In short
As third-party cookies disappear and privacy rules tighten, Manasa Denning, Senior Director of Partner Solutions at Integral Ad Science, argues that contextual targeting is the strongest way for marketers to keep reaching the right people. Drawing on consumer research, she shows that ads aligned with the content around them, including its emotional sentiment, are remembered longer and viewed more favorably, even next to negative news.
Key takeaways
- Align with contextually relevant content: contextual targeting delivers buyers unprecedented precision for targeting content that is contextually relevant for a given brand or campaign, to increase recognition, engagement and favorability.
Consumers want privacy and relevance at the same time
Denning opens with a simple definition. Context control, she explains, is about precisely understanding the content surrounding an ad in order to reach the ideal audience. The shift, in her view, is driven by consumers themselves. People are spending more time online, they know more time online means more data collected about them, and many are uncomfortable with hyper-targeting.
"Consumers want privacy and relevant information when browsing the internet." (1:56)
She cites figures from the slides (as the speaker cited): almost three-quarters of consumers say it is important for ads to be personally relevant, over half hold brands accountable for the content that appears next to their ads, and half are likely to engage with ads found alongside high-quality content. Combined with GDPR, CCPA and Chrome's planned 2022 cookie deadline, she says, the industry consensus is that cookie-based behavioral targeting will shrink and contextual targeting will return as an essential approach.
Topic is not enough: sentiment matters too
One of the talk's central points is that matching an ad to a page's subject is only the start. Denning asks the audience to imagine technology that reads a page like a human and understands the nuances of its emotional tone.
"The sentiment of a page can have a huge impact on how customers perceive your ad adjacency." (4:10)
Her example is a BMW 7 Series ad built around relaxation, luxury and comfort. Because the goal is to evoke those feelings, she suggests such an ad could be placed entirely outside automotive content, next to any content that creates the same mood. She recalls seeing the ad while reading luxury content on a premium website, and wondering whether she would have clicked if the surrounding content had felt different.
She then reports that consumers consistently preferred contextual relevance across verticals. As the speaker cited, 79% preferred entertainment ads on entertainment articles and 78% preferred financial services ads next to investing content, much like a full-page car ad that belongs in an auto magazine rather than a parenting one.
Losing the cookie and finding the mindset
Denning sets out what is changing for marketers. With the deprecation of cookies and the weakening of identifiers for advertisers such as IDFA, behavioral targeting based on past purchases, browsing and search history becomes difficult. A marketer can no longer see which websites a person visited. She notes that marketers named the loss of the third-party cookie as a global media challenge in 2021, and that 82% of people in the industry agree contextual targeting will gain favor as consumers regain control over their data (as the speaker cited).
"Targeting the right creative to match the right content personalizes the experience for consumers and helps marketers find consumers in the right mindset." (9:44)
To make it concrete, she shows two travel articles, one on hiking trails near New York City and one on American road trips. Both, she says, are natural homes for ads about airline tickets, family holidays, outdoor activities and credit cards, because they already put the reader in a getaway mood.
The congruence effect, even beside bad news
Integral Ad Science commissioned an online survey to test how ads perform beside content with positive, negative and neutral sentiment. Denning describes the congruence effect as the relationship between the message of an ad and the content surrounding it. As the speaker cited, 74% of consumers said they are likely to remember an ad if its message relates to the content around it, and ads were found more favorable beside content rich in positive and neutral sentiment.
The harder question is negative news, which brands cannot simply skip.
"It is unrealistic for brands to avoid all content with negative sentiment." (12:42)
In the test, consumers saw an article about a pedestrian struck and killed by a car alongside two ads: one for a new car with pedestrian detection, and a generic one about trunk space. Consumers preferred the first, finding it more receptive, favorable and memorable because its message aligned with the article.
"Consumers don't expect brands to stop advertising but recognize when brands appear in suitable environments. Context matters." (14:17)
Three trends to act on
Denning closes with three trends. First, third-party cookie deprecation, identified as the top challenge for marketers trying to reach their ideal consumers. Second, contextual targeting as the new proxy for reaching that audience while giving consumers more control over their data; she cites that 72% of consumers say their perception of an online ad is affected by the content surrounding it. Third, aligning ads with contextually relevant content, which she reports boosts attention by 107% (as the speaker cited).
Watch the talk
"To be effective, marketers must align their campaigns with contextually relevant ads" by Manasa Denning, about 17 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/be-effective-marketers-must-align-their-campaigns-contextually-relevant-ads
About the speaker
Manasa Denning is Senior Director, Partner Solutions NAM & APAC at Integral Ad Science (IAS), which she joined in 2015, where she keeps global product teams informed about developing markets and helps influence product launch decisions in the region. She works with the demand side and supply side to help partners understand their data and attribution modeling, and before IAS she worked with a search agency and with Toshiba in Australia.
Questions this talk answers
- What is contextual targeting?
- Why is contextual targeting gaining importance now?
- Does the sentiment of a page affect how an ad is perceived?
- Should brands avoid negative news content?
- What is the congruence effect?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.