A hand dryer that couldn't see darker skin, and the design gap behind it
An automated hand dryer that failed to detect users with darker skin made it through design and testing, a miss a more diverse room might have caught early. Elizabeth Williams, a product owner at NBCUniversal who has worked on e-commerce user journeys, argues that products can miss the mark before an idea is even conceived. So what can teams of any size do to build for as many people as possible?
Learn where inclusive design starts, from diverse teams to a first accessibility audit
Elizabeth Williams, a product owner at NBCUniversal, argues that inclusive design is a process that starts with who is in the room, long before a product exists. Using examples such as a hand dryer sensor that failed to detect darker skin, Microsoft's adaptive hardware and an AI accessibility plugin, she separates inclusive design from accessibility and recommends accessibility audits and diverse user groups as practical first steps.
“The mark can be missed well ahead of the conception of the idea.”
“It may have been picked up at an earlier stage, because it may have been a factor that would have impacted someone in the room.”
What you will learn
Distinguish inclusive design, a process for designing with diverse people, from accessible design, an outcome measured against published guidelines.
Explain why diverse perspectives at the earliest design stage catch exclusion problems like a sensor that fails on darker skin.
Start an accessibility review by checking screen reader support, font legibility and contrast in your own application.
Involve a range of users in focus groups and use third-party auditors for a more objective accessibility assessment.
Consider often overlooked users, such as older people, people with ADHD and people with little exposure to technology.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Inclusion
Design
Technology
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
18:03
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is inclusive design?
Using a CareerFoundry definition, Elizabeth describes it as making products and services accessible to and usable by as many people as reasonably possible without special adaptation or specialised design.
How is inclusive design different from accessible design?
Accessible design focuses on the outcome and is based on guidelines from governmental and industry groups. Inclusive design is a methodology, a process for creating designs that a diverse group of people can use.
Why do products keep missing the mark on inclusion?
Bias can enter as early as the selection of who builds the product, so issues are missed before the idea is even conceived. A more diverse room is more likely to spot problems that would affect someone in it.
How do you make a product accessible for many types of disability, not just one?
Elizabeth admits it is hard, but recommends running accessibility audits and involving a range of users in focus groups. Checks include whether the voiceover tool works and whether fonts and contrast are readable.
What is the most common miss she has seen?
Teams assume users already know how to use technology, which overlooks people, often older users, who have had little exposure to it because of the digital gap.
About this talk
We’ve found throughout time that many products and services fail to provide seamless usability for individuals (see Infrared gate, photo-apps, stock photos, apple watch gate and more). It’s important for both the providers of products and services to ensure the range of users that can, with satisfaction, utilise products is as broad as possible. The question is, however, how do we, as either individual entrepreneurs, small businesses, large businesses and general members of the design process ensure this?
The hand dryer that couldn't see darker skin (50 s)
Accessibility versus inclusive design, shown live (71 s)
Where to start: run an accessibility audit (52 s)
Elizabeth Williams: Right, so I'll get started. I'm Elizabeth and I'm going to be talking about inclusive design. What I'm going to try and do is go through all my slides within the first 15 minutes and then hopefully have at least five minutes for questions at the end. If there are any questions that we struggle to get in, I have left my contact details so you can drop me a message on LinkedIn and through my LinkedIn I'll be able to send my email.
Elizabeth Williams: If anyone wants to continue and engage in any further discussions surrounding inclusive design or just technology in general and yeah the focus for today is inclusive design and why it matters in technology. Elizabeth Williams: But before that, I'm going to kind of go into the definitions. There's quite a few online, but the main one I think that kind of encompasses my opinions as well. And Elizabeth Williams: And quite a range of technical scholars opinions is the underlying theme. So from career foundry. I've secured this definition, which defines inclusive design as ensuring products and or services that are accessible to and usable by as many people as reasonably possible without the need for special adaptation or specialized design.
Elizabeth Williams: So why is inclusive design necessary. And I think this really just links to the day and age is we are very technology dependent and obviously this is part of the women's tech global conference. Elizabeth Williams: There are a lot of people working in technology, but there's a lot of people also using technology and you rely on technology to produce more technology.
Elizabeth Williams: And you rely on technology and you rely on technology to learn it is a core, I guess, because they have core focus of most of most of our modern lives. Elizabeth Williams: And the digital gap is is expanding. Elizabeth Williams: As quick as our use of technology is. Elizabeth Williams: So it really comes down to basically trying to reflect the opinions and just the general like diversity of humans and ensuring that we are meeting our needs as we're producing things to satisfy our needs.
Elizabeth Williams: And I thought there was a cool quote here so this one centers three inclusive design centers accessibility and announces exclusivity reduces bias and is quoted. Elizabeth Williams: To be driven by the right team behind the design decisions and and user involvement process through use involvement in the design process. Elizabeth Williams: Which can be hard to do.
Elizabeth Williams: We've already seen quite a lot of statistics surrounding the weighting in gender when it comes to technology and who is making it and why why isn't that industry. Elizabeth Williams: As diverse as the users is a question that frequently pops up. Elizabeth Williams: And, but the truth is, there can be really large benefits of having just a diverse diverse team at the earliest stage of the design process.
Elizabeth Williams: Okay. Elizabeth Williams: So it's kind of links to what i'm saying, but essentially the result of an inclusive design processes. Elizabeth Williams: A better product design process that identifies the needs of a range of people and will satisfy the needs of a range of people. Elizabeth Williams: And we've seen there's quite a lot of popular YouTube videos about this, but I think the most notable one was.
Elizabeth Williams: The hand dryer in a bathroom. Elizabeth Williams: And a lot of hand dryer facilities now automated they just detect the sensory. Elizabeth Williams: So they detect the hands. Elizabeth Williams: And there was an issue and I said, which i've actually linked in this PowerPoint so if you do want to check it out. Elizabeth Williams: And where users with darker skin weren't being detected by the hand dryer so they'd wash their hands and they just be standing under the hand dryer wing for their hands to.
Elizabeth Williams: To be detected by it because during the Q&A process and the testing process that wasn't identified and during the design process that wasn't considered. Elizabeth Williams: If we had you know slightly more diverse range of perspectives and people in the room. Elizabeth Williams: It may have been picked up at an earlier stage, because it may have been a factor that would have impacted someone in the room.
Elizabeth Williams: Okay, so why do we keep missing the mark so bias through as early as the selection of those who produce science. Elizabeth Williams: The mark can be missed well ahead of the conception of the idea. Elizabeth Williams: So this kind of links into. Elizabeth Williams: Who are those in the room, how can we ensure that most people are well as many people as possible are engaged and it reflects modern day society where we're all different.
Elizabeth Williams: And this doesn't necessarily mean on the basis of someone's ethnic background or or gender, it encompasses quite quite a lot more than that. Elizabeth Williams: If someone has a certain disability, whatever features there are of a person. Elizabeth Williams: And it's good to have that reflected in the usability of a product, because then they have an easier time using the product and but also you go with the idea, knowing that your product has reached a wider range of people than has benefits of wider range of people.
Elizabeth Williams: So this diagram kind of covers the dimensions or the core focuses of inclusive design dimensions so. Elizabeth Williams: Inclusive designs linked to inclusive process and tools, which is diverse perspectives diverse participation accessible development tools accessible design tools. Elizabeth Williams: And then you also have recognized diversity and uniqueness and broader beneficial impact. Elizabeth Williams: Okay, so the next is inclusive design revising pre existing products and so the image here is actually from Microsoft.
Elizabeth Williams: A year ago Microsoft went back into some of their products and they try to. Elizabeth Williams: envision their products as being more accessible by having a more inclusive design process. Elizabeth Williams: So some of these products well, I guess, all of these products are pretty much digitally enhancing that these include like a mouse. Elizabeth Williams: And a track pad and these basically are tailored or created.
Elizabeth Williams: Including and considering those who may have different physical features. Elizabeth Williams: than than others or those who may have a physical disability and still do engage in you know the use of technology. Elizabeth Williams: As do most people. Elizabeth Williams: I'm at this point, but require something slightly more suited to their needs. Elizabeth Williams: So I thought this was pretty cool to look at.
Elizabeth Williams: And it's a function or a mouse that can be used by pretty much anyone but also acknowledges that we're all different and I think that's quite a good thing to see a larger company like Microsoft. Elizabeth Williams: Starting to acknowledge. Elizabeth Williams: Okay, so now i'm going to kind of link to accessibility and I know.
Elizabeth Williams: The discussions of inclusivity and accessibility kind of a bit of divisiveness around how linked they are, but I thought I can't mention one without mentioning the other. Elizabeth Williams: So in terms of examples of enhancing digital inclusivity through collaborative accessibility driven development. Elizabeth Williams: I came across this really cool thing and it was actually while I was shopping online and it's a plugin extension on the Bershka website and I'll show you what that looks like.
Elizabeth Williams: Just being cautious of time. Elizabeth Williams: I'll show you what that looks like in a second, but essentially this plugin. Elizabeth Williams: can alter using Ai can alter the way user sees the screen depending on which accessibility profile suits their needs. Elizabeth Williams: So if you have someone who has a visual related impairment, such as blindness or color blindness, they can adjust their setting and to ensure they view the website in a way that's.
Elizabeth Williams: In a way that basically suits and is adjusted to their needs, so you have some for epilepsy ADHD learning elder there's quite a few of them, but this is just a screenshot and I thought this is quite good i'll show you how this looks like. Elizabeth Williams: In one of the pages coming and but there's two key method approaches and there's two ways in which they think.
Elizabeth Williams: Accessible design focuses on the outcome or the end result of the design project is based on accessibility guidelines published by various governmental and industry groups. Elizabeth Williams: And then inclusive design is closely related to accessibility, but rather than an outcome it's methodology that helps approach design and it's a process for creating design that can be used by diverse group of people.
Elizabeth Williams: So I wanted to show this because this is actually a screencap by singing from the vertical website so this one's when I've adjusted the setting using the equality web extension. Elizabeth Williams: I've made this epilepsy compliant and you can see on the left that one's the default, but you can see there's a slight tweak and change and in the way in which the website presents itself.
Elizabeth Williams: But I think was cool here is we haven't actually changed the website whatsoever we've got the exact same website it's just the usability has extended because the amount of needs it meets now is larger things for the extension. Elizabeth Williams: cool thanks for getting involved and taking part in my discussion, do you guys have any questions I see there's a couple in the chat.
Elizabeth Williams: Oh, these are related to the screen. Elizabeth Williams: cool any questions from anyone. Elizabeth Williams: guidelines about these as in accessibility or inclusivity. Elizabeth Williams: There are quite a lot of resources. Elizabeth Williams: Sorry, just going on here. Elizabeth Williams: There are quite a lot of resources online and I use the accessibility audit. Elizabeth Williams: which is also really good and career foundry.
Elizabeth Williams: which is also quite good. Elizabeth Williams: And the plugin name. Elizabeth Williams: Sorry, one second. Elizabeth Williams: I can get to that page. Elizabeth Williams: it's equal way. Elizabeth Williams: it's equal web. Elizabeth Williams: Okay. Elizabeth Williams: Okay, there are quite a lot of resources. Elizabeth Williams: There are quite a lot of resources online. Elizabeth Williams: I use the accessibility audit.
Elizabeth Williams: Which is also really good and career foundry, which is also quite good. Elizabeth Williams: And the plugin name sorry, one second, let me get to that page. Elizabeth Williams: It's equal web. Elizabeth Williams: I believe they do contracts with with companies depending on the size, but you can get this added to. Elizabeth Williams: Definitely added to ecommerce websites.
Elizabeth Williams: So I would recommend that. Elizabeth Williams: No worries. Elizabeth Williams: Cool. Elizabeth Williams: Okay, so I did want to recommend a couple of resources. Elizabeth Williams: I can see you've still got a little bit of time. Elizabeth Williams: And I do recommend reading algorithms of oppression and the digital diaspora race for cyberspace. Elizabeth Williams: And it's quite a lot of resources online, but these are these are books that I've enjoyed and I think if you've kind of enjoyed the overall theme.
Elizabeth Williams: I definitely recommend this as well. Elizabeth Williams: And checking these out. Elizabeth Williams: And in terms of contact, do you feel free to reach out to me on linkedin. Elizabeth Williams: I've left my email address. Elizabeth Williams: Sorry, my linkedin URL. Elizabeth Williams: above. Elizabeth Williams: Cool. Elizabeth Williams: Do you guys have any more questions.
Elizabeth Williams: I believe we still have about five minutes. Elizabeth Williams: Oh sorry okay i've just i've just seen the Q amp a section. Elizabeth Williams: Thanks, Samantha. Elizabeth Williams: How do you make sure that you are making things accessible for all types of different disabilities and not just one. Elizabeth Williams: that's really hard to achieve admittedly.
Elizabeth Williams: I worked on quite a lot of user journeys in my past roles and quite a lot of e commerce. Elizabeth Williams: So that's my main remit. Elizabeth Williams: I meant ourselves now. Elizabeth Williams: But I think the common factor basically with it is you need to be running audits and you need to be ensuring that you have a range of users involved in the focus groups.
Elizabeth Williams: So if there's anywhere to start, I'd say run an accessibility audit. Elizabeth Williams: i'm assuming it's an application so on your application. Elizabeth Williams: And just double check, you know, are you able to use the voiceover tool is your font physically accessible is it dark font over a light background things like that. Elizabeth Williams: I did actually have a resource and if you add me on linkedin I will try and send that to you.
Elizabeth Williams: It looks like I can also type an answer so if i'm able to i'll try and paste it there. Elizabeth Williams: The plugin one that was equal web. Elizabeth Williams: Okay. Elizabeth Williams: And then I can see I still have a few more. Elizabeth Williams: What else would you like to see included in terms of inclusivity and websites.
Elizabeth Williams: Sure it's it sounds like a. Elizabeth Williams: bit of a cop out answer by radio pre the fact that. Elizabeth Williams: ADHD and basically. Elizabeth Williams: neuro neuro neurological. Elizabeth Williams: Ranges of features were included, because I tend to see. Elizabeth Williams: Sometimes like well I think most websites now have acknowledged that you need a dark font over light background, but.
Elizabeth Williams: You don't tend to see things. Elizabeth Williams: Catered towards elderly. Elizabeth Williams: ADHD. Elizabeth Williams: So I actually was quite happy when I saw that. Elizabeth Williams: What is the most. Elizabeth Williams: Common miss mark. Elizabeth Williams: You have seen in your experience. Elizabeth Williams: Yeah, I'd say pretty much the same. Elizabeth Williams: I'd also say.
Elizabeth Williams: it's it's it's quite difficult, but I think. Elizabeth Williams: Sometimes when we create technology, we're just thinking from it. Elizabeth Williams: Being okay, the person already knows how to use this. Elizabeth Williams: And there is a technology. Elizabeth Williams: Yeah, I actually was quite happy when I saw that. Elizabeth Williams: What is the most common miss mark you have seen in your experience.
Elizabeth Williams: Yeah, I'd say pretty much the same. Elizabeth Williams: I'd also say. Elizabeth Williams: It's it's quite difficult, but I think. Elizabeth Williams: Sometimes when we create technology, we're just thinking from it. Elizabeth Williams: Being okay, the person already knows how to use this. Elizabeth Williams: And there is a technology. Elizabeth Williams: There is a technology.
Elizabeth Williams: gap, and there are people who still haven't been able to use a computer Elizabeth Williams: yet or haven't had much exposure to technology. Elizabeth Williams: So I do think we're not very inclusive or tailored towards, you know, maybe Elizabeth Williams: the elderly who have suffered as part of that digital gap, in my opinion. Elizabeth Williams: Yeah, I mentioned accessibility audit.
Elizabeth Williams: It's not related to equal web. Elizabeth Williams: But an accessibility audit is something you can carry out internally. Elizabeth Williams: I think I found my resource from one of the Google options, but there is a specific one that I really, really liked. Elizabeth Williams: So I'll try and send that at one point. Elizabeth Williams: But essentially an accessibility audit is something you conduct when you're trying to assess how accessible your website is.
Elizabeth Williams: And typically there's a number of markers that you assess against. Elizabeth Williams: It's a lot better to have someone who's a third party, so not someone who actually works within the website space or works from that company. Elizabeth Williams: But a third party is a lot better. Elizabeth Williams: And then you can run an internal audit just to check every now and then, but definitely if you have the chance, look into accessibility audits because they do help enhance your web journeys.
Elizabeth Williams: Cool, I think that is pretty much it. Elizabeth Williams: Looks like we're just about there. Elizabeth Williams: Thank you so much for taking part and yeah, feel free to add me on LinkedIn and I'll be joining a couple of the discussions from here on out, but it's been very enjoyable. Elizabeth Williams: So thanks all.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why inclusive products start before the idea does
Elizabeth Williams explains why inclusive design is a process that begins with the team, and how an accessibility audit gives any product a practical starting point.
In short
Inclusive design matters because products that miss part of their audience usually miss it early, often before an idea is even conceived. Elizabeth Williams, a product owner at NBCUniversal, argues that the fix starts with diverse perspectives in the design process and continues with practical checks such as accessibility audits and testing with a range of users.
Key takeaways
Distinguish inclusive design, a process for designing with diverse people, from accessible design, an outcome measured against published guidelines.
Explain why diverse perspectives at the earliest design stage catch exclusion problems like a sensor that fails on darker skin.
Start an accessibility review by checking screen reader support, font legibility and contrast in your own application.
Involve a range of users in focus groups and use third-party auditors for a more objective accessibility assessment.
Consider often overlooked users, such as older people, people with ADHD and people with little exposure to technology.
What inclusive design means, and why it is urgent
Williams opens with a definition she takes from CareerFoundry: inclusive design means making products and services accessible to and usable by as many people as reasonably possible, without the need for special adaptation or specialised design. She frames the need in terms of how much modern life now runs on technology. People rely on technology to work, to learn and even to produce more technology, yet the people building it do not always reflect the people using it.
She warns that the gap is widening as fast as adoption grows: "And the digital gap is is expanding." (1:49) For Williams, inclusive design is about reflecting the real diversity of humans and making sure that what is built meets their needs. She notes that the gender imbalance in who makes technology is well documented, and points to the benefit of fixing it early: "And, but the truth is, there can be really large benefits of having just a diverse diverse team at the earliest stage of the design process." (2:53)
The hand dryer that could not see darker skin
Her central example is a widely shared one: automated hand dryers whose sensors failed to detect users with darker skin. People washed their hands and stood waiting for a dryer that never switched on. Williams points out that the problem slipped through the design process and through Q&A and testing alike.
Her diagnosis is about who was involved: "It may have been picked up at an earlier stage, because it may have been a factor that would have impacted someone in the room." (4:20)
That leads to her answer to why products keep missing the mark. Bias can enter as early as the selection of the people who produce the product. "The mark can be missed well ahead of the conception of the idea." (4:43) She stresses that diversity here goes beyond ethnicity or gender to include disability and any other feature that shapes how someone uses a product. Reflecting that range in usability makes life easier for those users and means a product reaches and benefits more people.
Williams then walks through the dimensions of inclusive design shown on her slide: inclusive processes and tools (diverse perspectives, diverse participation, accessible development and design tools), recognising diversity and uniqueness, and broader beneficial impact. She shows that inclusive design can also be applied to products that already exist.
Her example is Microsoft, which she says went back to products such as a mouse and a trackpad and redesigned them with people who have different physical features or physical disabilities in mind. She welcomes the signal this sends: "And it's a function or a mouse that can be used by pretty much anyone but also acknowledges that we're all different and I think that's quite a good thing to see a larger company like Microsoft." (7:16)
Accessibility and inclusion: outcome versus process
Acknowledging some debate about how closely the two ideas are linked, Williams separates them clearly. Accessible design focuses on the outcome and is based on accessibility guidelines published by governmental and industry groups. Inclusive design is closely related but is a methodology: a process for creating designs that a diverse group of people can use.
To show the two working together, she describes a plugin she found while shopping on the Bershka website. The EqualWeb extension uses AI to change how a user sees the page depending on the accessibility profile they choose, with options for visual impairments such as blindness or colour blindness, epilepsy, ADHD, learning needs and older users. Her screenshots compare the default page with an epilepsy-friendly version. What impresses her is that the website itself has not changed; the extension simply widens the range of needs it meets.
Where to start: audits, real users and the people left behind
In the Q&A, an attendee asks how to make things accessible for many types of disability rather than just one. Williams, who has worked on many user journeys and e-commerce projects, admits it is hard, and offers a starting point: "So if there's anywhere to start, I'd say run an accessibility audit." (14:01) That means checking whether the voiceover tool works, whether fonts are physically readable and whether dark text sits on a light background, alongside involving a range of users in focus groups.
She adds that independence matters: "It's a lot better to have someone who's a third party, so not someone who actually works within the website space or works from that company." (17:03) Internal audits are still useful for regular checks.
Asked about the most common miss she sees, Williams points to an assumption that users already know how to use technology. Many people, often older people, have had little exposure to computers, and she feels products are rarely tailored to them or to people with ADHD. For further reading she recommends Algorithms of Oppression and Digital Diaspora: A Race for Cyberspace, along with CareerFoundry's resources.
Watch the talk
Why does inclusive design matter in technology, Elizabeth Williams, 18 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/why-does-inclusive-design-matter-in-technology
About the speaker
Elizabeth Williams is a Product Owner at NBCUniversal, based in London. She studied International Relations at the University of Southampton and has long been interested in technology, design and sustainability and their impact on modern society.
Questions this talk answers
What is inclusive design?
How is inclusive design different from accessible design?
Why do products keep missing the mark on inclusion?
How do you make a product accessible for many types of disability, not just one?
What is the most common miss she has seen?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Inclusive design dimensions (inclusive process and tools, recognising diversity and uniqueness, broader beneficial impact)
Accessibility audit
Resources mentioned
Algorithms of Oppression (book)
Digital Diaspora: A Race for Cyberspace (book)
CareerFoundry
EqualWeb accessibility plugin
Accessibility audit
Cite this talk
Elizabeth Williams. "Why does inclusive design matter in technology." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/why-does-inclusive-design-matter-in-technology