BlackBerry had the better phone and still lost to the iPhone
A former BlackBerry insider recalls watching a technically superior phone lose to the iPhone because customers could no longer see why it was the best choice. The same trap catches any team that pours hundreds of hours into a product while a competitor gets all the buzz. Rickie Zayee, Senior Product Manager at Global Savings Group, asks what to fix before adding features, changing prices or chasing more capital.
Learn the positioning mistakes to avoid and three market frames for making your product stand out
Rickie Zayee, Senior Product Manager at Global Savings Group, argues that when a competitor wins the attention, the first fix is product positioning, not new features, pricing or capital. Using examples from BlackBerry, Evernote, DocSend and Revolut, the talk lists the common symptoms of poor positioning and the practical steps to fix it, then closes with three market frames of reference to choose from.
“i don't want starbucks telling me about race relations and world peace i want it to serve me a really good cup of coffee in a really pleasant location”
“And this is really where strong positioning can help make customers feel like you're the way of the future, and that choosing anyone else would be a mistake.”
What you will learn
Diagnose the symptoms of weak positioning, from inconsistent messaging to trying to appeal to everyone.
Use negative statements about what your product is not to separate it from competitors.
Interview your best customers to learn how they actually see your competition.
Craft a story and a simple promise that move the conversation from features to outcomes.
Choose between head to head, big fish smaller pond and change the game as your market frame.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Connecting your product with prospects
Understanding what Product positioning is and how to do it effectively
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career, Founder
Length
21:25
Published
June 2021
Questions this talk answers
What is product positioning?
Put simply, positioning is about context: the same product is perceived very differently depending on where and how it is presented, as violinist Joshua Bell playing on the street shows.
Why do negative positioning statements matter?
In crowded, commoditised markets, saying who you are not and what you don't do creates separation from competitors in prospects' minds.
What are the common symptoms of poor positioning?
Not being the preferred brand, struggling to express value, an inconsistent tone of voice, trying to appeal to everyone, assuming you are the sole source, selling on brand purpose and not adjusting strategy regularly.
What practical steps improve product positioning?
Tell a story, learn from your best customers, let go of existing baggage, communicate a simple promise, make positioning a team effort, change the conversation and determine who cares.
Which market frame of reference should a product choose?
Go head to head with an established leader, become a big fish in a smaller pond through sub-segmentation, or change the game by creating a new market, which is the hardest and best left until other options are exhausted.
About this talk
Positioning is the act of deliberately defining how you are the best at something that a defined market cares a lot about. If we fail at product positioning, we fail at marketing and sales. If we fail at marketing and sales then the entire business fails.
Positioning is context: the Joshua Bell test (52 s)
Why brand purpose won't sell your product (58 s)
Be a big fish in a smaller pond (79 s)
Speaker: Hi everyone. I'm Rickie. I'm one of the lead. I'm just going to actually, sorry, hold on. Sorry, is my presentation big enough for everybody? Anna? You can see my slides, yeah. Cool. Okay. We cannot see you. Oh, okay. Hold on. There we go. So yes. Thank you. So I'm going to talk to you a little bit about how I've gone in success from product positioning over the last few years. And I suppose it started with me a little bit like some of you, you know, when you spend hundreds of hours on your product, you're spending a a lot of money developing it yet, you know, despite all of our best efforts, the competitor somehow just gets all the buzz in the marketplace. So, and you know, people start to really struggle to stand out. So, you know, you, you kind of get back to the drawing board a little bit and you think, well, what, what is it that I need to do here? Do I need to change my pricing? Do I need to develop more features? Do I need more capital? But I guess, before you go back to the drawing board, it's always really good to look at product positioning.
yet you know despite all of our best efforts um the competitor somehow just gets all the buzz in the marketplace so um and you know people start to really struggle to stand out so you know you you kind of go back to the drawing board a little bit and you think well what what is it that i need to do here do i need to um change my pricing do i need to develop more features do i need more capital but i guess before you go back to the drawing board it's always really good to look at um product positioning and um and and really reconsider that first so i'd like to claim all these ideas in the presentation as my own but i'm afraid it's shameless plagiarism of um a lot of
books that i've read um a lot of events that i've attended over the years um as well as learning from you know some of the best product people um in the industry so um oh so what we're taught um so traditional positioning really revolves around positive statements so what is it that we sell who is it for how it works what are the benefits and but however as a market gets more crowded and commoditized um negative statements actually become far more valuable and because media buying now with ad agencies is pretty much a race to the bottom um companies are really having to lean lean very hard across their messaging into what they are not and what they don't do and by actively positioning yourselves in the market about who you're not and what you don't do you actually
create a lot of separation from some of your competitors in that market um and you also um you know carve out that separation as well in your prospects minds also so what is product positioning um to put it really really simply product positioning is simply about context now for those of you who don't recognize this violinist in this picture um this is joshua bell and he has a career spanning um more than 30 years um and is the one of the world's most celebrated violinists and performers but here as you can see he's nothing more than a street performer but look what happens when we change the context he goes from street performer to you know pretty much a musical genius here but oh sorry oh sorry all right
sorry but oh sorry we're just heading yeah but the product here as you can see it didn't change it's the same product but we change the cons we change the context so let's look at some common mistakes before we kind of go into you know how we really position product and i know that i've certainly made some or all of these mistakes that i'm just gonna i'm gonna quickly run run quickly through with you so you aren't considered the preferred brand if you're watching this and you are the preferred brand in your marketplace you probably don't need to kind of carry on listening to this and you could probably go and have a cup of tea but if you're not then let's go on if you recognize any of these
devices that you see in this presentation then congratulations you guys are as old as i am but blackberry used to be the number one selling smartphone in the world it was revered and it had customers that span the globe from celebrities to lawyers to kids unfortunately also to criminal gangs who loved their impenetrable and non-interceptible encryption technology on their devices but then what happened apple then came into the market and they said hey we're going to launch a phone and they took the market by storm now having worked at blackberry during this time and many years before the iphone was actually released i can tell you that blackberry was in terms of feature that the the the iphone was actually technically deficient when you compared it to the blackberry
device blackberry was the meat and potatoes of the communications world and apple was like this flimsy cotton candy type thing that would blow away in the wind you know if there was one strong enough but one of the issues is that blackberry they didn't realize what their strengths were and and where their market was until it was really too late and it became less obvious to their target market and to their existing customers um that they were the best choice um and it wasn't clear to their customers that if they went to apple what were they going to miss out on one of the other things is you struggle to express your value um you know are you confident in your team's ability to really um express your value very very clearly to the marketplace do you have a consistent
tone of voice i think hubspot actually said um that brands are that brands that consistently present themselves across the market have an average revenue increase of around 23 percent which is huge and if you promote different benefits in your data you know in in your in your ads versus your landing pages or if your brand tone changes from social media to your email communications or from mobile to web that inconsistency can actually be really really costly after all if your team isn't on the same page how do you expect your prospects to know why they should choose you and for your team to develop this new position you know you need a common understanding um of the goals and also all of the expected outcomes of your product now while having a hundred percent of your organization
aligned at all times really isn't realistic and i've never worked for a company that has been you know completely 100 aligned but a weak foundation of understanding makes position positioning for you as a product team incredibly difficult if customers don't know what they're getting and managers and your sales teams don't really know what they're selling or promoting then it's almost impossible for companies to really identify where their competitive position is here another common um another common mistake is you you try to appeal to everyone and without targeting a specific audience you risk blending in with your competition people really don't start to see kind of where you begin where they end etc etc and one of the most common mistakes that brands actually make when crafting messaging for their things like their website
for example is they try to speak to everyone um it's completely fine to sell to multiple personas and even to multiple markets and and in multiple market segments but you don't need to try and sell to every single persona in every single campaign or in every single website and if you remember a company called Evernote some of you might remember them um they were once a really promising note starting app i loved their i loved their solution and unfortunately Evernote started to drift really away from its original vision um which was a note-taking app and they started to create a whole host of other offerings that just didn't stick in the marketplace they built a chat chat app they built a recipe app they built a contact management app and it even sold like business gear um in a really ambitious kind of
e-commerce venture as well and with their attention so scattered over you know multiple messaging multiple brand you know just it was an absolute mess what they found was actually new note-taking apps like bear and also um there was one other notion um they really quickly stepped in to serve those customers that Evernote felt you know so their customers felt that Evernote weren't really delivering a solution anymore um one of the other common mistakes is you know you think you're the sole source of a product you think that you have the only solution in the marketplace and again you know customers now have control complete control over um where they choose to spend their money and you must adapt really quickly to that um social media and digital channels have given customers a way to really start to connect with each other
as um as customers but also um gather data from sources that weren't typically available to them before and they're now starting to form opinions about brands and are increasingly starting to become skeptical about messages coming directly from companies and brands so how are you engaging with your current customers and also your prospects how often do you interact with them what other sources are they using to learn and form opinions about your company and your products if you're messaging prospects and customers only when you're trying to sell to them um it's really obvious to the customer and they get turned off really really quickly when you guys do that so add value with things like high quality content and engage with comments questions and also concerns across multiple channels um including
including social media one of the big big big problems and you know i've been guilty of this before in the past as well is you're you're selling products on your brand values or purpose i mean patently the whole concept of brand purpose to me as a product manager and i'm sure there'll be lots of people who disagree with me is just moronic right i don't want starbucks telling me about race relations and world peace i want it to serve me a really good cup of coffee in a really pleasant location positioning is an active evolving process that requires constant refinement if you're not regularly adjusting your strategy and experimenting with how you market and sell you'll struggle to position yourself effectively even if historically you felt you've always been pretty well positioned
how long for example does it take you guys to adjust your messaging if you can make minor changes in days rather than waiting for your next quarterly or yearly strategy meeting then your positioning should and can change whenever you want it to and whenever you feel the need to so these are really the symptoms of poor positioning so we're going to understand a little bit about how can we effectively um you know put that product positioning into process and improving your positioning isn't straightforward as just you know coming up with a title for a blog post um but that doesn't mean there aren't some really nice concrete steps to work on it so let's just look at a few examples of how we can actually position properly the first thing i would say is tell a story
right um if dove a bar of soap can find an amazing way to tell a story of real beauty there is literally i don't believe not a brand in the world that can't find their interestingness or their sort of inner meaning and figure out how to tell their story and when you craft a compelling story you help change the conversation from comparing features and benefits to communicating the end result um that your product provides so while features and benefits are important of course they're important particularly in in the build building your product process they're easy to replicate and they don't often say anything compelling and many times you know and this is might be news to some of you the customer doesn't actually care so doc send is an example here they overhauled their product strategy and they completely moved away
from feature and benefit selling to storytelling and they saw a significant increase in their conversion identify and learn from your best customers instead of spending hours in meetings nose deep in spreadsheets looking at analytics looking at stats reach out to your best customers and find out why they chose you while it might be tempting to survey everyone your top customers often provide you with the key data so focus on them first which customers were quick to adopt your product and services which consistently refer your business customer interviews are a really good place to find out those answers and don't be afraid of them your top customers and certainly my top customers as well have provided me with insights into how they see my competition and most of the time it's drastically different from how i see my competition
and let go of your existing baggage if you've always thought of your product in one way at competing in a particular market or solving a particular problem it's hard to see it in any other way the reality is that most products can be lots of things to different types of buyers so what does your product do best you know is it simple is it easy to use is the support you offer world class internally you might have the answers to all of these questions but does your branding and messaging really communicate that to your target audience revolute which is um what we call a disruptive finance brand in the uk um they offered to simplify banking they took a mobile first approach which appealed to their target audience at the time which was young professionals and they leveraged the common
frustrations of traditional banking and they communicated their difference in a story by clearly telling you what they were not and it's you know really reap dividends for them and they're growing at a massive rate finally communicate a really simple promise what can you promise customers um if they invest in your product how can you communicate that in the simplest terms a great example is geckos 15 minutes could save you 15 on your car insurance in a single sentence they have set expectations and then they also promise value and finally make positioning a team effort positioning for products really works best when it comes ideally from different parts of your organization across different functional teams each team from sales to marketing to customer success you know can bring a really unique different viewpoint to how customers
perceive and also experience your products including all these teams in the positioning process really ensures that firstly that everyone is on the same page um and we've talked about some of the challenges of that everyone being on the same page can can really hinder but it also helps you unlock insights that may not always reach across departments for example you know maybe your customer service team have um have noticed that 15 of churn or cancellations result in a frustration with a particular feature that isn't explained very well during the sales process so your positioning affects multiple departments and every single leader of those departments should have a seat at your product table and you'll need company-wide buy-in really to reap some of those um some of those benefits
the other thing you can do is change the conversation it's tempting to really compare yourself with a competition um and we've all seen those competitive comparisons spreadsheets with the little ticks going all the way across it um but the most effective positioning really changes the conversation entirely um and there is perhaps nobody that embodies this better than um supply and um they basically sell razor blades for five to seven times the cost of a um and there is perhaps nobody that embodies this better than um supply um and um and um they basically sell razor blades for five to seven times the cost of a single razor blade and is perhaps nobody that embodies this better than supply. And they basically sell razor blades for
five to seven times the cost of a single razor blade. And their kind of way that they come into the market, the way that they position themselves, the stories that they tell is absolutely incredible. And this is really where strong positioning can help make customers feel like you're the way of the future, and that choosing anyone else would be a mistake. And then determine who cares. Okay, so once you have a good understanding of your product, what it's delivering versus other alternatives, you can then start to look at audiences that care a lot about value. But remember, even if you have some unique attributes, not all customers will feel the same way.
And then finally, is find a market frame of reference for you. And there's a lot of, there are a lot of things, but I'm just going to really talk very, very quickly, because I can see we only got a couple of minutes left on three things here. So head to head. So head to head is really where you are aiming to be the leader in a market category that already exists in the minds of customers. So there's an established market leader, and your goal is to beat them at their own game by convincing customers that you are better at delivering the solution. If you choose this way of taking your product to market, then you should be prepared to do battle against multiple competitors in this space, who will be simultaneously trying to prove that they are better than you.
The next one is big fish, smaller pond. If you're not able to compete directly with a market leader in the segment that you want to compete in, there's still a way for you to get a foothold in that market. And many startups actually use this method. And they do so successfully by simply just breaking up the market into very smaller manageable chunks. In product, we call this sub-segmentation.
So you get all the advantages of a well-defined market category without some of the stiff competition. A lot of companies do, particularly those who are a little bit more established, they do shy away from this approach because they're worried that moving from targeting the entire market to then just carving out a small sub-segment for themselves will mean less opportunity. But actually in my experience, it's completely the opposite.
You're simply unselecting those parts of the market that we're never going to buy from you anyway. And, you know, and it helps you focus on the customers who will see a clear advantage with your product. And finally, the last sort of element is change the game. And sometimes new technology or circumstances pave the way for an entirely new market.
Before you enter this strategy, though, you should probably have exhausted all other options. And because this style of positioning is very, very difficult. It can work well if your company is large and powerful and they already capture the attention of customers, media, analysts, for example. But you aren't simply capturing demand that's already here using this process. You have to really create that demand. You have to spark that interest first.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why the better product loses, and how positioning fixes it
Rickie Zayee shows why positioning, not more features or lower prices, is the first thing to fix when a competitor wins the market's attention.
In short
When a competitor gets all the buzz despite your best efforts, Rickie Zayee argues the first thing to revisit is product positioning, not pricing, features or capital. Drawing on time at BlackBerry and examples from Evernote, DocSend and Revolut, the talk names the symptoms of weak positioning, offers practical steps to fix it, and closes with three ways to choose a market frame of reference.
Key takeaways
Connecting your product with prospects
Understanding what product positioning is and how to do it effectively
Positioning comes before the drawing board
Zayee opens with a familiar scenario: a team spends hundreds of hours and a lot of money building a product, yet a competitor somehow captures the attention of the market. The natural reaction is to ask whether the answer is new pricing, more features or more capital. Zayee suggests pausing first: "But I guess, before you go back to the drawing board, it's always really good to look at product positioning." (0:00)
Zayee is open that the ideas come from books, events and the best product people in the industry. Traditional positioning relies on positive statements: what we sell, who it is for, how it works and what the benefits are. In crowded, commoditised markets, though, negative statements become more valuable. By saying clearly who you are not and what you don't do, a company creates separation from competitors in prospects' minds.
To show what positioning really is, Zayee uses the image of Joshua Bell, one of the world's most celebrated violinists, playing as a street performer. Change the setting and he becomes a musical genius, though the product never changed. In Zayee's words, "to put it really really simply product positioning is simply about context" (2:34).
The symptoms of poor positioning
Zayee walks through common mistakes, admitting to having made some or all of them. The first is not being the preferred brand. BlackBerry was once the number one selling smartphone in the world, and Zayee, who worked there before and during the iPhone launch, says the iPhone was technically deficient by comparison. The problem was that BlackBerry did not realise where its strengths and market lay until it was too late, and customers could not see what they would miss by switching.
Other symptoms follow. Teams struggle to express their value and lack a consistent tone of voice; Zayee cites HubSpot, as the speaker cited, on brands that present themselves consistently seeing an average revenue increase of around 23 percent. Companies try to appeal to everyone, as Evernote did when it drifted from note-taking into chat, recipes, contact management and e-commerce, leaving room for apps like Bear and Notion. Some assume they are the only solution, while customers now gather opinions from many sources and grow skeptical of brand messaging.
Zayee is blunt about selling on brand purpose: "i don't want starbucks telling me about race relations and world peace i want it to serve me a really good cup of coffee in a really pleasant location" (10:40). The final symptom is treating positioning as fixed, because "positioning is an active evolving process that requires constant refinement" (10:40). Teams that can adjust messaging in days, rather than waiting for a quarterly strategy meeting, can reposition whenever they need to.
Practical steps to position effectively
The first step is to tell a story. If Dove, a bar of soap, can tell a story of real beauty, Zayee believes any brand can find its own. Features and benefits matter while building a product, but they are easy to replicate and often fail to say anything compelling. DocSend, Zayee notes, moved from feature and benefit selling to storytelling and saw a significant increase in conversion.
Next, learn from your best customers rather than burying yourself in spreadsheets. Ask who adopted quickly and who refers you, and interview them. As Zayee puts it, "your top customers and certainly my top customers as well have provided me with insights into how they see my competition and most of the time it's drastically different from how i see my competition" (13:33).
Teams should also let go of existing baggage about what their product is for. Revolut took a mobile-first approach for young professionals and told a story about what it was not, built on frustrations with traditional banking. A simple promise helps too: Zayee points to GEICO's single sentence about 15 minutes and car insurance, which sets expectations and promises value at once. Finally, positioning should be a team effort, with sales, marketing and customer success all bringing their view of how customers experience the product, and every department leader holding a seat at the product table.
Change the conversation and choose your frame
Rather than filling comparison spreadsheets with ticks, the strongest positioning changes the conversation entirely. Zayee highlights Supply, which sells razor blades for five to seven times the cost of a single blade through the stories it tells: "And this is really where strong positioning can help make customers feel like you're the way of the future, and that choosing anyone else would be a mistake." (17:44) From there, teams should determine who cares, remembering that not every customer values the same attributes.
The talk ends with three market frames of reference. Head to head means trying to beat an established leader at its own game, and preparing to battle several competitors. Big fish, smaller pond means sub-segmenting the market to gain a foothold, an approach many established companies avoid for fear of losing opportunity. Zayee's experience is the opposite: "You're simply unselecting those parts of the market that we're never going to buy from you anyway." (20:20) Change the game, creating an entirely new market, is the hardest route, best left until other options are exhausted, because it requires creating demand rather than capturing it.
Watch the talk
How to effectively position your product, Rickie Zayee, 21 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-effectively-position-your-product
About the speaker
Rickie Zayee is a Senior Product Manager at Global Savings Group, based in Cambridge, United Kingdom. Zayee loves that building products never stands still and finds no greater reward than making product decisions that delight, engage and retain customers.
Questions this talk answers
What is product positioning?
Why do negative positioning statements matter?
What are the common symptoms of poor positioning?
What practical steps improve product positioning?
Which market frame of reference should a product choose?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Negative positioning
Market frame of reference: head to head, big fish smaller pond, change the game
Sub-segmentation
Cite this talk
Rickie Zayee. "How to effectively position your product." WomenTech Network, 2021. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-effectively-position-your-product