0:0019:33

Designing For The Ten Percent: How To Unbias Your Designs

Jasmine Orange 19:33 2020

To design without bias, designers have to stop relying on empathy

A driver who is 5'2" sits so close to the steering wheel that the airbag, not the crash, can be what kills her, because crash test dummies aren't normally made for that seat. UX designer Jasmine Orange of Ernst & Young, trained in industrial design, finds the same blind spot in stairs, iOS 7 animations and public restrooms. If designers can't check their own unconscious biases, what should they do instead?

Learn why compassion, diverse teams and designing for the margins work better than empathy alone

Watch on YouTube

In short

UX designer Jasmine Orange argues that design picks up the conscious and unconscious biases of the people who make it, and that designing for an imagined average user harms the most marginalized "10%", sometimes fatally. She suggests designers lead with compassion rather than empathy, build diverse teams that can spot each other's blind spots, and design for the margins, which ends up helping everyone.

“But in order for us to design without bias, we have to get rid of the idea of empathy.”
“A lot of times you hear, I'm not the user, but I feel like we should take that a step further. It's, I'm not that person.”

What you will learn

  • Distinguish conscious from unconscious bias and see how each one gets into a design process.
  • Recognize how designing for an imagined average user can make products annoying, unusable or even deadly.
  • Replace empathy-only thinking with compassion by admitting you are not the user and trusting what users tell you.
  • Build diverse design teams that can catch the unconscious biases you cannot see in yourself.
  • Recruit research participants who are the opposite of your assumed user, from discovery onward.

Details

Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career
Length
19:33
Published
July 2020

Questions this talk answers

Who are the 10% in design?

They are the most marginalized people, not the wealthy elite. Conscious and unconscious bias pushes them to the edge of designers' thinking.

Why isn't empathy enough to design without bias?

Designers cannot feel what another person feels, and no amount of research puts you in someone else's shoes. Orange argues for compassion instead: admitting you don't have the answers and trusting users when they say something is wrong.

How can a team catch biases it cannot see in itself?

You cannot check yourself for unconscious bias, but other people can. That is why design has to be done by everyone, with a diverse team that you trust to point out problems.

Does designing for marginalized users make products worse for everyone else?

No. Closed captions, push-to-open doors, voice features and reduced motion settings were designed for the 10% and now help the 90% too.

How do you build compassion into a UX process?

Bring in people of different backgrounds and abilities from the discovery phase onward, and look for people who are the opposite of your assumed user. Where you can, go to them in their own environment.

About this talk

Have you ever thought about how shorter people have to bring their seats so close to the steering wheel (and subsequently, the airbag) when driving? Have you noticed some people choose their phone based on what can comfortably fit in their hand and not the features? What about people who don’t fit the “societal ideal body type” and the difficulty in finding clothes? Have you noticed that websites of major companies are being sued for things like the color of text?

Our society, and the people in it, have biases. And because design is people-centric, it can also have biases. In this talk, we will be discussing what biases in design look like and what the consequences can be when someone doesn’t recognize that bias can greatly change your design process and outcome: From lack of usability to even potential harm. We will talk about how these “edge cases” or “10% restraints” mentioned above are more common than we even realize. We will also discuss what happens when designers remove those biases and what great good can be done when designing for the 1%.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library