Designing For The Ten Percent: How To Unbias Your Designs
Jasmine Orange19:332020
To design without bias, designers have to stop relying on empathy
A driver who is 5'2" sits so close to the steering wheel that the airbag, not the crash, can be what kills her, because crash test dummies aren't normally made for that seat. UX designer Jasmine Orange of Ernst & Young, trained in industrial design, finds the same blind spot in stairs, iOS 7 animations and public restrooms. If designers can't check their own unconscious biases, what should they do instead?
Learn why compassion, diverse teams and designing for the margins work better than empathy alone
UX designer Jasmine Orange argues that design picks up the conscious and unconscious biases of the people who make it, and that designing for an imagined average user harms the most marginalized "10%", sometimes fatally. She suggests designers lead with compassion rather than empathy, build diverse teams that can spot each other's blind spots, and design for the margins, which ends up helping everyone.
“But in order for us to design without bias, we have to get rid of the idea of empathy.”
“A lot of times you hear, I'm not the user, but I feel like we should take that a step further. It's, I'm not that person.”
What you will learn
Distinguish conscious from unconscious bias and see how each one gets into a design process.
Recognize how designing for an imagined average user can make products annoying, unusable or even deadly.
Replace empathy-only thinking with compassion by admitting you are not the user and trusting what users tell you.
Build diverse design teams that can catch the unconscious biases you cannot see in yourself.
Recruit research participants who are the opposite of your assumed user, from discovery onward.
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career
Length
19:33
Published
July 2020
Questions this talk answers
Who are the 10% in design?
They are the most marginalized people, not the wealthy elite. Conscious and unconscious bias pushes them to the edge of designers' thinking.
Why isn't empathy enough to design without bias?
Designers cannot feel what another person feels, and no amount of research puts you in someone else's shoes. Orange argues for compassion instead: admitting you don't have the answers and trusting users when they say something is wrong.
How can a team catch biases it cannot see in itself?
You cannot check yourself for unconscious bias, but other people can. That is why design has to be done by everyone, with a diverse team that you trust to point out problems.
Does designing for marginalized users make products worse for everyone else?
No. Closed captions, push-to-open doors, voice features and reduced motion settings were designed for the 10% and now help the 90% too.
How do you build compassion into a UX process?
Bring in people of different backgrounds and abilities from the discovery phase onward, and look for people who are the opposite of your assumed user. Where you can, go to them in their own environment.
About this talk
Have you ever thought about how shorter people have to bring their seats so close to the steering wheel (and subsequently, the airbag) when driving? Have you noticed some people choose their phone based on what can comfortably fit in their hand and not the features? What about people who don’t fit the “societal ideal body type” and the difficulty in finding clothes? Have you noticed that websites of major companies are being sued for things like the color of text?
Our society, and the people in it, have biases. And because design is people-centric, it can also have biases. In this talk, we will be discussing what biases in design look like and what the consequences can be when someone doesn’t recognize that bias can greatly change your design process and outcome: From lack of usability to even potential harm. We will talk about how these “edge cases” or “10% restraints” mentioned above are more common than we even realize. We will also discuss what happens when designers remove those biases and what great good can be done when designing for the 1%.
When the airbag is the danger for short drivers (77 s)
Why empathy can't put you in someone's shoes (82 s)
Designing for the 10% helps the 90% (79 s)
So my name is Jasmine Orange. I'm a UX designer for Ernst & Young. I studied industrial design at Virginia Tech. I don't know if you guys can hear that, but there's a storm brewing here in Atlanta. And because I have for a majority of my life done things, yes, go Hokies, done things involving design, I'm very, very into it. I am obsessed with design, especially design history.
And I love talking about blending the digital and the physical designs because there's a lot of overlap there. So that's one of my favorite things about being a designer is to talk about the things that you can see a lot of patterns in. But one of the patterns that I see a lot is designing for the 10%. And that's something that I learned in industrial design school.
So who is the 10%? So normally you hear the 10% and then you think to yourself, oh, that must mean the wealthy, that must mean the elite. But in school, I learned that the 10% are those that are actually the most marginalized. These are the people that are normally ostracized from our societies. And we are taught to normally forget that these people are there, which is ironic because these are the people that we should be protecting the most.
And so a lot of these people get pushed to the edge of our thought processes because of our conscious and unconscious bias against them. So conscious bias, unconscious bias, what do these terms mean? So Georgetown University talks about conscious bias like this. These are biases that are very clear to a person and their feelings and their attitudes and their relative behaviors are conducted with intent.
Where that these biases exist, whereas unconscious bias, these are a little harder for you to recognize. They're a lot harder for you to even be aware that you have them. And a lot of times it's because our society has taught us these unconscious biases and it's really hard for you to break away from the things that you've been taught essentially since birth and generationally.
Kind of the difference between conscious bias and unconscious bias. And because design is a job that is primarily performed by humans. And humans naturally have biases. It's easy then to assume that design has biases. So what does that look like? What happens when design bias starts to sneak into your designs and sneaks into the design process? What does that look like?
Well, design biases can range and it can take a product and range it from being just mildly annoying and difficult to use to even being deadly in a lot of cases. It can make it really hard for someone if when this project or this product was being designed, if they weren't on the forefront of the designers or the developers or that team's mind.
So now we're going to get into some examples because, again, I am a design nerd, so I have to talk about the examples. So the first one are stairs. Stairs were designed to get us from one level of grounding to another. But not everyone can use stairs. And as a matter of fact, it wasn't until the American Coalition of Citizens with Disabilities came along, which was a disabled rights organization.
And they had a sit in and they protest and they really pushed for the government to make it possible for us to have the Section 504 Act of 1973. And this was one of the first Disabilities Act in the world to set civil rights provisions for those with disabilities. And so without them, we wouldn't have ramps for people to do basic things like go into one building and out of another.
Another way that biases can show up is an animation design. So this is iOS 7 and the motion sickness of 2017. So back when iOS 7 came out, it was drastically different than iOS 6 because it had these things like zooming when you clicked on an app and there were parallaxes and there was sliding everywhere. So there was a lot of animation happening, which to someone who doesn't have a vestibular disability, you think to yourself, oh, this is cool.
This is so fun. This is great. But if you have something like motion sickness, they can make you really, really sick. And a lot of people were getting sick. A lot of people were using these animation designs and were getting extremely sick. And then if you have something like vertigo, it can make you pass out. It can really, really make you ill.
And so after that, after that caught wind, there were countless articles written about it. iOS, they had to go back and make some changes and Apple had to do some reworking on it. But, you know, that's one of the things that can happen on a digital side. And then you have things like crash test dummies. Whose bodies are these designed for?
Because a lot of times if you have a body that's bigger, taller, then it's probably designed for you. But if you have a shorter body, then you have to sit closer to the steering wheel. I'm very short. My older sister is shorter than me. I'm 5'2" and my older sister is 4'11". And we both sit extremely close to the steering wheel.
And crash test dummies aren't normally made for that kind of seating for you to sit so close. So then if we were to get into a car accident, you then have to assume that we're going to die from the car accident. And not because of the car wreck itself. A lot of times when you are shorter, you end up dying from the airbag being so close to your face and opening up so close to your face.
And so things like designing for different bodies is really important for things like safety. And then we have things like changing stations. The Babies Act of 2016 was a law that required there to be changing tables in public and accessible federal buildings. So up until 2016, there weren't changing tables in men's restrooms, which is very interesting to me.
I think just excluding an entire group of people from your family dynamic is strange. It was something that wasn't well thought out. And I'm not saying, oh, the designers on these projects were evil people or they purposely left out these people. It's probably that they just didn't think of these people. When they were designing something, they designed for what they think is the average person.
But if we live in a world with so many different kinds of people, then what does average look like? What does that even mean to be an average person? And so what do we do if we know that there are designs out there that can range from annoying to deadly? And we're designers and we want to make the world a better place.
How do we fix that, especially when some of these things have to do with unconscious biases that we can't check ourselves for? How do we fix these problems? So I know empathy is a really big thing in design. We always talk about the importance of being empathetic. But in order for us to design without bias, we have to get rid of the idea of empathy.
Empathy, by definition, means the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. It also means the action of understanding and being aware or being sensitive to or vicariously feeling thoughts and experiences that another person has. And the thing with that is I can't vicariously feel what another person feels. I can feel sad about something if someone else is sad, but it's not the same if that person I'm not going to have the exact same sadness.
I don't know what it's like to be in a different body. I don't know what it's like to have different abilities, to be a different height. And sure, in design, we can research these things, and we rely heavily on research. But I don't really think that research is the way that we should go with this. Research can help us for a leg of it, but no amount of research is going to put you in somebody else's shoes.
It's not going to put you in the same thoughts as someone else. So I think we should probably just do away with saying that empathy is what we should rely on. Instead, I think it's important that we lead with compassion, that we say to our users, to these people that are using these products that we're creating, I don't have all the answers.
I don't know what it's like to be you. I have no idea what you go through on a daily basis. I can try to understand it. I can do as much research and do in-depth analyses of it. I can even try to run tests where I put myself in similar positions as you, but it's not the same as being you.
And so I want to be able to lead with the compassion. So when a user is telling me, this is difficult, this is wrong, I don't understand this, you have to trust that they're telling you the truth. You have to trust that they aren't making this thing up, that they know more than I do because I'm not them.
A lot of times you hear, I'm not the user, but I feel like we should take that a step further. It's, I'm not that person. And so I think it's important for you to listen to people. And I mean like really listen, listen to what they say, watch what they're doing and ask them questions. Ask them, what do you mean by that? Like, I don't know. I know that I'm professionally this thing, but I'm not who you are.
So I think it's really important for us to talk about listening. And this one is really important to me. If you look at my website, any comment I've ever made on something, I say very often that design is for everyone. And when I say that, a lot of people think that I mean that design, the thing that I design is for everyone.
And that's partially true. That's half of it. The other half is design has to be done by everyone. Design is for everyone, both in your end goal of what you're creating, but also the people who are creating it. Like I said, I don't know what it's like to be a different person other than who I am. And so it's important for your team to have that kind of diversity so that you can design for that diversity.
If you want to get rid of your biases, this is the way to do it because you can't check yourself for your unconscious biases. But someone else can, someone who someone else can absolutely do that. And so in those examples that I just showed, these are examples of what happens when your team isn't diverse. So you have to be able to have a team that says, wait, I just want you to know, like, this doesn't make sense to me because of this reason.
This seems a little offensive and this is why and having those people that are there that you have that trust in who will check you on these things and tell you that biases here. So these are some examples of what happens when you do design for the 10%. A lot of people think that designing for the 10% is so hard that it's going to end up being something that's ugly or something that's not helpful for everyone else.
And it's the complete opposite. So things like closed captions, those were designed for people that can't hear. But there's a lot of people that use closed captions. I use closed captions all the time when I'm in the kitchen cooking and I want to watch Chalked but I can't hear because I'm clanking all the pans together. This is when I would use closed captions or sometimes the character is whispering.
Things like the push to operate door. If you have a lot of stuff in your hand and you need to be able to open the door but you can't pull the actual door handle, that's an example of you being temporarily disabled. And you needing to have that kind of assistance. And that's when having something that was designed for the 10% really does help the 90%.
Things like voice. Having accessibility options on your phones and on your tablets. Like I said, voice is a really good one because it's designing for different audiences and different ways of speaking. Having reduced motion like on the Animal Crossing website. I play a lot of Animal Crossing. So designing for the 10% is the same thing as designing for the 90%.
If you can help those that are on the marginalized side of things and you really put forth the effort to help these people, then you're making life easier for them and you're making life easier for the rest of us as well. You need to make sure that design should be for all parties involved. And that is the end of my presentation.
Thank you so much for all of you that joined. And now I'm going to take some time to look at the comments. I did see the one about Go Hokies and I agree. I'm going to keep saying Go Hokies until I guess I pay back my student loan. My website is here. My social media, my LinkedIn, all of these things are the same.
It's Jasmine and UX. So if you ever want to contact me, I love meeting new people. I love talking to new people. So this has been great. I'm super excited to talk about these things. Let's see. Oh, we have some people in here that were from ID to UX, Interior Design to UX. Yes. Those are like my favorites.
Oh, somebody. Oh, I'm definitely going to read this. Patricia, this seems really good. This article that you sent over. In a UX process, how do we include compassion? How can we change the design and testing? So I think how the best way we can add compassion to our UX process is to bring in those people as often as we possibly can.
A lot of times when we're having these conversations with users, we're basically trying to just get users that are our ideal user. Even if we don't call them that, that's what we're doing. We're pulling the average quote unquote person and we're having them validate the designs and the ideas that we have. A lot of times, especially at the beginning of your UX research, like the beginning discovery phase, that's the time.
And throughout is when you would pull in people of different backgrounds, people of different abilities, people of just differences. Try to think of what, who you're designing for, have it in your mind, and then try to find someone completely opposite of that. Because those are the people that you should be designing for. These are the people that need a lot of help.
And even in some ways, the conversation that I'm having right now is one filled with lots of design bias and filled with lots of design privileges. Because I'm talking about getting people to come to me and do these things. If you have the ability to go to these people and help them that way in their environment, that's the best way of doing that, I think.
Thank you, everyone who's saying that they enjoyed the presentation. That makes me very happy. Like I said, I love talking about design, so if any of you want to connect, I can talk your head off about it. Thank you. Um, someone asked where should we connect? Connect with me on LinkedIn. Um, I didn't add the Twitter icon for some reason, but you can also add me on Twitter.
Um, Instagram. Most of the time I'm pretty active on LinkedIn. So that's probably the best way for you to contact me. Um, I'm normally like on and off most social medias, but LinkedIn, I stay pretty consistent. Oh, yes, I can. I definitely can do that. Um, actually, here's one of them. Luckily, I'm doing this at home so that I can randomly pull out a book.
So Defined by Design is a wonderful book. It is so good. So, and it's really, it really gets into the thick of what it means to design for different people and what some of these, uh, design issues show up when there's a lot of bias. Um, if you live in Atlanta, I found it at the museum of, uh, design.
If you want to buy that book, but I'm sure you can buy it online. Um, and I have other resources that I am, will be happy to post on LinkedIn for everyone. Yeah. Uh, designing, uh, design principles for HR would be great. Cause I mean, your team has to be as design as diverse as the audience that you're designing.
Uh, designing for the elderly, designing for the elderly is something that should be the first thing you do. Designing for those that are older, because it's not just an accessibility thing. We're all going to get old, right? So designing for them is really important. Um, I have like five seconds left, but thank you so much, everyone. I really appreciate it.
Thank you. I appreciate it. Everyone. Please contact me on LinkedIn.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why designers need compassion, not empathy, to remove bias
Jasmine Orange explains how designing for the most marginalized 10% protects people from harm and makes products better for everyone.
In short
Jasmine Orange, a UX designer at Ernst & Young with a background in industrial design, argues that bias gets into products because designers design for an imagined average person. The people pushed to the edges, whom she calls "the 10%", pay the price, and the cost ranges from mild annoyance to real danger. Her answer is to lead with compassion rather than empathy, build diverse teams, and accept that designing for the margins makes life easier for everyone.
Key takeaways
Distinguish conscious from unconscious bias and see how each one gets into a design process.
Recognize how designing for an imagined average user can make products annoying, unusable or even deadly.
Replace empathy-only thinking with compassion by admitting you are not the user and trusting what users tell you.
Build diverse design teams that can catch the unconscious biases you cannot see in yourself.
Recruit research participants who are the opposite of your assumed user, from discovery onward.
Who the 10% really are
Orange first met the idea of designing for the 10% in industrial design school, and it has shaped how she sees patterns across physical and digital products ever since. Most people hear "the 10%" and think of the wealthy or the elite. She was taught the opposite: "But in school, I learned that the 10% are those that are actually the most marginalized." (1:01) These are the people society tends to forget, even though, as she notes, they are the ones who most need protecting.
What pushes them to the edge of designers' thinking is bias. Drawing on a definition from Georgetown University, Orange separates conscious bias, which a person knows about and acts on with intent, from unconscious bias, which people absorb from society, often across generations, and struggle even to notice. Her conclusion is simple: "And because design is a job that is primarily performed by humans. And humans naturally have biases." (2:27)
From annoying to deadly: bias in everyday design
Orange calls herself a design nerd, and her examples show how widely bias spreads. Stairs move people between levels but exclude anyone who cannot climb them. She credits the American Coalition of Citizens with Disabilities, whose sit-in and protests pushed for Section 504 of 1973, with making ramps possible. In the digital world she points to iOS 7, whose zooming, parallax and sliding animations made people with vestibular conditions sick, so Apple had to rework them.
The most personal example is the car. Orange is 5'2" and her older sister is 4'11", and both sit very close to the steering wheel. Crash test dummies are not normally made for that seating position. "A lot of times when you are shorter, you end up dying from the airbag being so close to your face and opening up so close to your face." (6:22) She also mentions that, until the Babies Act of 2016, men's restrooms in federal buildings were not required to have changing tables.
She does not blame bad intent. "It's probably that they just didn't think of these people." (7:19) The real problem, she says, is designing for an average person in a world where it is unclear what average even means.
Why empathy falls short
The most striking part of the talk goes against a core idea in UX. "But in order for us to design without bias, we have to get rid of the idea of empathy." (8:08) Empathy, by definition, means feeling what another person feels, and Orange says she simply cannot do that. She does not know what it is like to live in a different body, with different abilities or at a different height.
Research does not close the gap either. "Research can help us for a leg of it, but no amount of research is going to put you in somebody else's shoes." (9:13) Instead she argues for compassion: telling users openly that you do not have all the answers, and trusting them when they say something is difficult or wrong. She takes the familiar UX saying a step further: "A lot of times you hear, I'm not the user, but I feel like we should take that a step further. It's, I'm not that person." (10:42) In practice that means really listening, watching what people do and asking what they mean.
Design for everyone, by everyone
Orange often says that design is for everyone, and she explains that people only hear half of it. "The other half is design has to be done by everyone." (11:32) Because no one can audit their own blind spots, team diversity is the method, not an extra. "If you want to get rid of your biases, this is the way to do it because you can't check yourself for your unconscious biases." (11:59) She describes the failures in her examples as what happens when a team is not diverse, and she argues for teammates you trust to say when something does not make sense or feels offensive.
Designing for the 10% helps the 90%
Many people assume that designing for the margins leads to ugly or less useful products. Orange says it is "the complete opposite". Closed captions were designed for people who cannot hear, yet she uses them while cooking with clanking pans. A push-to-open door helps anyone carrying too much, which she calls being temporarily disabled. "And that's when having something that was designed for the 10% really does help the 90%." (13:28) Voice features and reduced motion settings, like those on the Animal Crossing website, follow the same pattern.
In the Q&A she turns this into research practice. Teams usually recruit an ideal or average user to validate ideas, but from the discovery phase onward they should invite people of different backgrounds and abilities. "Try to think of what, who you're designing for, have it in your mind, and then try to find someone completely opposite of that." (16:19) She admits that even asking people to come to the designer reflects privilege, and says going to people in their own environment is better. She also recommends designing for elderly people from the start: "We're all going to get old, right? So designing for them is really important." (18:53)
Watch the talk
Designing For The Ten Percent: How To Unbias Your Designs, by Jasmine Orange (about 20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/jasmine-orange-designing-ten-percent-how-unbias-your-designs
About the speaker
Jasmine Orange is a UX Designer at Ernst & Young, based in Atlanta, where she works on the Global Market team and cares deeply about design, diversity and creating experiences that are pleasant for all people. She is also a teaching assistant for Georgia Tech's UX bootcamp, a member of UXHelpers and IxDA, and speaks about inclusion, design history and design thinking.
Questions this talk answers
Who are the 10% in design?
Why isn't empathy enough to design without bias?
How can a team catch biases it cannot see in itself?
Does designing for marginalized users make products worse for everyone else?
How do you build compassion into a UX process?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Designing for the 10%
Conscious and unconscious bias
Resources mentioned
Defined by Design (book)
Cite this talk
Jasmine Orange. "Designing For The Ten Percent: How To Unbias Your Designs." WomenTech Network, 2020. https://www.womentech.net/video/jasmine-orange-designing-ten-percent-how-unbias-your-designs