal scorer.
If you watch footage of any of my goals, you'll see the moment after I score, I begin to point. I point to the teammate who assisted. I point to the defender who protected us. I point to the midfielder who ran tirelessly. Every goal I've ever scored belonged to my entire team. So when you score, you better start pointing.
In other words, Abby believes you should be a champion for other people's hard work. In your companies, what if every day we started pointing? What if we point at the colleague who did a great job, but did so behind the scenes? What if we speak up and point to the woman down the hall who never gets invited to lunch?
What if we point to all of our underrepresented colleagues who start at the new company ready to give their all? And what if we keep pointing at them and including them and coaching and mentoring them? What if instead of an industry where the majority employees have always had more opportunities than the women and underrepresented ones? What if we all chose to point at our colleagues who make a difference by being inclusive and going out of their way to uplift others?
I have always believed in taking responsibility for my team and giving more credit to them than they may even deserve if something goes right. I think I point a lot. For me, being a holistic leader and a damn good pointer is about looking at the bigger picture and finding ways to make the biggest impact. For me, I like to raise diversity and inclusion issues when we're making decisions about the business or staffing or initiatives.
I'm someone that can be counted on, a wheel constantly in motion to represent all of our employees. You can be that too, and I hope that you want to be. Quickly, in closing, I want you to remember three things. When we connect across boundaries, we create a diverse network with common ground for everyone. When we guide with intention, we foster an equitable learning relationship between everyone, regardless of who's involved.
And when we represent with pride, we ensure that everyone is included, heard, and over time, we have more diverse leaders who are ready to listen and act. This is holistic leadership, and this is what I've been chasing and measuring myself against all of these years. If you pick only one of these things and implement it at your company, change will happen.
Leadership will find you, and you will find what it is to lead. And I would love to hear about it. Seriously, here's my email. Reach out and tell me what you did and how it went. Now, let's all get out there, tear down our silos, stay out of our assigned lanes, and let's point like crazy to everyone who's helping us be the best leader, teammate, and person we can be.
Thank you so much for having me. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why every person in tech should lead beyond their job description
Thumbtack's Chief Legal Officer Melanie Margolin makes the case for holistic leaders who connect, mentor and champion others regardless of title.
In short
Melanie Margolin, Chief Legal Officer at Thumbtack, believes that everyone is a leader, whatever their title, and that tech urgently needs more leaders who serve rather than dictate. Her answer is the holistic leader: someone who treats their job as the hub of a wheel rather than a box, and who connects across boundaries, guides with intention and represents others with pride.
Key takeaways
Understand the principles of holistic leadership and how to implement them in your career, no matter your level of seniority.
Learn how to earn trust beyond your job description and inspire people across a company to get out of their comfort zone.
Learn how to connect across boundaries and build diverse networks and teams.
See the importance of mentorship and how to guide with intention, fostering equal learning relationships between mentor and mentee.
Tech has a leadership shortage
Margolin opens by asking viewers whether they consider themselves company-wide leaders. In one-on-one conversations, she says, the answer is usually a hesitant no. Her goal is to change that, because in her view the industry lacks the right kind of leaders. There is no shortage of people ready to tell others what to do, she argues, but far fewer who inspire colleagues or care about their careers.
Her definition is simple: "Good leadership is interested in service, not power. Good leaders guide and support." (1:57)
Margolin brings an outsider's eye. She has 25 years of business and legal experience, about ten of them as an executive, but only joined the tech industry in 2020. She points out that technology cannot fix this gap on its own: "We can use technology to build amazing things, but we simply cannot automate good leadership." (3:11)
The wheel, not the box
Two pieces of career advice frame the talk. Margolin follows the first, "don't be afraid to try something new," and deliberately ignores the second, "stay in your lane." Together they lead to what she calls the highest form of leader.
She describes the holistic leader as "someone who uses their job, not as a box to live in, but as the center of a wheel, or a great connector of ideas and people and platforms." (4:22) A wheel has no corners, so every spoke moves in sync. In practice, that means serving wherever there are gaps or projects that energise you, regardless of your job description. She uses Megan Rapinoe as an example of someone whose impact grew by stepping outside her soccer lane into equal pay activism.
Connect across boundaries
The first practice is about leaving the comfort of the familiar. Margolin, who lived in Indiana for over 20 years, draws on a Midwestern image: "Silos are great for storing things and from shielding them from the elements. But maybe you've noticed no one lives in a silo." (6:39)
She takes her own network seriously, some of it dating back to college and law school, and deliberately includes people she did not initially have much in common with. That network pays off most visibly in hiring. At Thumbtack her approach became a process the team calls Hire Like Melanie: treat hiring as a mission, build the candidate pool through personal and team networks, review every resume personally, and wait until at least half of the pool is women, LGBTQ+, differently abled people, veterans or people of color before contacting anyone. "The hiring process is not a lottery. It should not be a game of chance." (8:12)
The results, as she describes them: she joined a legal team of two white straight men in December 2020, and as it grew to ten, seven teammates were racially, ethnically and gender diverse. She notes that she is not an HR professional, which is exactly the point of refusing to stay in her lane.
Guide with intention
The second practice is mentorship, which Margolin sees as a team sport that happens at every level. She pushes back on anyone who thinks they have nothing to offer: the relationship "is not about who's senior and who's junior," but about helping each other build skills, see blind spots and plan for an uncertain future.
At a previous company she introduced a one, three and five year career plan for her team, which helped people identify and close their career gaps and left them more connected to the company. At Thumbtack she launched Mentoring with Melanie, a five-part group mentorship series that drew over 150 people to some sessions. Her motivation is personal: she spent years as often the only female voice in the room, and wants to give visibility to "strong gay female talent or people who are adjacent to me and also underrepresented in their own right." She found a true mentor only 15 years into her career, and became general counsel of a publicly traded company five years after working for her.
Represent with pride, and start pointing
The third practice rests on trust. "The currency of leadership is trust, and there are simply no shortcuts there." (14:14) Margolin became executive sponsor of the ProudTacks employee resource group and later the Black employee resource group, and says she now spends about half of her time on company-wide initiatives rather than legal work alone.
Being a champion means speaking up for people when they are up for promotion or need visibility. She tells the story of Lauren, a talented law firm associate whose work was behind the scenes until Margolin brought it forward and later wrote her a recommendation. Talent alone is not always enough: "Sometimes tomorrow's leaders need a champion today." (16:14)
She closes this section with Abby Wambach's book Wolfpack, in which the soccer player describes pointing to the teammates who assisted every goal. Margolin turns that into a challenge for workplaces: point at the colleague who works behind the scenes, the woman who never gets invited to lunch, and the underrepresented new starters ready to give their all. If you implement even one of the three practices, she says, change will happen.
Watch the talk
"How to be a Holistic Leader (And Why We Need More Holistic Leaders in Tech)" by Melanie Margolin, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-be-holistic-leader-and-why-we-need-more-holistic-leaders-in-tech
About the speaker
Melanie Margolin is Chief Legal Officer at Thumbtack, where she has also served in an interim Head of Operations role. She has over 20 years of experience leading legal teams and advising executive teams at large public companies, including negotiating multi-billion-dollar commercial agreements, M&A transactions and major litigation settlements.
Questions this talk answers
What is a holistic leader?
Why does the tech industry have a leadership shortage?
How can a hiring manager build a diverse team without being an HR professional?
Can someone early in their career be a mentor?
What does it mean to represent with pride?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Holistic leadership (connect across boundaries, guide with intention, represent with pride)
One, three, five year career plan
Hire Like Melanie
Mentoring with Melanie
Resources mentioned
Wolfpack (book by Abby Wambach)
Cite this talk
Melanie Margolin. "How to be a Holistic Leader (And Why We Need More Holistic Leaders in Tech)." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-be-holistic-leader-and-why-we-need-more-holistic-leaders-in-tech