Who Gets to Decide What's Fair? Exploring Bias in Algorithmic Decision-Making

Powered by AI and the women in tech community.

Algorithm designers shape fairness in decision-making by embedding biases and adhering to ethical guidelines. Data scientists influence fairness through data selection, while regulatory bodies enforce legal fairness standards. Ethical review boards and third-party auditors provide oversight beyond legalities. Users and affected individuals offer crucial feedback on fairness perceptions. The media, academic researchers, and professional associations impact fairness norms, while international standards organizations set global fairness benchmarks in algorithms.

Algorithm designers shape fairness in decision-making by embedding biases and adhering to ethical guidelines. Data scientists influence fairness through data selection, while regulatory bodies enforce legal fairness standards. Ethical review boards and third-party auditors provide oversight beyond legalities. Users and affected individuals offer crucial feedback on fairness perceptions. The media, academic researchers, and professional associations impact fairness norms, while international standards organizations set global fairness benchmarks in algorithms.

Contribute to three or more articles across any domain to qualify for the Contributor badge. Please check back tomorrow for updates on your progress.

Contribute to three or more articles across any domain to qualify for the Contributor badge. Please check back tomorrow for updates on your progress.

The Role of Algorithm Designers

In the context of algorithmic decision-making, the initial shaping of what’s considered fair often rests on the shoulders of the algorithm designers. These individuals or teams decide the variables and rules that the algorithm follows, inadvertently embedding their biases, perspectives, and understanding of fairness into the system. However, their control is not absolute as they must navigate ethical guidelines, legal requirements, and societal expectations.

Add your perspective

Influence of Data Scientists

Data scientists play a pivotal role in determining fairness within algorithms by selecting and processing the data these algorithms are trained on. Their decisions on data sources, handling of biases in the data, and the weighting of different data points can significantly influence the algorithm's outcomes, potentially reflecting their subjective notion of fairness.

Add your perspective

Regulatory Bodies and Legal Frameworks

Governmental and regulatory bodies have the authority to define and enforce legal standards of fairness in algorithmic decision-making. Through legislation and policy-making, these entities set boundaries within which algorithms must operate, aiming to protect individuals from discrimination or unfair treatment. Their decisions often reflect a societal consensus on what constitutes fair and unbiased decisions.

Add your perspective

Ethical Review Boards

Ethical review boards, often found within organizations or as independent entities, assess algorithms and their deployment from an ethical standpoint. Their insights help ensure that algorithmic decisions do not violate ethical norms, providing a layer of oversight on what is considered fair, beyond legal requirements.

Add your perspective

Users and Affected Individuals

Ultimately, the perceptions of fairness from those impacted by algorithmic decisions cannot be overlooked. Users and individuals subjected to these decisions are vital in critiquing and providing feedback on the fairness of algorithms. Their experiences and objections can inform adjustments and reforms, pushing for a more inclusive understanding of fairness.

Add your perspective

Third-Party Auditors

Independent third-party auditors are increasingly being called upon to evaluate the fairness of algorithms. Their role involves assessing the algorithms’ compliance with stated fairness criteria, transparency standards, and ethical norms. These auditors act as neutral parties, providing an objective viewpoint on the fairness of algorithmic decision-making processes.

Add your perspective

The Media and Public Opinion

The media and public opinion also play a role in shaping perceptions of fairness in algorithmic decision-making. Investigative reports, media coverage, and public discourse can highlight fairness issues, influencing public opinion, and prompting organizations to revisit and revise their algorithms. This external pressure serves as a checks-and-balances mechanism, promoting transparency and accountability.

Add your perspective

Academic Researchers

Academics in fields such as computer science, ethics, and law continually explore the intricacies of fairness in algorithms. Their research contributes to the development of new theoretical frameworks and practical approaches to measuring and achieving fairness. This body of work influences both the creation of algorithms and the policies governing them.

Add your perspective

Professional and Industry Associations

Professional associations and industry groups develop standards and best practices for their members, including guidelines on ethical algorithm design and fair decision-making processes. Their influence shapes industry norms, encouraging a collective movement towards fairer algorithmic practices.

Add your perspective

International Standards Organizations

Global standards organizations, like the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), play a crucial role in setting international benchmarks for fairness, transparency, and ethics in technology, including algorithmic decision-making. These standards help harmonize principles of fairness across borders, promoting a global approach to addressing biases in algorithms.

Add your perspective

What else to take into account

This section is for sharing any additional examples, stories, or insights that do not fit into previous sections. Is there anything else you'd like to add?

Add your perspective

Identifying and Addressing Bias

Want to contribute ? We select experts based on their experience and skills.

Learn more about becoming a contributor.

Rate this article

More articles on Identifying and Addressing Bias

See all

More relevant reading

Inclusive Leadership Training
How Can Organizations Benefit from Fostering Inclusive Leadership Among Women in Tech?
Bias in Hiring Practices
What Role Does Organizational Culture Play in Perpetuating Hiring Bias?
Gender Bias in Tech
How Can Tech Education Become More Inclusive for Women?
Cultural Competence Training
Why Is Cultural Competence Crucial for Women Advancing in Technology Fields?